I would like to address a couple of the issues mentioned here. I have some experience on both sides of the fence.
As a young woman married to a military officer we were posted to Germany, and moved to a village near Nurnberg with our two small children. My husband eventually took a European discharge and we continued to live in Germany for another three years, our children went to German schools, I had a son born in a German Hospital who was very premature and required hospitalization for two months at a special children's neonatal center all at no cost to ourselves. We therefore utilized socialistic medicine, and did not pay German taxes. We both were working, my husband for an American Company selling to the P X's and I worked for American Express, so we paid the American taxes necessary but not German. He was transferred to England-more socialized medicine-and I was not allowed to work because I had no work permit. We divorced, and I remained in England for another three years, during which time I worked very hard for room and board for myself and my children, but received no wages. If I wanted some cash to buy us something other than the basics provided I would sell something that I had. Don't get me wrong, I enjoyed my time there but was never allowed to obtain a work permit and eventually decided that I needed to come back to America and raise my children as Americans. The issue of not paying for medical expenses came up in both countries because we felt we should pay something, but both local governments said that their system was not set up to take such payments. When I first returned to America I immediately found a job but had absolutely no insurance. I applied to welfare just so that my children would have insurance in case of an accident until I was eligible for my jobs insurance which at that time was a wait of six months. In 1971 that required allowing welfare officers to come in my home at any time they so desired to make sure I was not harboring any other adults that could be bringing any income into the home. During those six months they visited at least three times at different hours of the day without any prior notice. I was very very glad when my insurance took effect and I dropped welfare. I never needed the medical insurance that we had applied for, but I was glad that it was available. Fast forward to 1990, I broke my neck. We had insurance, and we just had to pay the 20% out of pocket which took us close to five years to pay off. The wheelchair eventually destroyed our marriage and for the next two years I was able to keep insurance by paying Cobra, but then.ran out of benefits. Because I had worked for the state government and had not paid Social Security for the entire time I was working but instead paid into the state benefits program, I was two quarters short to apply for disability benefits when I broke my neck. Therefore, according to the government, I was not disabled nor did I ever receive any disability benefits, and now I had no Health Insurance and was a C4 quad. I was a contractor to the state but had no benefits through the state, so I was able to get into a general clinic where I paid on a sliding scale. I was eligible for only basic care and paid $95.00 per visit. I was usually the only non Hispanic person in the waiting room, and I would watch Hispanic families with 4 or 5 children change receive medical treatment and not have to pay anything. I would also watch the same Hispanics go outside and get into an Suv that was much nicer and much newer than anything I could afford. The next seven years I paid for all of my medical treatment out of pocket, including one hospitalization for a major infection that came to $30,000. Dollar down and a dollar a week was my model J. But I did eventually paid for everything, and I was a happy camper when I was able to get on Medicare on my 65th birthday. I came into Medicare as a total C4 quad, had my own wheelchair that I had bought out of pocket, and soon found that although I had Medicare that they would not take care of my chair unless they bought me a new one-and since I was very happy with my chair I opted to pay for its maintenance by myself rather than have to have the chair that they dictated I qualified for, and then still pay the 20% or what ever percentage I would have to pay. 5 and 1/2 years later I am still paying for maintenance on my chair which has averaged me $1200 a year, and I am not ready to give it up for another chair that is less than adequate. When it breaks down we order parts directly from the company and depending upon what it is I have someone fix it. Because our DME here in Reno sucks, we usually take it to a DME about 50 miles away, or a friend will fix it. Now that I have rambled on for far too long, what is my message? I suppose it is that we always need to look at both sides of the story. Was it fair that I received socialized medicine without paying a penny or a half pence for the excellent Medical Care I received? Was it fair that I had to pay out of pocket for seven years because I was not disabled according to the government, and was not able to obtain insurance on my own? Is it fair that I have to pay out of pocket to have repairs made on my wheelchair because I do not want to accept a less reliable wheelchair? The answers to all of the questions probably depend on what side of the fence you're standing on. There is no real clear answer. Do I feel that the illegal immigrants here in America should get better care than those Americans who are uninsured, no. I do know that the entire time I was in Europe I tried to pay my way and was turned down by the government's involved, but that I did receive excellent care. But getting down to nuts and bolts I receive my health care for free. So where does wrong end and right began? Excellent question. Joan What you do for yourself dies with you. What you do for others, lives forever.

