Compliance Test results for Quagga Mainline
-------------------------------------------
(based on latest Git commit 1c6db0d from January 6, 2015)

For a complete testreport, see 
http://www.opensourcerouting.org/compliance-test-results/


Below is the summary of the recent new failures.
If you plan to look at a specific bug and need more information,
then please feel free to ask.

Regards,
   Martin Winter
   OpenSourceRouting.org / (part of NetDEF)


==================================

Test: ANVL-BGPPLUS-15.14  (BGP IPv6)

Reference: RFC 4271, Sect. 5, p 23, Path Attributes
Class:   MUST
Summary: Path Attributes
         The sender of an UPDATE message should order path attributes within
         the UPDATE message in ascending order of attribute type.
         The receiver of an UPDATE message MUST be prepared to handle path
         attributes within the UPDATE message that are out of order.

Problem: Quagga does not put the attributes in ascending order
Fails since 0.99.23 - last released version is 0.99.22

==================================

Test: ANVL-ISIS-2.4  (ISIS IPv4, Level-1)
Test: ANVL-ISIS-2.14  (ISIS IPv4, Level-2)

Reference: ISO/IEC 10589:1992(E) s9.8 p54-55 Level 1 Link State PDU
           RFC 1195 s5.3.4, p40-43 Level 1 Link State PDU
Reference: ISO/IEC 10589:1992(E) s9.9 p57-59 Level 2 Link State PDU
           RFC 1195 s5.3.5,p43-48 Level 2 Link State PDU
Class:   MUST
Summary: Link State PDU
         The valid codes that must be present in the VARIABLE LENGTH FIELD
          of level 1 link state PDU are:
           Area Addresses
           Intermediate system Neighbors
           Protocols Supported
           IP Interface Address
           IP internal Reachability Information

Problem: Level 1 Link State Packet incorrectly does not contain Intermediate 
         System Neighbours CLV  (1)
Worked in last released version (0.99.23.1), fails in current Quagga Git Master

ANVL-ISIS-2.14 is same issue for ISIS Level-2 and fails the same way

==================================

Test: ANVL-ISIS-17.4  (ISIS IPv4, Level-1)
Test: ANVL-ISIS-17.10  (ISIS IPv4, Level-2)

Reference: RFC 1195 s5.3.4 P42 Level 1 Link State PDU
Reference: RFC 1195 s5.3.4 P45 Level 2 Link State PDU
Class:   MUST
Summary: Type of Service Routing
         Bit 7 of DEFAULT METRIC field (marked I/E) must be set to zero
         indicating internal metric

Problem: Received Level 1 Link State Packet without IS Neighbours' field
Worked in last released version (0.99.23.1), fails in current Quagga Git Master

ANVL-ISIS-17.10 is same issue for ISIS Level-2 and fails the same way

==================================

Test: ANVL-OSPFV3-6.32 (OSPFv3 IPv6)

Reference: RFC 5340, s4 p13 Implementation details
           RFC 2328, s9.3 p73 The Interface state machine
Class:   MUST
Summary: Implementation Details
         When router is in Waiting state, if WaitTimer event fires
         then router calculates the attached network"s Backup
         Designated Router and Designated Router

Problem: Designated and Backup Designated Router ID field in received hello 
packet
are incorrectly set
Worked in last released version (0.99.23.1), fails in current Quagga Git Master,
but was unreliable in previous versions. Potentially a test setup problem.

==================================

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: Message signed with OpenPGP using GPGMail

_______________________________________________
Quagga-dev mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.quagga.net/mailman/listinfo/quagga-dev

Reply via email to