Dear Timo, Quagga dev-list,

Every time there is a new protocol implemented in Quagga it will give some
(hopefully small) issues. Nothing wrong with that, and they will be fixed.

With NHRP this is no different.
There is the OpenNHRP implementation and as of writing it's project page (
http://sourceforge.net/projects/opennhrp/ ) reports 18 downloads in the
past week.
If one takes a look at Cisco's NHRP pages the latest update is from April
2007.

OpenNHRP gets 5 stars from 4 reviewers (with one very strange one).

The only use of this technology is for VPNs. Cisco mentions it works with
FR and ATM, but if one uses PVCs, than bypassing the hub for traffic will
not be possible.

To me there is no use in having NHRP being part of Quagga and with OpenNHRP
the functionality can be set up.

My vote: -1

Timo, please continue with your great work.

Viva Quagga!


Regards,

Han Coumans
_______________________________________________
Quagga-dev mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.quagga.net/mailman/listinfo/quagga-dev

Reply via email to