-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA512


Jean-Philippe Ouellet:
> Maybe one could imagine a scenario where some court-order is issued
> to create fake future canaries to be released by law enforcement at
> a future date. If this order is appealed and the decision reversed,
> then the fake-future canaries without proof-of-freshness are 
> indistinguishable from real-future canaries, whereas with 
> proof-of-freshness you could at least tell the difference?
> 

Yes! This is a good case to prove that the proof of freshness can be
still useful.

> IANAL, but there seems to at least be at least *some* (contrived) 
> scenario in which it might be marginally useful.

I agree. I also came up with some other scenarios where the proof of
freshness may also be useful. I will share them with you all once the
thoughts are mature enough.

> Since there's virtually no cost or risk to including it... why
> not?
> 

Thank you very much for your help!

Best,
iry
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
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=Em1f
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

-- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"qubes-devel" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email 
to [email protected].
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
To view this discussion on the web visit 
https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/qubes-devel/73c8d6ae-0a80-c68e-2e08-789ac59426ac%40riseup.net.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.

Reply via email to