Hi Ivan,
On 2/26/10 6:30 AM, Ivan Calandra wrote:
You are definitely right...
What to do with bad beginner's questions is not a simple issue.
If a "beginner's mailing list" is created, who will answer to such
questions?
If I subscribe to the beginners mailing list, then I have to expect
novice questions and I should be willing to help. Otherwise, I should
not be there.
And moreover, the beginners won't take advantage of the other
questions (I've personally learned a lot trying to understand the
questions and answers to other's problems).
They can still subscribe to the advanced, but they will know that they
are here to observe and learn, not to ask novice questions. You want to
ask basic stuff, go to the beginners list :)
Not sure if you guys have been on some of the linux mailing lists out
there, but man let me tell you, some of these lists have a RTFM attitude
and they will fry you if you ask novice questions. Frankly, that is
understandable, as most of the members are geeks and they have higher
expectations. This mailing list is different, I have seen posts from
different disciplines; biology, biostats, stats, computer science,
oceanography, etc. So, IMO, there should be a beginners list to cope
with such broad committee.
Thanks,
Saeed
And also, as you said, the
problems might persist.
The beginner's mailing list might be good in one aspect though: the
"experts" who subscribe to it would be willing to help the beginners to
get started with R, knowing that the questions might not be clearly stated.
As you pointed out, the mailing list is not the best for basic stuff
(the question is of course "what is basic?"). Not everybody knows some
colleagues who work with R (I'm personally the 1st one to use R in my lab).
I think, somehow and I have no idea how, documentation and guidance to
search for help should be more accessible as soon as you start with R.
Maybe a _*clear*_ section on the R homepage or in the "introduction to
R" manual like "where to find help", including all of the most common
and useful resources available (from "?" and RSiteSearch() to R Wiki and
Crantastic).
I hope that this whole discussion might help to make the R world better.
Thank you Patrick for initiating it!
Regards,
Ivan
Le 2/26/2010 15:09, Paul Hiemstra a écrit :
Ivan Calandra wrote:
Since you want input from beginners, here are some thoughts
I had and still have two big problems with R:
- this vectorization thing. I've read many manuals (including R
inferno), but I'm still not completely clear about it. In simple
examples, it's fine. But when it gets a bit more complex, then...
Related to it, the *apply functions are still a bit difficult to
understand. When I have to use them, I just try one and see what
happens. I don't understand them well enough to know which one I need.
- the second problem is where to find the functions/packages I need.
There are many options, and that's actually the problem. R Wiki,
Rseek, RSiteSearch, Crantastic, etc... When you start with R, you
discover that the capabilities of R are almost unlimited and you
don't really know where to start, where to find what you need.
As noted in earlier posts, the mailing list is really great, but some
people are really hard with beginners. It was noted in a discussion a
few days ago, but it looks like some don't realize how difficult it
is at the beginning to formulate a good question, clear, with
self-contained example and so on. Moreover, not everybody speaks
English natively. I don't mean that you must help, even when the
question is really vague and not clear and whatever. I'm just saying
that if you don't want to help (whatever the reason), you don't have
to say it badly. But in any cases, the mailing list is still really
helpful. As someone noted (sorry I erased the email so I don't
remember who), it might be a good idea to split it.
Hi everyone,
My 2ct about the mailing list :). I understand that beginners have a
hard time formulating a good question. But the problem is that we
can't answer the question when it is unclear. So either I:
- Don't bother answering
- Try do discuss with the author of the question, taking lots of time
to find out what exactly is the question.
- Send a "read the posting guide" answer
I mostly do the first, as I have to get things done during my PhD :).
So this leaves us with kind of a problem, the person mailing the list
doesn't have the knowledge to ask the right question, the list can't
answer properly and consequently, the person mailing the list still
doesn't get the information he/she needs. We could start an R-beginner
mailing list, but this would also suffer from this problem. What do
you guys think?
Maybe the mailing list is not the right medium for really basic stuff.
For that I would recommend a good R-book or (better) a course in R or
(even better) some colleagues who work with R that you can ask
questions to.
cheers,
Paul
Hope that's what you wanted
Ivan
Le 2/26/2010 08:39, Dieter Menne a écrit :
Patrick Burns wrote:
* What were your biggest misconceptions or
stumbling blocks to getting up and running
with R?
(This derives partly from teaching)
The fact that this xapply-stuff was not idempotent (worse: not
always) and
that you need a monster like do.call() to straighten this out.
Nowadays,
plyr comes close.
The concept of environment. With S it was worse, though.
That you cannot change values "passed by reference". I noted that
the latter
is no problem for students who have not worked with c(++/#) before.
That
there is only one return-result in functions.
"[" and the likes as an operator.
10 years ago, when I started, the message was: S4 is the future, S3 is
legacy. So I learned S4. Only to never use is in self-written code
later.
Might be different for BioConductor people.
That sometimes you can use vectors not in data= (lattice), and
sometimes not
(ggplot2). Still a VERY confusing inconsistency.
The "why-does-this-not-print" FAQ.
Why does par(oma..) not work with lattice?
Dieter
______________________________________________
R-help@r-project.org mailing list
https://stat.ethz.ch/mailman/listinfo/r-help
PLEASE do read the posting guide
http://www.R-project.org/posting-guide.html
and provide commented, minimal, self-contained, reproducible code.
[[alternative HTML version deleted]]
______________________________________________
R-help@r-project.org mailing list
https://stat.ethz.ch/mailman/listinfo/r-help
PLEASE do read the posting guide http://www.R-project.org/posting-guide.html
and provide commented, minimal, self-contained, reproducible code.
______________________________________________
R-help@r-project.org mailing list
https://stat.ethz.ch/mailman/listinfo/r-help
PLEASE do read the posting guide http://www.R-project.org/posting-guide.html
and provide commented, minimal, self-contained, reproducible code.
