Hello Wouter et al, I have plenty to say about all aspects of this. Currently at SAMSI we are discussing similar topics in a subgroup of a spatial stat comp working group... http://sisla06.samsi.info/spatial/comp/doku.php
My feature list for spt is growing exponentially lately for spt related things. I welcome any and all interested in working on such a library. I spent a large amount of time reading up on different date/time libraries, their differences, their inheritances, etc. I'm happy for you to bounce any ideas off me about what your constraints are (eg data structure sizes, data structure processing times, vizualization needs, etc) I have been out of the R realm lately, working more with python+gis+statistical modeling code, as well as with building a geocoded data collection sensor (arduino + gps + sensor(s) of choice + sd card). I'm trying to gather some microclimate data and fit some models (just a personal side project, but has some useful applications). If you have some very specific needs, I may already have the alpha/beta classes/methods working. Please contact me offline (or via the listserve) with any specific needs/questions/comments. If you can write up some clear use cases/methods/classes you want, I could probably put them together within a week or two... Just let me know. Best, Blair In response to: Dear Wouter, as to your question on related work, Blair Christian has started two threads on this list: https://stat.ethz.ch/pipermail/r-sig-geo/2009-September/006435.html https://stat.ethz.ch/pipermail/r-sig-geo/2009-September/006491.html and the resulting work is now at r-forge, called spt, see http://r-forge.r-project.org/projects/spt it is a mix of classes and methods for spatio-temporal data and functions that are needed for his particular research domain. It has a vignette. For the two suggestions you make I cannot say much; if you have running prototypes I'd be happy to look at them. Simply adding an sp object to a time series (as attribute) [or a set of time stamps to an sp object] means that you'll sacrifice the multi-atribute space for multiple spatial entities [time entities], so your objects become univariable. That might only work as a short-term solution; next time you'll want to work with water chemistry data. Best regards, -- Edzer Wouter Buytaert wrote: > > Hi all, > > this question is mainly aimed at the developers of sp, but any feedback > is welcome. > > We are designing some classes for hydrological modelling in R (the > r-hydro package on R-Forge) and facing the decision of how to design a > class for georeferenced time series (e.g., a precipitation or river flow > series, the first referring to a point and the second to an area). > > We're considering an xts time series with an sp object as attribute, but > there may be other options (xts as data slot in an sp object for > instance) that may be preferrable for reasons beyond my knowledge. Also, > there may be similar efforts underway of which we have no knowledge. > > cheers > wouter _______________________________________________ R-sig-Geo mailing list R-sig-Geo@stat.math.ethz.ch https://stat.ethz.ch/mailman/listinfo/r-sig-geo
