Title: WSJ.com - Best of the Web Today Mail HTML - 1 colmn
The trouble with Romney.

David

ORourke1 Signature
"Anyone who thinks he has a better idea of what's good for people than people do is a swine."--P. J. O’Rourke


-------- Original Message --------
Subject: Best of the Web Today - October 19, 2011
Date: Wed, 19 Oct 2011 16:45:05 -0400
From: WSJ.com Editors <[email protected]>
Reply-To: [email protected]
To: [email protected]


WSJ.com - Best of the Web Today Mail HTML - 1 colmn
The Wall Street Journal Online - Best of the
                      the Web Today Email
  Online Journal E-Mail Center   




October 19, 2011 -- 4:40 p.m. EDT
See all of today's editorials and op-eds, video interviews and commentary on Opinion Journal.

VIEW TODAY'S FULL COLUMN

FORMAT THIS COLUMN FOR PRINTING

ObamaCare's Heritage

The think tank, the individual mandate and the trouble with Romney.
By JAMES TARANTO
advertisement
Advertisement

At last night's CNN debate, Mitt Romney and Newt Gingrich sparred over the paternity of the illegitimate child eventually adopted by Barack Obama:

Romney: Actually, Newt, we got the idea of an individual mandate from you.
Gingrich: That's not true. You got it from the Heritage Foundation.
Romney: Yeah, we got it from you and the Heritage--you got it from the Heritage Foundation and from you [sic].
Gingrich: Wait a second. What you just said is not true. You did not get that from me. You got it from the Heritage Foundation.
Romney: And you've never supported?
Gingrich: I agree with that, but I'm just saying, what you said to this audience just now plain wasn't true.
Romney: OK. Let me ask, have you supported in the past an individual mandate?
Gingrich: I absolutely did, with the Heritage Foundation, against HillaryCare.
Romney: You did support an individual mandate?
Gingrich: Yes sir.
Romney: Oh, OK. That's what I'm saying. We got the idea from you and the Heritage Foundation.
Gingrich: OK--little broader.
Romney: OK.

The Democratic propaganda site ThinkProgress joined in, tweeting a similar tu quoque in defense of ObamaCare: "FACT: Basis for socialist Obamacare, the individual mandate, originated with right-wing Heritage Foundation #truth."

[botwt1019]

Is it the #truth? Yes, but it's a little more complicated than the ThinkProgs let on. Heritage did put forward the idea of an individual mandate, though it predated HillaryCare by several years. We know this because we were there: In 1988-90, we were employed at Heritage as a public relations associate (a junior writer and editor), and we wrote at least one press release for a publication touting Heritage's plan for comprehensive legislation to provide universal "quality, affordable health care."

As a junior publicist, we weren't being paid for our personal opinions. But we are now, so you will be the first to know that when we worked at Heritage, we hated the Heritage plan, especially the individual mandate. "Universal health care" was neither already established nor inevitable, and we thought the foundation had made a serious philosophical and strategic error in accepting rather than disputing the left-liberal notion that the provision of "quality, affordable health care" to everyone was a proper role of government. As to the mandate, we remember reading about it and thinking: "I thought we were supposed to be for freedom."

The plan was introduced in a 1989 book, "A National Health System for America" by Stuart Butler and Edmund Haislmaier. We seem to have mislaid our copy, and we couldn't find it online, but we did track down a 1990 Backgrounder and a 1991 lecture by Butler that outline the plan. One of its two major planks, the equalization of tax treatment for individually purchased and employer-provided health insurance, seemed sensible and unobjectionable, at least in principle.

VIEW TODAY'S FULL COLUMN

FORMAT THIS COLUMN FOR PRINTING

Video
                            Thumbnail
Larry Sabato on President Obama's Virginia tour and falling poll ...
play
Video
                            Thumbnail
James Taranto on President Obama's dismal political ...
play
TODAY'S MOST POPULAR: OPINION






TO UNSUBSCRIBE DIRECTLY from this list, click here.
Your request will take effect within 48 hours.

TO VIEW OR CHANGE any of your e-mail settings, click here.
You are currently subscribed as [email protected]

FOR FURTHER ASSISTANCE, please contact Customer Service at 1-800-JOURNAL (1-800-568-7625) between the hours of 7 am - 10 pm Monday - Friday ET and 8 am - 3 pm Saturday ET or e-mail [email protected].


Copyright 2011 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
Contact Us

--
Centroids: The Center of the Radical Centrist Community <[email protected]>
Google Group: http://groups.google.com/group/RadicalCentrism
Radical Centrism website and blog: http://RadicalCentrism.org

Reply via email to