>> I tried the latest state of implementation of the Radio alarm
>> functionality.
>Are we talking about the latest 7.4.2 ? or 7.5 ? I've yet to upgrade
>from 7.4.1 so I'm interested in whether the numerous threads on alarm
>issues are getting any attention.
>
I am testing with 7.5/trunk.

>I've said before that I feel the menu is more pain than gain, but if it
>must exist, I see no reason why your preference (to keep playing)
>couldn't be a third option in the menu.
>
More options = less space for the time display, and harder to choose a menu 
action.  Which is why I find it strange that the stop alarm option is there, as 
really the only needed action is Snooze.

>Also seems like the intent is to
>allow developers to override the alarm menu via apps - so maybe you'll
>have to hope that this gives you the functionality you want. But for me,
>the radio should get the basics right, out of the box - and for me its
>not yet doing that.
>
Yes, the functionality shouldn't be shunted out to third-party development, or 
at least provide better support.  Having an alarm screensaver mode would be 
great to allow third-party extensibility, but that's not there.  If there were 
a screensaver for alarm mode, then no third-party development would be needed 
for any of the various ideas/reqests that I have seen.  i.e. could select alarm 
dialog, clock, now playing, weather report or even a blank screen.

>Personally prefer to hit the power button to stop the alarm - although
>in my build (7.4.1) when you next power-on (could be days later), the
>alarm menu is still there. IMO this is a bug. Powering off the radio
>should cancel "alarm mode". Is this still the same in your build ?
>
Yes, totally bizzare unexpected behaviour - I consider that a bug too.
_______________________________________________
Radio mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.slimdevices.com/mailman/listinfo/radio

Reply via email to