---------- Forwarded message ----------
Date: 20 Jun 1999 05:59:01
From: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Reply-To: "Conference act.indonesia" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To: Recipients of indonesia-act <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Subject: JP: Building an Indonesian Hall of Shame

From: Tapol <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Subject: JP: Building an Indonesian Hall of Shame 

Received from Joyo

Excerpt: International organizations and governments, to which this nation owes a lot, 
have been interfering in our domestic business, and this is something the people of 
this country need to be ashamed of. With the enormous debt, we are no longer a fully 
independent nation. Just like dancing we dance to the music they play. And they could 
just change the tune any time they want, or stop the music altogether. This shameful 
condition is not what the founding fathers of this nation had in mind when they fought 
for independence so many years ago. And it is our duty to remind people of the 
mistakes that we have been making. The trouble is, not many feel the same way. Au 
contraire, those who participated in bulldozing this country into a dump are now 
fighting for more opportunities to do so. They do not feel ashamed of 
what they did in the past. 

Jakarta Post
Sunday, 20 June 1999

FEATURES  

Building an Indonesian Hall of Shame 

JAKARTA (JP): "We can't even scratch our head without the IMF telling us 
which part of the head to start with," said a contributor to my old friend Andreas, 
who was in the process of designing the first Indonesian Hall of Shame. 

The said contributor sent his poster to be displayed in the proposed hall of shame the 
way basketball supporters post their complaints after their 
favorite team loses. "I like this," said Andreas happily, rereading the 
statement written on the poster the way Indonesian Civil Servants Corps 
(KORPRI) members read their institutional vows at their routine flag- raising 
ceremonies on the 17th of every month. 

"I think I will put it in the main hall. This shows how far the international monetary 
body has been messing up our domestic affairs." 

Well, international organizations and governments, to which this nation owes a lot, 
have been interfering in our domestic business, and this is something the people of 
this country need to be ashamed of. With the enormous debt, we are no longer a fully 
independent nation. Just like dancing we dance to the 
music they play. And they could just change the tune any time they want, or stop the 
music altogether. 

This shameful condition is not what the founding fathers of this nation had in mind 
when they fought for independence so many years ago. And it is our duty to remind 
people of the mistakes that we have been making. The trouble is, not many feel the 
same way. Au contraire, those who participated in bulldozing this country into a dump 
are now fighting for more opportunities to do so. They do not feel ashamed of what 
they did in the past. 

Intrigued by Ben Anderson's criticisms on various shameful facts in 
Indonesia, Andreas felt this country needed to have a place to accommodate facts, 
comments, thoughts, or protests that might remind the people of shameful things we 
have done. In this way we could contemplate the issues and make efforts to correct 
them. 

When Andreas does something, he does it. He soon went to work on the project and found 
sponsorship for it. And the response was unbelievable. So many people have expressed 
their intention to pitch in. One of them said he would contribute Rp 5 billion to this 
project. 

"Good for you!" I said skeptically. 

Andreas has to be careful. That money may come with strings attached. In this 
kind of situation it is very unlikely that somebody gives you something 
without ulterior motives. Donations of an extraordinarily large amount of money to a 
sports committee, for instance, could come with a demand for a special favor. The guy 
in question may want Andreas to support his party. Or, the money could be derived from 
funds supposedly meant for the social safety net program. 

"You and your prejudice!" he shouted, when I reminded him of the tainted 
scheme. 

"Now, do me a favor. Help me collect items for display." 

Thinking that I should not kill his enthusiasm, I wrote to several people to obtain 
facts and thoughts or anything that could be shameful. And did I get responses! Within 
a week, my house was full of tidbits contributed by those who were eager to say 
something. I received not only written items, but also souvenir-type materials, such 
as pictures, books, tools, imitation guns, bullets, you name it. Some made me laugh, 
but most of them brought sad memories. 

A contributor from East Timor sent a big picture of a nail and a hammer with a caption 
that read: "The government is just like a nail. It works only when it is driven by a 
hammer." 

That expression could not be more perfect to describe the current government. There 
are so many facts to justify this. For instance, take the shooting and raping that 
took place during the May 1998 riots. The government admitted and condemned the 
violence only after many institutions imparted strong pressure on it to do so. And, 
that's it. No further action has been taken. 

The probe into Pak Harto's wealth is another example of the government's 
reluctance when it comes to law enforcement. So far, the President and the attorney 
general have been beating about the bush. Now, after Time magazine wrote about it, and 
Golkar issued an unusually strong demand (hey, where have they been so long?), the 
President instructed his aides to follow up on the case that has attracted controversy 
for so long. And, just to show that he means business, the President dispatched some 
kind of Mission Impossible -- comprising two of the nation's highest-ranking officials 
to Austria and Switzerland -- to track down money said to belong to the former 
president. 

It does not take a genius to say that the mission was impossible, what with tight bank 
secrecy and all that. And, just as predicted by ordinary people, the team came back 
empty-handed. Well, I mean, not really empty. They could carry some shopping bags and 
Swiss watches for gifts. 

As for the hall of shame, items have kept on flowing in, including a trophy from an 
old man from North Sumatra with a note which read: "To Indonesia, the world's most 
corruptive nation." 

A widow in Aceh sent a replica of a human skull with a note reading: "This represents 
my husband and countless victims of Aceh's killing fields. They're still waiting for 
the authorities to unveil the truth." 

The most touching item came in the form of a book containing pictures and stories 
about students and activists who were abducted, killed and tortured during the reform 
struggle. It was created by a group of women, including some who lost their children. 
The front page of the book reads: "We raised our children with love and care, through 
struggles and pain. But when they were grown up, we lost them to the hands of 
abductors and murderers without anybody being held responsible. What kind of country 
is this? Where has justice gone?" 

As the contributions kept coming, I was looking forward to the construction 
of the hall. But things turned sour when Andreas one day abruptly hurried 
into my house. He looked very tired as though he had just had 12 rounds with 
Evander Holyfield. 

"Forget the project," he said with a lump in his throat. "We have obtained so 
many items that we will need an area as enormous as Jabotek (the greater area 
of Jakarta) to facilitate the building. And nobody could afford it." 

"Oh, what a shame," I sighed. 

-- Carl Chairul 
 
 


**************************************************
Paul Barber
TAPOL, the Indonesia Human Rights Campaign,
25 Plovers Way, Alton Hampshire GU34 2JJ
Tel/Fax: 1420 80153
Email: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Internet: www.gn.apc.org/tapol 
Defending victims of oppression in Indonesia, 
East Timor, West Papua and Aceh, 1973-1998

25 Years...and still going strong! 






RantauNet http://www.rantaunet.com
Isikan data keanggotaan anda di http://www.rantaunet.com/register.php3
==============================================Tanpa mengembalikan KETERANGAN PENDAFTAR 
ketika subscribe,
anda tidak dapat posting ke Palanta RantauNet ini.

Mendaftar atau berhenti menerima RantauNet Mailing List di: 
http://www.rantaunet.com/subscribe.php3
==============================================

Kirim email ke