Hi, William, and thanks so much for the response!

Unfortunately, I'm actually not mystified by bicycle geometry. :-)  I work 
in a bike shop and if I'm around always work with the shorter women who 
come in hoping to be fit on road bikes (and I've trained all the other 
staff and mechanics to understand the issues). I also have experience with 
other models of Rivendells -- between my boyfriend and me, we have three 
(one for me; two for the boyfriend).  We visit the SF Bay Area at least 
once a year to see family and always take a ride to visit Rivendell HQ.

Unfortunately, the new 47cm Atlantis frame -- if the ETT of 54cm is correct 
-- will not work for me (even with the nicely slack seat-tube angle) _if I 
would like to use drop bars_.  It's a lovely frame, and perhaps in 20 years 
or so I may prefer swept-back bars on a beautifully designed, 
somewhat-rough-stuff all-rounder, but not at this time.

It's unfortunate (for me and for similarly height-challenged women who 
could probably justify a $1,600 frame but who would have a harder time 
justifying a nearly $3,000 one!), but there are far great tragedies in the 

Enjoying the list/forum, and always happy when I check in to read the 
updates. I wish Rivendell a long and prosperous future! All the best,

Elisabeth Sherwood
Washington, DC

On Wednesday, April 11, 2018 at 12:11:27 AM UTC-4, William deRosset wrote:
> Dear Elisabeth,
> This is why stack and reach sizing helps cut through the mess that sloping 
> top tubes and variable setback creates. 
> I turn out to be a bone-stock 56 cm racing bike rider based on the CONI 
> manual, but that ends up being a: 57, a 55, or a 53 in Grant Petersen 
> machines depending on the model, somewhere around a 59 in French-fit rando 
> machines. 
> It all works out to: 73 from the tip of my saddle to the top of the brake 
> lever, 2" or so drop, and 73 saddle height with drop bars. Adjust for loop 
> bars, add a pile of reach for mountain bike bars, and hope that nobody has 
> cut the threadless steerer too short on non-gp machines.
> By the way, GP bikes were traditionally built with ling top tubes and 
> slack seat tubes, contrary to the long-leg and short torso design orthodoxy 
> for women. Individual variation trumps generalization, but stack and reach 
> will help demystify the effective geo of sloping bikes.
> Or you can call in to the mothership. They won't steer you astray.
> Best Regards,
> Will
> William M deRosset
> Fort Collins CO USA

You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "RBW 
Owners Bunch" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email 
to rbw-owners-bunch+unsubscr...@googlegroups.com.
To post to this group, send email to rbw-owners-bunch@googlegroups.com.
Visit this group at https://groups.google.com/group/rbw-owners-bunch.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.

Reply via email to