Hi Ed,

Rebforce can easily help you.

Try these:

    If Error? set/any 'Fred Try [ Print "Get a grip!" ] [ Print
"Whatever!" ]

    If Error? set/any 'Fred Try [ Write %Temp.txt "Yup!" ] [ Print
"Whatever!" ]

We might call it "a subtle intricacy of the language". This is a feature,
that deserves a lengthy discussion. I would prefer a different behaviour
instead, but the above solution works... The whole trouble is caused by a
situation similar to this:

    a: ()

, while this works:

    set/any 'a ()

Cheers
-L


----- Original Message -----
From: "Ed Dana" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To: "REBOL List" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Sent: Wednesday, August 28, 2002 4:51 AM
Subject: [REBOL] Help me, Obi Reb Kenobi, you're my only hope!


OK, so what's going on here.

I'm trying to put a little error handling around my application. If it
fails, I need it to send out an alarm. But, depending on the statement,
I get an error when trying to trap the error.

For example, this works as expected:

 >> If Error? Fred: Try [ 1 / 0 ] [ Print "Whatever!" ]
Whatever!

As does this:

 >> If Error? Fred: Try [ 1 / 1 ] [ Print "Whatever!" ]
== none

This too:

 >> If Error? Fred: Try [ Print ] [ Print "Whatever!" ]
Whatever!

But this doesn't:

 >> If Error? Fred: Try [ Print "Get a grip!" ] [ Print "Whatever!" ]
Get a grip!
** Script Error: Fred needs a value
** Near: If Error? Fred: Try [Print "Get a grip!"]

This is confusing because why should I get an error on something that
doesn't and shouldn't cause an error.


This works, of course:

 >> If Error? Fred: Try [ x: 1 ] [ Print "Whatever!" ]
== none

And this:

 >> If Error? Fred: Try [ x: 1 / 0 ] [ Print "Whatever!" ]
Whatever!

And so do these:

 >> If Error? Fred: Try [ Do [ 1 / 0 ] ] [ Print "Whatever!" ]
Whatever!

 >> If Error? Fred: Try [ Do [ 1 / 1 ] ] [ Print "Whatever!" ]
== none

What's perplexing about the previous two is that it is a "Do" statement
that I am trying to execute and trap. Instead of functioning as above,
it blows up and gives me the "needs a value error".

And curiously, not only does Print fail, but so does Write. And that is
a function that I need error trapping on, if ever there was one.

 >> If Error? Fred: Try [ Write %Temp.txt "Yup!" ] [ Print "Whatever!" ]
** Script Error: Fred needs a value
** Near: If Error? Fred: Try [Write %Temp.txt "Yup!"]

I've even tried disarming the error, but to no avail:

>> If Error? Fred: Try [ Write %Temp.txt "Yup!" ] [ Print "Whatever!" ]
Disarm Fred
** Script Error: Fred needs a value
** Near: If Error? Fred: Try [Write %Temp.txt "Yup!"]

So what gives? Is this some subtle intricacy of the language, a bug, or my
normal state of confusion?

--
Sincerely,         | Mud can make you prisoner, and the plains can bake
Ed Dana            | you dry. Snow can burn your eyes, but only people
Software Developer | make you cry.
1Ghz Athlon Amiga  |   -- Lee Marvin, Paint Your Wagon.
=========== http://OurWorld.CompuServe.com/Homepages/EDanaII ===========



--
To unsubscribe from this list, please send an email to
[EMAIL PROTECTED] with "unsubscribe" in the
subject, without the quotes.



-- 
To unsubscribe from this list, please send an email to
[EMAIL PROTECTED] with "unsubscribe" in the 
subject, without the quotes.

Reply via email to