ABC TV The 7:30 Report Transcript 10/02/00 Death in custody raises questions about mandatory sentencing KERRY O'BRIEN: Today's news that a 15-year-old orphan has died while serving a mandatory sentence in Darwin, for stealing goods from a school valued at less than $100, has turned up the heat in one of Australia's more acrimonious legal and human rights debates. For the past three years, both the Western Australian and Northern Territory Governments have held fast to mandatory sentencing laws in the face of trenchant criticism by human rights advocates. In the west, anyone convicted of burglary for a third time faces a minimum of 12 months in custody. In the Top End, adults found guilty of a property offence face a mandatory two weeks in jail. Juveniles face a mandatory 28 days in jail if convicted of a second property offence. Amid concerns that such sentencing regimes may contravene Australia's obligations under international agreements such as the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child, a Senate committee has been holding public hearings on the issue. In a moment, I'll be talking to the Northern Territory's Chief Minister and Attorney-General, Denis Burke. But first, this report from Darwin correspondent Murray McLaughlin. MURRAY McLAUGHLIN: It was here at Alyangula Courthouse on Groote Eylandt, in the Gulf of Carpentaria, that the 15-year-old Aboriginal boy was sentenced last month to 28 days in detention. It was his second time before the court, so the Northern Territory's mandatory sentencing laws came into play. JON TIPPETT, NT LAW SOCIETY: He was a 15-year-old boy who had committed trivial property offences to a value of about $100 or less. That it was his second appearance in a court, that he was given a mandatory sentence of 28 days. MURRAY McLAUGHLIN: The boy was brought here to the Don Dale Juvenile Detention Centre in Darwin, two hours by plane away from his home. He was due for release on Monday, but last night hanged himself and died early this morning at Darwin Hospital. DARYL MANZIE, NT CORRECTIONAL SERVICES MINISTER: There's no evidence that this young lad may not have still been in prison, whether there was mandatory sentencing, or not. So it doesn't have any relationship to the fact that he committed suicide while in detention, and that's the area that we have to look at. MURRAY McLAUGHLIN: Can I suggest that if you don't think it's related in any way to the mandatory sentencing policy, that you might be the only one today out of step? DARYL MANZIE: You can suggest what you like. Obviously, you're allowed to have a point of view, but I think the tragedy of youth death and youth suicide -- especially in regards to detention -- is not a matter that should be delegated to the role of political point-scoring and, unfortunately, that seems to be what's happening at the moment. MAXINE McKEW: I'm not talking politics, I'm talking about policy -- DARYL MANZIE: But you are suggesting that, in fact, this is a matter to do with mandatory sentencing. MURRAY McLAUGHLIN: Yes, I am. DARYL MANZIE: Yes, well, I just pointed out very succinctly that that may not be the case at all. This young lad, unfortunately, has been in detention before and there's nothing to say he would still be in detention, whether there was mandatory provisions in place or not. GORDON RENOUF, NORTH AUSTRALIA ABORIGINAL LEGAL AID SERVICE: Well, my response is that this is yet another terrible thing that has happened as a consequence of the mandatory sentencing laws. There's no doubt that this young man would not be in custody but for the mandatory sentencing laws. MURRAY McLAUGHLIN: Last year, the Northern Territory Government tempered its mandatory sentencing laws, so the juvenile sentence for a second time for a property offence could be referred to a diversionary program. But that's not happening in remote communities in the Territory because there were no programs out there. Detention was the only option for the dead boy from Groote Eylandt. TOM STODULKA, NT ANTI-DISCRIMINATION COMMISSIONER: It's clear that this matter now has again brought the whole issue of restorative justice and diversionary programs very much into the forefront, which I think is a wonderful thing. It's a wonderful opportunity to be able to identify how can we start doing a better job for juveniles in some of these difficult situations throughout the Northern Territory. MURRAY McLAUGHLIN: Today's death has given a tragic impetus to a hearing by a Senate committee and to a private member's bill which seeks to rub out mandatory sentencing laws affecting juveniles in the Northern Territory and elsewhere. The bill's proponent, Tasmanian Senator Bob Brown, says the NT's laws breach international covenants and treaties. The NT Government defended its mandatory sentencing laws before the committee in Darwin last week and resiled against the prospect of Federal Government intervention. DAVID ANDERSON, NT ATTORNEY-GENERAL'S DEPARTMENT: Should the Commonwealth interfere with and override a valid law of the Northern Territory passed by its democratically-elected representatives? And what would be the long-term implications and effects of such actions upon the constitutional integrity of the Northern Territory? JON TIPPETT: I thought the Government's case to the Senate committee was quite extraordinary, in its denial of the fact that mandatory sentencing was having any effect upon the justice system at all. It put figures to the Senate committee that we haven't ever seen before, that apparently are obtained by it from some place or other that we know not, in support of the conclusion that mandatory sentencing really isn't having an effect. Well, now the Government knows it's having an effect. It's affected one child, we just hope it doesn't affect many more. MURRAY McLAUGHLIN: Scrutiny of the Northern Territory Government's mandatory sentencing laws will not diminish. Today's death will be investigated by the coroner, who, in his other role as magistrate has often lamented the absence of sentencing options other than jail. Next week, this same magistrate will again be sitting at Groote Eylandt to continue hearing charges against this 20-year-old, who is charged with stealing biscuits and cordial worth $23 the Christmas Day before last. Because it's his third property offence he's facing 12 months jail, if he's found guilty. and.... ABC TV The 7:30 Report Transcript 10/02/00 Burke denies blood on his hands KERRY O'BRIEN: And I'm joined now by the Chief Minister and Attorney-General of the NT, Denis Burke, in Darwin. Denis Burke, how do you feel that a child is dead tonight after mandatory imprisonment under your laws for stealing some textas and a tin of paint? DENIS BURKE, NT CHIEF MINISTER: It's pretty grotesque, Kerry, when you've got the experts coming out and saying what the cause of this child's death was just over 12 hours since he's died. I just think that's pretty grotesque. The second thing is all of the critics are rubbing their hands with glee and saying, "Burke's got blood on his hands because of mandatory sentencing." None of the media reports I've heard so far are accurate. To suggest that the reasons this child were in detention are the reasons given are wrong. I've got the record here and I know what's being said is not true. But the issue that happened with this child is one of a youth suicide and we're dealing with self-destructive behaviour in youth. We're dealing with a whole range of issues about self-destructive behaviour in the NT which are very complex. We've got kids in the Tiwi Islands that are climbing electric lightpoles and suiciding. Now, to suggest that, somehow, this child died because of mandatory sentencing I think is flat grotesque. KERRY O'BRIEN: Did he die in detention after a mandatory sentence? DENIS BURKE: Well, look at it this way -- he did, that's true. KERRY O'BRIEN: Does that have any relevance at all? DENIS BURKE: But, Kerry, people have died in detention long before mandatory sentencing was ever introduced and people will continue to die in detention. The only way people won't die in detention, Kerry, is to stop detention. We've had national inquiries about indigenous deaths in custody, we've had a whole range of actions taken by all governments and we're doing our very best to prevent deaths in custody. This is an issue and an incident that could not be prevented. Now I've been out to the Don Dale correction centre. It's not a prison. It's a very well-run facility with very caring staff and this child last night was playing eight-ball, was asked to do his chores and do the washing up. He refused to do so and the staff then sent him to his room. It wasn't locked -- the room wasn't locked. The child was unsupervised for not more than 5 or 10 minutes, at most. And during that time, he committed suicide. Now, to suggest that, somehow, mandatory sentencing is the cause of his suicide I think is just grotesque. KERRY O'BRIEN: Are you in any position to suggest that his suicide was not linked in any way to the impact on him of being detained? DENIS BURKE: Well, no-one knows the real answer to that. KERRY O'BRIEN: At the age of 15? DENIS BURKE: No-one knows the real answer to that. We should at least get that in the coronial report and that will come out. But some of the reasons for mandatory sentencing that are run around -- truly, people down south are not presented with the facts. Mandatory sentencing for juveniles in the NT, firstly, does not apply for the first few instances when children get a superintendent's caution -- they don't even come before the court. When they come before the court on their first offence and are convicted, mandatory sentencing does not apply. KERRY O'BRIEN: But for their second conviction? DENIS BURKE: When they come before the court on their second conviction, they are able to undertake diversionary programs and mandatory sentencing doesn't apply. KERRY O'BRIEN: How often does that happen? What proportion of children get diversionary programs, compared to the proportion of juveniles who end up with mandatory sentencing? DENIS BURKE: Well, I can tell you that at the moment at Don Dale there were, last night, 12 juveniles in Don Dale and five of those were subject to mandatory sentencing. That was the highest number that's been there for some time. The incarceration rate in the NT for indigenous youths is half the national average. When do-gooders down south criticise the NT, realise that we are dealing with 27 per cent of our population. We've got mandatory sentencing laws up here that we apply because we treat property offences very seriously. They don't target indigenous children. And we don't somehow believe that Aboriginal people should be given some separate system of justice and, therefore, somehow Aboriginal families can have their homes broken into and criminals get special treatment. KERRY O'BRIEN: Let's review some of the crime and punishment under mandatory sentencing and you can tell me if somehow or other this is wrong. The 18-year-old indigenous man who responded to his father's plea and admitted to stealing $2.50 cigarette lighter sentenced to 14 days. The 24-year-old indigenous mother sentenced to 14 days for receiving a stolen $2.50 can of beer. The 18-year-old man, 90 days jail for stealing 90 cents from a car. DENIS BURKE: Those are the ones that are run very emotively. I don't have the details on those. I can tell you now, I'll take a punt, Kerry -- they're wrong. I can tell you now that I'll take a punt -- they're wrong. KERRY O'BRIEN: Let me read from the Human Rights and Equal Opportunities Commission report. Robert, a 15-year-old Aboriginal boy, lacked parent support since he was 12, attempted suicide in police custody after his arrest for a mandatory detention offence. His crime was to break a window after hearing about the suicide of a close friend. DENIS BURKE: I haven't seen one report by that group or others. I read an 'Age' newspaper report the other day that said 11-year-olds are in jail for mandatory sentencing in the NT. It only applies for 15 and 16-year-olds. You've got to be a heavy hitter to hit your second conviction into court and also fail a diversionary program to be subject to detention the second time, as some of these youths are. When they quote -- KERRY O'BRIEN: Where is the evidence that mandatory sentencing is working as a deterrent to crime? DENIS BURKE: It was never introduced as a deterrent to crime. KERRY O'BRIEN: Well, what's it purpose? DENIS BURKE: It was introduced to show the criminal that we have a great regard for the victim. I don't care what anyone down south says. When people have their homes broken into and their possessions destroyed, when people have things that they've worked for all their lives trashed, they feel assaulted and grieved. Now, we believe that we have a very clear message to send. We have diversionary programs, rehabilitation programs, all those sorts of things. KERRY O'BRIEN: Deterrence is not a part of mandatory sentencing? DENIS BURKE: Deterrence is only one part of the justice system. KERRY O'BRIEN: Does it work? Does mandatory sentencing work as a deterrent? DENIS BURKE: It works extremely well in the NT. KERRY O'BRIEN: Where is the evidence? DENIS BURKE: Well, I'll tell you how it works, Kerry, because if you're caught, you go to jail. I mean, that's how it works. KERRY O'BRIEN: Is it also true that many of these people who end up mandatorily sentenced like that and going to jail or detention have come from remote Aboriginal communities, in many, many instances, are under the influence of alcohol or drugs or petrol-sniffing at the time. I mean, to what extent is this having any impact at all of any positive nature to the community, and to what extent are you punishing people for a deeply underlying social issue that Federal and State governments seem incapable of coming to grips with? DENIS BURKE: If you want to deal with the underlying social issue, that's a national problem. I'll be the first to work hard on that. But to suggest that we target Aboriginal people is just quite wrong, Kerry. KERRY O'BRIEN: Whether you deliberately target them or not, they are the ones who are mostly ending in jail, aren't they? 75 per cent of juveniles? DENIS BURKE: It doesn't target Aboriginal people. We had a politician's son locked up the other day, and he did his 14 days. So it's non-discriminatory. KERRY O'BRIEN: He's one of the 25 per cent. DENIS BURKE: I would dispute the fact that Aboriginal people are targeted and I'll dispute the fact that in terms of incarceration, the instance of indigenous incarceration has risen since mandatory sentencing has been applied. But it is the responsibility of the justice system and the judicial system and the parliamentary system in the NT to set our own rules. We don't tell NSW and Victoria how to do business and law and order is a State issue, it's a Territory issue, and it doesn't deserve to be interfered with by do-gooders like Bob Brown or others. KERRY O'BRIEN: Denis Burke, thanks for talking with us. DENIS BURKE: Thank you, Kerry. email: [EMAIL PROTECTED] � 2000 Australian Broadcasting Corporation ------------------------------------------------------- RecOzNet2 has a page @ http://www.green.net.au/recoznet2 and is archived at http://www.mail-archive.com/ To unsubscribe from this list, mail [EMAIL PROTECTED], and in the body of the message, include the words: unsubscribe announce or click here mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]?Body=unsubscribe%20announce This posting is provided to the individual members of this group without permission from the copyright owner for purposes of criticism, comment, scholarship and research under the "fair use" provisions of the Federal copyright laws and it may not be distributed further without permission of the copyright owner, except for "fair use." RecOzNet2 is archived for members @ http://www.mail-archive.com/recoznet2%40paradigm4.com.au/
