Please find attached the minutes for the working group meeting in
Prague.
A big thank you to Ulrich Wisser for volunteering to record the minutes!
They have been posted to the datatracker for the proceedings. However,
it would be helpful if those who were in attendance would review them
for accuracy and completeness. If there are any updates or suggestions
please post them here and the Chairs will make sure to get the
datatracker updated.
Thanks to all!
Antoin and Jim
IETF 104, REGEXT WG, Monday 2019-03-25 13:50-15:50
Opening by James Galvin and Antoin Verschuren (both! present)
Jabber scribe George Michaelson
RFC published since last meeting, RFC 8521, 8495, 8543, 8544
Submitted for Evaluation "Registration Fee extension",
"Strict bundling registration"
Document withdrawal by authors for "Verification Code extension"
Newly adopted documents
- Federated authentication for RDAP
- RDAP Query Parameters for Result Sorting
- RDAP Partial Response
- RDAP Reverse Search
- Login Security Extension for EPP
Scott Hollenbeck presents his draft about "Federated Authentication for RDAP".
Adam Roach, Scott make sure to make parameters compliant with BCP 190
Andrew Newton, device flow makes things over complicated
James Galvin (as individual), how do we handle non browsers if not
by device flow?
Richard Wilhelm, on going policy in ICANN is not ICANN organisation
but the ICANN process
Alexander Mayerhofer, do out-of-band for non browsers
Jaromir Talir, problem discussion with oauth around restful vs. session
Mario Loffredo, presents RDAP Sorting and Paging
Jim Gould, is it possible to implement paging without sorting?
Mario Loffredo, yes
Jim Gould, is it possible to identify what is supported?
Jim Gould, would it be benificial to support different version numbers
for sorting and paging
Andrew Newton, need mechanism for servers to indicate capabilities
Jim Gould, seconds Andrew
Mario Loffredo, presents RDAP Partial Response
Jim Gould, policy in draft, better a mechanism to let server
define fieldsets
Andrew Newton, thinks normally expected is good enough
Mario Loffredo, presents RDAP Reverse Search
Stephane Brotzmeyer, privacy considerations is not enough,
reverse search is dangerous,
Gurshabad Grover, seconds Stephane
Alexander Mayerhofer, privacy section not sufficient, should say it is
ok to just implement a subset
Andrew Newton, MUST NOT do until the user is authenticated
Jim Gould, Login Security Extension for EPP
Robert Story, password complexity requirements not met should be better
Martin Casanova (Switch), agent is free text, should maybe be more structured
Stephan Brotzmeyer, password recommendations should reference password
research document
Milestone review
James Galvin, we have two streams RDAP and EPP and struggle to balance
between them
George Michaelson, RDAP is important now because industry wants to
replace whois, we might need two time slots
Richard Wilhelm, RDAP has core documents that are important and others
that are less important
James Galvin, Alexander Mayerhofer, two workstreams have diffrent sice
of audience, EPP small audience world wide, RDAP much larger audience
in the future
Peter Koch, we need in depth review of privacy,
Andrew Newton, if two meetings, maybe two working groups
James Galvin, stay focused on 5 mile stones at most, proposal to have
two milestones per stream and assign the fifth as appropriate
Jim Gould, do not split, substantial personal overlap
Scott Hollenbeck, do not split, maybe more than 5 milestones
James Galvin, maybe we can have adopted documents but not have
milestones for them
Andrew Newton, George Michaelson, privacy stuff is important, we need
an overarching doc for privacy
Antoin Verschuren, do we have the expertise in the wg?
James Galvin, maybe we can't commit to milestones and find a way to
manage discussion to get a document to this point
Barry Leiba, documents can be moved between adopted, worked on,
milestones as needed
Proposed New Work
Tom Harrison, presents RDAP Mirroring Protocol
Marc Blanchet, Map a registrar ID to the registrar RDAP server URL
Andrew Newton, RDAP jcard issues
Alexander Mayerhofer, announcing Registry Lock side meeting at IETF104
_______________________________________________
regext mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/regext
