26 Jun 2021 12:58:45 bill-auger <bill-auger@peers.community>:
> On Wed, 16 Jun 2021 11:44:38 -0400 Richard wrote: >> <li id="A4"><p>Does not permit nonfree licenses (or lack of license) >> for works for practical use, in publicly accessible >> repos. <strong>(A4)</strong></p></li> >> >> <li id="A4-1"><p>Does not permit nonsharing licenses (or lack of >> license) for any works in publicly accessible >> repos. <strong>(A4-1)</strong></p></li> > > there does not seem to be any value in the A4/A4-1 separation - > the "any works" in A4-1, makes A4 redundant Neither A4 not A4-1 is the subset of the other. Let's say the forge allows a certain game repo with code (practical) and assets (nonpractical). - if the code is licensed under a free license but assets is nonsharing (eg all rights reserved) then A4 is satisfied but not A4-1 - if the code is under a sharing but nonfree license and the assets are under a sharing license then A4-1 is satisfied but not A4.
