WELCOME TO IWPR'S REPORTING CENTRAL ASIA, No. 479, January 27, 2007
TAJIKS SQUEEZED BY RUSSIAN CLAMPDOWN ON TRADERS New legislation hits
vulnerable migrant labour from Central Asias poorest republic. By Anora
Sarkorova in Dushanbe
KAZAKSTAN: MIGRANT WORKERS FACE DEPORTATION Illegal immigrants are being
rounded up only weeks after a controversial campaign offering them work
permits. By Olga Dosybieva in Almaty
KYRGYZSTAN: FOREIGN LABOUR BAN SPARKS CONTROVERSY Tough new restrictions on
migrants in the retail sector criticised by rights activists and some in
business community. By Cholpon Orozobekova in Bishkek
**** NEW AT IWPR
2006 KURT SCHORK AWARDS IN INTERNATIONAL JOURNALISM For details about the
winners as well as the awards ceremony held in London please go to:
IWPR LAUNCHES CENTRAL ASIAN NEWS AGENCY: News Briefing Central Asia is a new
concept in regional reporting, comprising analysis and news behind the news
in Kazakstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan and Turkmenistan. Available at:
REPORTING CENTRAL ASIA RSS: http://www.iwpr.net/en/rca/rss.xml
TURKMEN RADIO: INSIDE VIEW is an IWPR radio training and broadcast project for
Turkmenistan. View at: http://www.iwpr.net/?p=trk&s=p&o=-&apc_state=henh
RECEIVE FROM IWPR: Readers are urged to subscribe to IWPR's full range of free
electronic publications at:
GIVE TO IWPR: IWPR is wholly dependent upon grants and donations. For more
information about how you can support IWPR go to:
TAJIKS SQUEEZED BY RUSSIAN CLAMPDOWN ON TRADERS
New legislation hits vulnerable migrant labour from Central Asias poorest
By Anora Sarkorova in Dushanbe
The recent Russian ban on migrants from Central Asia working as market traders
will have a major impact on the lives of hundreds of thousands of Tajiks.
The new legislation, which came into force on January 15, will not only leave
many people from the former Soviet states without work, but slash the
remittances they are able to send home.
Russias economic development minister German Gref has said the new rules are
designed to improve the way markets operate, but many observers suspect the
decision reflects a groundswell of xenophobic attitudes towards people from
Central Asia and the Caucasus. Following violence between Russians and
Caucasians in the town of Kondopoga last year, President Vladimir Putin accused
ethnic gangs of dominating markets, to the detriment of the native Russian
Under the new regulations, foreign nationals must account for no more than 40
per cent of the total number of market traders and street vendors before April,
and after that they will be banned from working in the informal retail sector
altogether. They are specifically prohibited from selling alcohol and
According to Russias Federal Migration Service, one quarter of all foreign
nationals in the country are employed at markets. Almost all these traders,
together with seasonal workers in other low-paid sector such as construction,
are from the former Soviet Union, China and Vietnam.
Depending how seasonal migrants are counted, there may be around a million
Tajikistan nationals away working in Russia, many of them in the grey economy.
Tajik officials put the figure lower, at some 450,000, but either way the
figure is high for a population of seven million people.
A recent World Bank study estimated that the remittances sent back by these
workers contribute more than 10 per cent of Tajikistans gross domestic
product. Economists warn that the impoverished Central Asian republic can ill
afford to lose this regular influx of cash, and social conditions would be hit
further if tens, perhaps hundreds, of thousands of Tajiks reappeared on the
domestic labour market.
Also in January, Moscow introduced legislation to streamline the process by
which foreigners register for a legal work permit. This will benefit successful
applicants, who will be entitled to benefits and legal protection, and reduce
the number working in the shadow economy.
But some confusion has been caused by Moscows decision to cap the total number
of work permits issued to immigrants from the former Soviet Union most of
whom do not need visas to come to Russia - at six million, with individual
quotas for each country.
The situation is very difficult, said Muhammad Egamzoda of Tajikistans
embassy in Moscow. Russia has not yet defined the quotas for each country, and
every day dozens of our compatriots ring the embassy asking what they should
The Russian and Tajik migration services have established a joint commission
which will review the implications of the new legislation.
In the wake of the new legislation, many seasonal migrants are already leaving
But some analysts in Tajikistan argue that the restrictions on market trading
will not really reduce the number of Tajiks going to Russia.
Political scientist Khojimahmad Umarov, for example, notes that between 30 and
50 per cent of the Tajiks working in Russia could be affected by the trading
ban, but predicts that this will not cause a large exodus.
The ban on retail trading will simply mean that the migrants look for work in
other areas, particularly in the construction industry and other manual jobs
where no qualifications are needed, he said.
Many Tajiks are more pessimistic. Labour migration status has caused a huge
number of problems with the migrants documents, said Gavhar Juraeva, director
of the Tajikistan Foundation in Dushanbe. There are no exit stamps, and there
are many other problems. The Russian authorities are not ruling out abolishing
the quota for visa-free countries altogether.
At Dushanbe airport, more than half the passengers on an arriving Tajikistan
Air plane were migrant workers returning on the four-hour flight from Moscow.
Among the passengers was Ozod Rahimov, who had just completed a marathon eight
hours in the air. After flying to Moscow in the morning, he was sent home the
same evening after Russian passport officers identified him from his retina and
fingerprints as having been deported several years ago.
Figures from the Tajik interior ministry show that Russia deported around 7,000
Tajik migrants last year, mainly for working illegally. Russian regulations bar
them returning for five years.
After the Russians started deporting large numbers of Tajiks, many tried to
circumvent the regulations by changing their passports and names. But this was
not enough to fool the Russian computers.
"Yes, I won't conceal the fact - I broke the law, said Rahimov. I have a lot
at stake. I earn money for my family. I have to do something, since I cant
earn any money in my own country.
According to official figures, average pay in Tajikistan is 30 to 35 US dollars
a month, whereas in Russia a skilled worker can earn 300 dollars or more.
Anvar Boboev, head of Tajikistans Migration Service, hopes some that a
solution can be worked out between the two countries.
These people are not terrorists or murderers, and they havent committed
serious crimes in Russia, said Boboev. So were hoping the Russians will show
some understanding on this issue.
Dushanbe has asked Moscow to amnesty as many as 50,000 deported migrants, but
the Russian migration service has said each case needs to be reviewed
individually, meaning the process is likely to take a long time.
Even when Tajiks try to register properly in Russia, they encounter many
difficulties. Ravshan Salihov has lived in Moscow for three years without being
able to formalise his status. He says bosses prefer to keep their gastarbeiters
off the books so as to avoid taxes and insurance payments, and they therefore
refuse to endorse work permit applications.
As a result, Im an illegal immigrant, but I have to put up with it. I came
here to earn money and feed my family. So I'll put up with anything, he said.
Under the new legislation, businesses that continue to employ unregistered
immigrants will pay heftier fines.
Human rights campaigners have criticised Moscow for the new legislation, saying
it serves only to stir racism and xenophobia, allowing Russians to blame crime
and social problems on the migrants from the southern republics of the former
Its quite unrealistic to use quotas to regulate immigration, Galina
Vitkovskaya of International Organisation for Migration told the Moscow
newspaper Novye Izvestiya. Whats the point of it if there is a quota of
300,000 jobs [in Moscow] but there are 400,000-450,000 people from China alone
Anora Sakorova is a correspondent for the BBC and a contributor to IWPR in
KAZAKSTAN: MIGRANT WORKERS FACE DEPORTATION
Illegal immigrants are being rounded up only weeks after a controversial
campaign offering them work permits.
By Olga Dosybieva in Almaty
Kazakstan has followed a campaign to legalise labour migrants with a large
police operation to identify and deport those who could not or would not take
advantage of the scheme.
Like Russia, Kazakstan is a net importer of labour from the poorer Central Asia
republics, and for years they have lived in the grey economy, receiving no
formal rights or benefits and paying no taxes.
Last years legalisation scheme was designed to clear up the ambiguity. From
August, Tajiks, Uzbeks and Kyrgyz were able to apply for temporary residence
papers and work permits.
The scheme closed on December 31 with the authorities saying an impressive
164,586 CIS citizens had received work permits. The largest number, more than
71 per cent, were from Uzbekistan, with Kyrgyzstan, Russia and Tajikistan
comprising the rest.
However, those who didnt register last year now face deportation. Operation
Migrant began immediately after the legalisation campaign ended with the Almaty
police conducting raids on city markets, train stations and building sites.
Its not yet clear how many have been deported but at one market police filled
two buses with illegal immigrant in just two hours.
Political analyst Eduard Poletaev told IWPR that the Kazak government is
cracking down on labour migrants for economic reasons. Control over migrants
has been increased because the Kazakstan authorities are concerned that if the
economic situation in neighbouring countries worsens - and given the fact that
Kazakstan's economy is developing thanks to oil dollars - an increasing number
of migrants may come to Kazakstan, which may cause chaos on the labour market,
But some who failed to register and are now vulnerable to deportation insist it
wasnt their fault they didnt get work permits. They say their employers
hindered the registration process, preferring that they work illegally - a
claim confirmed by one businessman in the building sector.
He says law enforcement and other officials in Kazakstan often demand bribes
from businesses that employ illegal workers but says thats cheaper than paying
I gladly hire illegal immigrants, he said. Firstly, they work better than
the locals, and for much less money. Secondly, hiring these people allows me to
avoid paying a certain amount of money in taxes. If I paid the full amount, I
would have to close my firm.
Alimbek, a Kyrgyz who works at a building site in Almaty, says the only
migrants legalised during the recent campaign were the ones permitted to do so
by their employers.
We have no rights, our employers or the police can take our documents, he
said. We try not to show ourselves in public places, to avoid being detained,
or because we are simply scared of humiliation and beatings. None of us can
complain to the authorities. We only get medical aid in extreme cases. Many
illegal immigrants don't even know the word contract.
Only those with permanent contracts were allowed to register for work permits,
meaning some like Mukhitdin, who came to Almaty from Samarkand and sends money
home to his wife and five children, failed to get one, because they only had
temporary jobs during the registration period.
And there were other blips as authorities tried to extort bribes at a local
level. The news agency Inforbyuro reported that in the Aktyubinsk region in the
northwest, immigration officials colluded with notaries, telling those seeking
permits that they must first have their employment contracts certified. This
was untrue but netted notaries an illegal three million tenge (23,500 US
dollars), a portion of which they are suspected of sharing with the immigration
Red tape slowed down the registration process, according to the Aktyubinsk
prosecutor's office, and left many who should have qualified without a work
permit when the legalisation scheme ended.
Some, however, say they prefer their illegal status because they dont have to
pay any tax. Labour migrants with work permits earn about 26,700 tenge (200
dollars) per month in Astana but up to 20 per cent of that is lost through tax.
But though they may be better off financially, illegal workers lead precarious
lives. Conditions for them are often difficult and dangerous, as highlighted by
a recent court case in Aktobe. Inforbyuro reported that 18 illegal workers were
allegedly enslaved, beaten and raped at a private bathhouse in the city. The
owner is now on trial at the Aktobe city court on charges of human trafficking,
illegal exploitation and the mistreatment.
Meanwhile, in Mangistau, in the west, police uncovered a human trafficking ring
from Uzbekistan and the autonomous region of Karakalpakstan. Over 150 women
were allegedly brought to Aktau on the Caspian shore over a one-year period,
promised work as waitresses and dishwashers. Instead, their documents were
taken and they were put to work as prostitutes.
For 20-year-old Yusuf Zhumanov, the price he paid for working illegally was
high. He came from Bukhara to Shymkent and worked on a building site, living on
the streets. He says he wasnt paid and lost both his feet to frostbite in the
winter, because he couldnt afford warm clothing and footwear.
Whether further legalisation campaigns to help workers like Zhumanov will
follow is unclear, but what is certain is that the financial benefits to the
Kazak economy of more legal workers paying taxes is huge. The government says
around 2 million labour migrants came to the country last year compared with
just 200,000 two years ago. Budget revenue from taxes from the legalisation
campaign alone will exceed one billion tenge.
In 2007, tax revenues from the salaries of legalised foreign labour migrants
will be over 340 million tenge a month, or over 4 billion tenge a year, said
the deputy ministry of internal affairs, Alik Spekbaev, at a press conference
The director of the Kazakstan Human Rights Bureau agrees that legalisation is a
step forward but warns that the problem of illegal migrants is a complicated
one to tackle - and not only in Kazakstan.
Unfortunately, the problem of labour migrants has not yet been solved in any
country in the world, said Evgeny Jovtis.
It is a long time before we can talk about solving the problem, given the
transparency of the borders, especially the southern borders, and the
discrepancy in legislation among Central Asian countries on this issue, and the
lack of clear agreements between governments.
I think that a solution to the problem is not legislation in one country - but
legislation across the CIS. It is an issue of agreements between nations on
regulating the flows of labour.
Olga Dosybieva is an IWPR reporter in Almaty.
KYRGYZSTAN: FOREIGN LABOUR BAN SPARKS CONTROVERSY
Tough new restrictions on migrants in the retail sector criticised by rights
activists and some in business community.
By Cholpon Orozobekova in Bishkek
Traders from others countries will be out of work this spring when new
legislation banning labour migrants from working in Kyrgyz markets comes into
Starting April 1, only Kyrgyz nationals will be allowed to sell in the
countrys markets, with a ten per cent quota imposed on labour migrants working
in other retail sectors like supermarkets and shopping centres.
The decision to limit non-Kyrgyz workers comes after Russias January
announcement banning market traders from other countries working there, a move
that will have significant impact on the Kyrgyz economy and could leave up to
100,000 of its citizens unemployed.
President Kurmanbek Bakiev has appealed to the Russian president to allocate a
quota of 500,000 Kyrgyz who would be allowed to work in the countrys markets.
The Russian side has yet to respond.
Also key to the new legislation was lobbying on the part of local market
traders who complain they cant compete with the labour migrants. They say the
number of Chinese, Uighurs, Turks, Koreans, Iranians and Uzbeks has increased
dramatically in recent years, particularly at large markets in Bishkek and Osh.
Some had even threatened to take to the streets and demonstrate if the
government failed to crack down.
Aigul Ryskulova, the chairwoman of the state committee for immigration and
employment, says the government imposed the restrictions in response to those
complaints and to create more favourable conditions for Kyrgyz businessmen.
The impetus came from appeals and complaints by our local street traders, she
They have appealed to us several times. Its no secret that every year the
number of foreign traders increases. And unemployment in the country is
growing, so they should be replaced by local people. All the work which was
previously done by foreigners will be done by Kyrgyzstan citizens.
Even before Russias ban on labour migrants, unemployment was a serious problem
in Kyrgyzstan with official statistics suggesting about 17 per cent of the
population is out of work. However, the actual figure is much higher, meaning
local traders welcomed the new rules, although there has been criticism from
some human rights advocates and businessmen.
Every month someone I know loses his job. And theres nowhere else to go.
There isnt any other work. I have three children, said Karim, a market trader
in Bishkek who supports the new legislation.
Juman Mederaliev, who has been working at Oshs Karasuu market for five years,
said traders had planned a demonstration for February had the government failed
to responds to their concerns.
The people would have risen up, he said. We demand lawfulness and justice.
Lyubov Ivanova, a businesswoman from Bishkek, says the labour migrants get tax
breaks in their own countries and have close connections with the factories
that produce the inexpensive goods they sell. She also questions the quality of
some of the products they bring in.
There is no benefit to the country. The money is taken out of the country,
Sharapat Majitova, the chair of the trade union at Karasuu, says the number of
traders from other countries began to increase when Kazakstan and Uzbekistan
toughened their own labour laws. The Chinese and Uighurs who were deported
from these countries came to us, she said, adding she fears violence between
the local and migrant workers. We need to stop this expansion now, because
local traders are angry and sometimes even threaten to use violence.
Juman Mederaliev agrees that tensions are rising. Many of them work illegally.
We need to regulate the system and introduce some rules. No one can guarantee
that local residents will not resort to methods of force. They may burn their
goods and drive them out, he said.
Some, however, oppose the government decision to ban non-Kyrgyz traders from
the countrys markets and kiosks.
The chairman of the presidential human rights commission, Tursunbek Akun, sees
the move as a violation of the migrants human rights, [They] also have
rights. I am against this decree.
Some in the business community have also spoken out against the changes.
Company president Emil Umetaliev believes the ban will hinder the development
of the small businesses that have sprung up to service the migrant workers and
suggests a system allocating a certain number of traders visas would be more
appropriate than banning them altogether.
Businessman Omurbek Abdrakhmanov also proposes allowing a restricted number of
migrants in. I consider the invasion of citizens from [other] countries to be
a dangerous signal. A quota for each country individually should have been
introduced long ago, he said.
There is concern in Kyrgyzstan that the recent debate will harm the countrys
relations with its neighbours - a fear the government dismisses.
At a diplomatic level, there should not be a negative reaction to the
government decree, said Aigul Ryskulova. If the decision is passed, then this
means it was required by the internal situation in the country.
Ryskulova says any complaints will ultimately be resolved between governments.
Meanwhile, migrant workers like Yan from China are worried. Shes been working
at Bishkeks Dordoi market for two years and is concerned shell lose her job.
Yes, I earn good money here, but it is not easy work. I dont want to leave. I
want to stay, she said.
Rozmukhamet, an Uighur from the Xinjiang-Uighur autonomous region who also
trades at Dordoi, is more optimistic. He doubts the new law will be
implemented. Kyrgyzstan is a poor country. We help people by providing them
with cheap goods. Who are we hindering? The police? We give them money everyday
for lunch and dinner. I think that the legislation will provide another excuse
to take money from us. But we will stay here and continue to work, he said.
Cholpon Orozobekova is an IWPR reporter in Bishkek.
REPORTING CENTRAL ASIA provides the international community with a unique
insiders' perspective on the region. Using our network of local journalists,
the service publishes news and analysis from across Central Asia on a weekly
The service forms part of IWPR's Central Asia Project based in Almaty, Bishkek,
Tashkent and London, which supports media development and encourages better
local and international understanding of the region.
IWPR's Reporting Central Asia is supported by the UK Community Fund. The
service is published online in English and Russian.
The opinions expressed in Reporting Central Asia are those of the authors and
do not necessarily represent those of the publication or of IWPR.
REPORTING CENTRAL ASIA: Editor-in-Chief: Anthony Borden; Managing Editor: Yigal
Chazan; Senior Editor: John MacLeod; Central Asia Programme Manager: Saule
Mukhametrakhimova; Editor in Bishkek: Kumar Bekbolotov.
IWPR Project Development and Support: Executive Director: Anthony Borden;
Strategy & Assessment Director: Alan Davis; Managing Director: Tim Williams.
IWPR builds democracy at the frontlines of conflict and change through the
power of professional journalism. IWPR programs provide intensive hands-on
training, extensive reporting and publishing, and ambitious initiatives to
build the capacity of local media. Supporting peace-building, development and
the rule of law, IWPR gives responsible local media a voice.
Institute for War & Peace Reporting
48 Grays Inn Road, London WC1X 8LT, UK
Tel: +44 (0)20 7831 1030 Fax: +44 (0)20 7831 1050
For further details on this project and other information services and media
programmes, go to: www.iwpr.net
ISSN: 1477-7924 Copyright © 2006 The Institute for War & Peace Reporting
If you wish to change your subscription details or unsubscribe please go to: