WELCOME TO IWPR'S REPORTING CENTRAL ASIA, No. 585 Part 2, August 5, 2009
TURKMEN GOLDEN LAKE MAY PROVE GREEN DISASTER Desert reservoir will soak up
water and money faster than any improvements it may bring, say Turkmen and
Uzbek environmentalists. By IWPR staff in Central Asia
POVERTY TAJIKISTANS ONLY GROWTH AREA More than half the population are
already classed as poor, and things look set to get worse as incomes and job
opportunities are squeezed. By Sayrahmon Nazriev in Qurghonteppa and Aslibegim
Manzarshoeva in Dushanbe
2009 KYRGYZ ELECTION UPDATES: http://iwpr.net/kyrgyzelection09
NEW VACANCIES AVAILABLE http://iwpr.net/vacancies
BECOME A FAN OF IWPR ON FACEBOOK: http://iwpr.net/facebook
FOLLOW US ON TWITTER at http://twitter.com/iwpr
**** IWPR RESOURCES
CENTRAL ASIA RADIO: http://iwpr.net/centralasiaradio
CENTRAL ASIA PROGRAMME HOME: http://iwpr.net/centralasia
IWPR COMMENT: http://iwpr.net/comment
SAHAR JOURNALISTS ASSISTANCE FUND: http://iwpr.net/sahar
REPORTING CENTRAL ASIA RSS: http://www.iwpr.net/en/rca/rss.xml
RECEIVE FROM IWPR: Readers are urged to subscribe to IWPR's full range of free
electronic publications at: http://iwpr.net/subscribe
GIVE TO IWPR: IWPR is wholly dependent upon grants and donations. For more
information about how you can support IWPR go to: http://iwpr.net/donate
TURKMEN GOLDEN LAKE MAY PROVE GREEN DISASTER
Desert reservoir will soak up water and money faster than any improvements it
may bring, say Turkmen and Uzbek environmentalists.
By IWPR staff in Central Asia
The environmental costs of building a giant reservoir in the middle of the
desert easily outweigh the benefits it will bring to Turkmenistans
agricultural sector, experts say.
In neighbouring parts of Uzbekistan, ecologists say the lake could prove the
latest man-made disaster to hit the region, adding to the problems created by
the drying up of the Aral Sea.
On July 15, President Gurbanguly Berdymuhammedov opened the sluices to mark the
formal launch of a reservoir dubbed Altyn Asyr, after the Golden Age which
Turkmenistans people are officially enjoying.
This grand project has been years in the making; construction began in 2000
under Berdymuhammedovs predecessor Saparmurat Niazov.
Official reports on the reservoir have accentuated the benefits it will bring.
One hundred kilometres long and 19 wide, the lake will be used to collect water
drained off from agricultural lands. This will go through a process of
desalination and purification so that it can then be re-used for irrigation.
The Turkmen government hopes this massive recycling operation will save
precious water and reduce the environmental cost of irrigated agriculture in a
region with an arid climate.
A lecturer at Turkmenistans University of Agriculture, who asked not to be
named, says subsoil drainage created by years of irresponsible land management
has become a huge problem, making farmland increasingly saline.
At the moment, excess irrigation water in northeastern Turkmenistan as well as
neighbouring parts of Uzbekistan accumulates in the naturally-formed Lake
Sarykamysh on the two countries border. Elsewhere, the water contaminated
with salt from the soil and pesticides goes into irrigation canals, into the
ground, or back into the Amu Darya river which is the main waterway in this
part of Central Asia.
The Altyn Asyr reservoir is presented as the answer to all these ills
preventing contaminated water from seeping back into the soil and waterways,
and reducing overall use through recycling.
Experts in Turkmenistan agree on the scale of the challenge, although many fear
the artificial lake will create more problems than it resolves.
Among their concerns are that as it collects in the lake, much of the water
will simply sink into the desert sands beneath. Meanwhile, surface water will
evaporate under the hot sun, concentrating the harmful chemicals in the
Finally, as with the Aral Sea which lies north and east of the lake, areas
around the expanse of water will dry and quickly turn into a dustbowl, from
which the wind will spread poisonous chemical particles far and wide.
The idea of collecting drainage water from all regions of the country and then
using it in a rational way sounds promising in itself, but they [the
authorities] should be completely open about the downside, said one
Ashgabat-based analyst. The benefits of constructing the Turkmen lake are like
ankle-high water, whereas the damage will be knee-high.
A local environmentalist warns that the reservoir could share the fate of Lake
Sarykamysh, which has filled up with agricultural chemical residue and become a
stagnant, drying effluent pool.
In time, the new Turkmen lake will turn into another time bomb, seriously
aggravating an ecological situation that is already extremely problematic, he
said. The old time bomb [Sarykamysh] is about to go off why plant a new one?
A veteran water engineer from Dashoguz, the province where the lake is located,
gave a vivid description of the possible outcome.
Imagine a childrens sandpit, and a huge tanker truck begins pouring water
into it, he said. The sandpit turns into a mass of wet sand. This is how the
Kararakum [desert] will look in 30 or 40 years if drainage waters are collected
An excavator driver working on the reservoir confirmed that the sandy terrain
made a poor foundation.
We keep digging out the bottom and removing the sand that constantly slips
down, but more of it slides down again, he said.
A retired economist agreed that sand was a major obstacle to making lasting
The sands of the Karakum desert are constantly on the move, which means that
the two water-collection canals that have already been dug, with a combined
length of 1,003 km, will fill up with sand, he said. Maintaining stability in
the water flow and all of the lakes facilities is going to cost many billions
in state subsidies.
Other analysts, too, say the project is likely to consume never-ending amounts
of money as well as water.
To date, expenditure on constructing the water-collection canals and the lake
itself has already run to substantial sums of money, several billion dollars,
said the Dashoguz-based engineer.
The Turkmen government has been reticent about giving precise numbers for
project spending. In 2002, a figure of four billion dollars was cited, later
rising to 6.5 billion.
Now that so much money has been put into it, theres no going back, and
construction work will be completed regardless of the cost, said an anonymous
staff member at Turkmenistans ministry for water resources.
Across the border in Uzbekistan, environmentalists in Khorezm region and the
Karakalpakstan autonomous republic are looking on in horror.
They are only too aware of the ecological catastrophe caused by the shrinking
of the Aral Sea over recent decades, caused by over-use of the waters of the
Amu Darya and Central Asias other great river, the Syr Darya. This was a
direct result of intensive cotton production, a grand project of the Soviet
An environmentalist from Karakalpakstan recalls the drought of 1999 and 2000,
when the lower reaches of the Amu Darya all but disappeared leaving residents
of this part of Uzbekistan without water.
Every spring, I worry whether theres going to be water in Karakalpakstan and
Khorezm; whether the irrigation canals will fill, so that people can raise
their livestock and get some kind of harvest, she said.
She is in little doubt that the Turkmen reservoir will make things worse.
How can it be that a desert lake, where the water literally disappears into
the sand, is more important than the lives of millions of people? she asked.
This Turkmen sea can only be filled by rivers of tears from the residents of
Karakalpakstan and Khorezm. It will be the Sea of Tears and Woe.
Another Uzbek environmentalist, working on the Aral Sea problem, said there
were grave concerns that far from restricting themselves to drainage from their
own territory, the Turkmen authorities were quietly drawing off extra water
from the Amu Darya to fill the reservoir.
We dont trust the Turkmen, he said. Since independence [in 1991] theyve
been taking more than the agreed volumes of water out of the Amu Darya. It
would be possible to use satellite imagery to monitor the removal of fresh
water from the Amu Darya via these collection canals. But no one is doing that.
To the frustration of local ecological activists, the Uzbek authorities have
not offered much opposition to their neighbours giant water project in stark
contrast to their vocal hostility to hydroelectric dam projects upstream in
Tajikistan and Kyrgyzstan.
A scientist based in Karakalpakstan noted this contrast in behaviour, saying,
The Academy of Sciences of Uzbekistan is playing along with the Turkmen, even
conducting joint studies of water resources in the Amu Darya basin. I dont
know what all this is for. Our people are demanding an international ecological
feasibility study of plans to build dams in Tajikistan and Kyrgyzstan, yet
Tashkent isnt demanding the same thing for the Turkmen lake.
The environmentalist from Karakalpakstan added, Uzbekistan depends on the
waters of the Amu Darya
but its unable to interfere in the internal affairs
of its neighbour and tell it what to do.
She concluded, I think that after so many years of misunderstanding. it is
important that both countries finally sit down at the negotiating table, with
other neighbours and international arbitrators also present, and solve this
problem once and for all.
(The names of interviewees in both Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan have been
withheld out of concern for their security.)
POVERTY TAJIKISTANS ONLY GROWTH AREA
More than half the population are already classed as poor, and things look set
to get worse as incomes and job opportunities are squeezed.
By Sayrahmon Nazriev in Qurghonteppa and Aslibegim Manzarshoeva in Dushanbe
As government figures confirm that the global economic downturn is having major
effects on Tajikistan, experts warn that more and more households in Central
Asias poorest country will be driven into poverty.
Aside from collapsing production and exports, the decline in money sent home by
migrants working abroad will deprive families of a key income source.
Tajikistans statistical agency reports that the economy grew by 2.8 per cent
year on year in the first six months of 2009, half the rate seen in the same
period of 2008. Industrial production fell by 13 per cent, and export revenues
were 48 per cent down, a reflection of low world prices and lack of demand for
aluminium and cotton, Tajikistans key export commodities.
Nuriddin Kayumov, director of Tajikistans Institute of Economic Studies, said
that as of June, one-third of all industrial plants and factories across the
country were at a standstill.
Many directors are complaining that they cant sell their products and they
are being forced to send their workers on unpaid leave, he added.
The slump has slashed tax revenues, so that even the modest expenditure levels
the government envisages after scaling down its budget earlier this year may
not be achievable. (See Faint Praise for Tajik Crisis Plan, RCA No. 575,
Tajik president Imomali Rahmon warned as much on a visit to the southern
Khatlon region last month, when he criticised the provincial government for its
low tax collection rates and expressed concern that public-sector wages and
pensions were not being paid on time.
Delays on wages and pensions are already occurring, and appear to be worse in
The state owes pensioners in our village two months in back-payments and when
you get it, its only for one month, said 75-year-old Zaynab from Bokhtar in
Zaynab said that even when she got her pension, worth around 13 US dollars a
month, it was not enough to buy a sack of flour, just a bit of flour and some
Aside from conventional economic activities like agriculture and industry, one
of Tajikistans main sources of income in recent years has been money
remittances from the estimated 1.5 million migrants working abroad, mainly in
Russia and also Kazakstan.
These funds keep families afloat and contribute to economic growth between 30
and 50 per cent of Tajikistans gross domestic product, according to various
estimates by paying for goods and services on the domestic market.
Citing World Bank figures, the Tajik economy ministry reports that recorded
remittances that is, money transferred through the banks rather than being
carried home in cash stood at 525 million dollars in the period January-May,
a 34 per cent drop on the same period of 2008.
Sangchagul Jononova from Bokhtar district described how the income of her
15-member family was slashed after two of her three sons returned from Russia
after losing their jobs. She used to receive a total of 300 dollars from them,
but the two now at home are earning much less one gets 45 dollars a month
working on a building site and the other far less than that as a farmhand. We
dont have enough money for food, let alone clothes and shoes, she told IWPR.
The new school year starts soon, and I dont know how Im going to send the
children to school
. The only things we can afford now are bread and tea,
sometimes with sugar.
Over the summer, Jononova has supplemented her familys diet with fruit and
vegetables from her garden, but this will end when winter comes.
Like many returning migrants and their families, Jononova can only hope the
crisis in Russia will end soon so her sons can go back there. (For more on this
issue, see our recent report Tajikistan: No Jobs for Returning Migrants, RCA
No. 583, 12-Jul-09.)
Analysts warn that the multiple effects of the crisis falling remittances,
job losses at factories, and small business closures as consumers spend less
will inevitably force more and more people below the bread line, at a time when
the government is struggling to pay wages and benefits.
Prior to the crisis, the World Bank calculated that 54 per cent of Tajikistans
population were living on less than two dollars a day, its benchmark figure for
Hojimahmad Umarov, a professor at the Institute for Economic Studies, says that
figure has now risen to 60 per cent. Meanwhile, he says, 15 per cent of people
in Tajikistan are living on less than one dollar a day.
These are families that cannot rely on members working abroad as labour
migrants. Most of them live in Khatlon and in Badakhshan, he said.
Najiba Shirinbekova, who heads a non-government group called Law and
Prosperity, notes that the north of Tajikistan, traditionally better off than
other parts of the country, is also being hit.
The latest information indicates a particularly high level of poverty in the
ostensibly wealthy, industrially developed Soghd region. This is because
factories are standing idle because of the financial crisis and the winter
energy crisis, she said.
Larisa, a 59-year-old resident of the capital Dushanbe, typifies the kind of
people who still have jobs but have few other resources to prevent them sliding
Living on her own, she earns about 30 dollars a month placing her in Umarovs
bottom 15 per cent. Her wage has to cover food, household utilities and travel
to and from work.
I havent bought myself any clothes probably for three years. Ive forgotten
what meat, sausages, cheese and cream taste like. I buy small amounts on
holidays, and sometimes neighbours invite me over for a meal, she said.
Although the inflation rate is lower this year than last, prices in the shops
are still rising enough to cut into Larisas purchasing power. At her age, not
in the best of health, she cannot take on a second job to top up her income.
If it gets very difficult, I will have to turn to my children for help and
hope they wont leave me to fend for myself, said Larisa, whose children have
emigrated to Russia.
People further up the income rung, for example shopkeepers and market traders,
are also seeing their earnings eaten away.
Since most of their customers money was sent by relatives abroad rather than
earned in Tajikistan, the decline in remittances has led to shops closing and a
slowdown in trading at the traditional open-air bazaars.
People are trying to buy only the most essential items, said a Dushanbe
businessman who gave his first name as Aknazar.
Selling foodstuffs wholesale to other parts in the country, Aknazar reckons he
is turning over less than a third of what he would have been making before the
Previously, I was supplying beer and chicken to the Pamirs [Badakhshan
region], but now some of my regular customers come only once every three
months. The prices of many goods have increased including sugar and cooking oil
and the same thing is happening to flour.
Mavzuna, who works in a womens clothes store in Dushanbes Sadbarg shopping
centre, said, Trade has practically died out, we dont know how to pay the
rent, which the owners have increased. Shop assistants like Mavzuna find
themselves under increasing pressure to make money.
We are told to deliver 22 dollars worth of sales on a daily basis, but how
can we achieve that? At the moment we arent reaching that sales target in the
course of a week.
Sayrahmon Nazriev and Aslibegim Manzarshoeva are IWPR-trained journalists in
REPORTING CENTRAL ASIA provides the international community with a unique
insiders' perspective on the region. Using our network of local journalists,
the service publishes news and analysis from across Central Asia on a weekly
The service forms part of IWPR's Central Asia Project based in Almaty, Bishkek,
Tashkent and London, which supports media development and encourages better
local and international understanding of the region.
IWPR's Reporting Central Asia is supported by the UK Community Fund. The
service is published online in English and Russian.
The opinions expressed in Reporting Central Asia are those of the authors and
do not necessarily represent those of the publication or of IWPR.
REPORTING CENTRAL ASIA: Editor-in-Chief: Anthony Borden; Managing Editor: Yigal
Chazan; Senior Editor and Acting Central Asia Director: John MacLeod; Central
Asia Editor: Saule Mukhametrakhimova.
IWPR PROJECT DEVELOPMENT AND SUPPORT: Executive Director: Anthony Borden; Head
of Programmes: Niall MacKay; Head of Strategy: Mike Day.
IWPR is an international network of four organisations which are governed by
boards of senior journalists, peace-building experts, regional specialists and
IWPR builds democracy at the frontlines of conflict and change through the
power of professional journalism. IWPR programmes provide intensive hands-on
training, extensive reporting and publishing, and ambitious initiatives to
build the capacity of local media. Supporting peace-building, development and
the rule of law, IWPR gives responsible local media a voice.
IWPR - Africa, P.O. Box 3317, Johannesburg 2121
Tel: +2 711 268 6077
IWPR - Europe, 48 Grays Inn Road, London WC1X 8LT, UK
Tel: +44 20 7831 1030
IWPR United States, 1325 G Street, NW, Suite 500, Washington, DC 20005,
Tel: +1 202 449 7717
1515 Broadway, 11th Floor, New York, New York 10036, United States
Tel: +1 202 903 1073
Stichting IWPR Nederland, Eisenhowerlaan 77 K, 2517 KK Den Haag, The Netherlands
Tel: +31 70 338 9016
For further details on this project and other information services and media
programmes, go to: www.iwpr.net
ISSN: 1477-7924 Copyright © 2009 The Institute for War & Peace Reporting
If you wish to change your subscription details or unsubscribe please go to:
This electronic mail message and any attached files are intended solely for the
named recipients and may contain confidential and proprietary business
information of the Institute for War & Peace Reporting (IWPR) and its
affiliates. If you are not the named addressee, you should not disseminate,
distribute or copy this e-mail.
Institute for War & Peace Reporting. 48 Gray's Inn Road, London WC1X 8LT, UK.
Registered with charitable status in the United Kingdom (charity reg. no:
1027201, company reg. no: 2744185); the United States under IRS Section
501(c)(3); The Netherlands as a charitable foundation; and South Africa under