On 5/3/05, Jeffrey Liu <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> Hi Steve, 
> Configure in this case means the user goes to the Eclipse perference page,
> choose the version of Tomcat that was downloaded, and point Eclipse to the
> location where it was unzipped. Nothing major, but not obvious to novice
> users. Although I'm not similar with what autonomic-system-management is, I
> don't think this is anything near that. 

Well, that's all right then. I was worried you were thinking of
configuring tomcat to find a spare port, open a hole in the firewall,
etc etc.

But if you arent doing that, then this proposal is purely for the
Eclipse IDE itself?

That's a bit, well, limited. 

We currently have three ways of distributing stuff
 -on the web, for download
 -as rpms, including jpackage rpms of java stuff
 -as maven/maven2 downloads

RPMs are interesting because although linux-centric (and redhat
centric, to be precise), there are a lot of tools out there than can
pump them out to systems in a cluster; you get good management.

maven repositories are fun because every JAR is on a URL; you can pass
them to a URL classloader as is if you want. The .pom also declares
dependencies for transitive work; a bit like debian apt-get.

We are just starting to roll out Maven2 support, both in Apache and
outside it. I am not (yet) convinced we need
yet-another-archive-format with another set of distributables, and if
it only benefited one IDE, I dont think it is justifiable. It would
surely be better if we had

-a gui client that could work with the existing Apache repositories
-a client build on AWT for broadest cross platform execution. 
-some way of pushing out packages to multiple systems in a cluster
-support per/user, per-system packages
-good auditing to determine package set (with JMX integration)

That is, a Java successor to all the rpm management tools.

Incidentally, one pressing problem with the maven repositories is
there is no easy way to fetch Sun stuff. That is, if I want to use
Axis with mail.jar and activation,jar, you cant get those from the
Apache site for legal reasons. Do you propose any solution to the
clickthrough licensing problem?


Reply via email to