|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||| ANNOUNCEMENTS and ARTICLES: http://pnews.org/art/art.shtml ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
(By the way, PNEWS-L is a list for POINTERS, not for replies to articles. At the end of each article, or most of them, is a bulletin board type of forum for your comments. That would have been the appropriate venue for discussion of the article - even more so than the RHETORIC list. Didn't you see it there? Perhaps I'll migrate the article to Wiki where there is sure to be much discussion of the premise that conspiracies are generally, more often than not, simply business as usual...) Interesting comments and not the first one which challenges my unpopular view of conspiracy theories. I'm trying to relate this to what I wrote and I do see semantic differences, but I also see I need a more cogent example. It is so much easier to blame what is unknown on something tangible than to see it as part of a design that is not a conspiracy because too many people know about it; it is designated policy which just seems like conspiracy to those who find it outside their normal frame of reference. I wonder if you have read anything by Chip Berlet, who did at one time post regularly to PNEWS-L (in the old days) and has been regularly taken to task for much the same reason -- for challenging the acceptable view which is to blame it on a conspiracy. This is the same unremarkable resort to conspiracy to explain the assassination of JFK, which next to Lincoln is probably the best known conspiracy just as the U.S. Liberty, a classic case of "friendly fire" has become a popular conspiracy for the right. Cover-ups are not conspiracies, they are "business as usual" which just resemble a conspiracy, a conspiring to have something happen for a particular reason. I call it two-may-toe and you call it too-maw-tow. But it is still a tomato There were two article about conspiracies. The one you quoted from and the next one -> There are Conspiracies There are very real conspiracies that do exist and there has been confirmation of their plans, i.e., the failed attempts to kill Fidel Castro, assassination of Patrice Lumumba, Watergate, the C.I.A.s "involvement" in the movement of drugs and the conspiracy against Chile's Salvador Allende, and Nicaragua's Sandisistas. And, Israel conspired with South Africa to develop nuclear weapons. In the 90s we have the Iran-Contra Affair, the BCCI banking scandal, Watergate and all of them were fraudulent and illegal activities. They have all been called "grand conspiracies" and were coverups by the ruling classes. http://pnews.org/portal/modules.php?name=Sections&op=viewarticle&artid=14 Read both and post your response there. There is a form for your commentary in the second and since it follows the first part, though I used different form and markup (a conspiracy), the second one is your place to reply. Read Chip Berlet's "The Right Woos the Left," written several years ago and very, very good; a classic really, and the essay covers this subject in great detail. Also, another quote (there is so much you can find about the fancy notion of conspiracies and how they distort truth at PRA) Conspiracism as Parody of Institutional Analysis (quote) The conspiracist analysis of history has become uncoupled from a logical train of thought. . .it is a non-rational belief system that manifests itself in degrees. Conspiracism blames individualized and subjective forces for economic and social problems rather than analyzing conflict in terms of systems and structures of power. Conspiracist allegations, therefore, interfere with a serious progressive analysis--an analysis that challenges the objective institutionalized systems of oppression and power, and seeks a radical transformation of the status quo. Bruce Cumings, put it like this: "But if conspiracies exist, they rarely move history; they make a difference at the margins from time to time, but with the unforeseen consequences of a logic outside the control of their authors: and this is what is wrong with "conspiracy theory." History is moved by the broad forces and large structures of human collectivities."28 See: http://www.publiceye.org/tooclose/conspiracism-06.html The rest says: Power structure research is not inherently conspiracist, but conspiracist pseudo-radical parodies of power structure research abound. Examples include right-wing populist critics such as Gary Allen, Antony Sutton, Bo Gritz, Craig Hulet, and Eustace Mullins. Left-wing populist critics include David Emory, John Judge, and Danny Sheehan of the Christic Institute. Conspiracism tarnishes the artistic work of filmmaker Oliver Stone. A recent book by the respected left analyst Michael Parenti, Dirty Truths, contains a very problematic defense of conspiracism.31 There are also a plethora of practitioners who have drawn from both the left and the right such as Daniel Brandt and the late Ace Hayes. Conspiracism blames individualized and subjective forces for economic and social problems rather than analyzing conflict in terms of systems and structures of power.32 Conspiracist allegations, therefore, interfere with a serious progressive analysis--an analysis that challenges the objective institutionalized systems of oppression and power, and seeks a radical transformation of the status quo. The subjectivist view of conspiracist critics of the status quo is a parody of serious research. As Lyons observes, "To claim, for instance, that the Rockefellers control the world, takes multiple interconnections and complex influences and reduces them to mechanical wire pulling."33 As one report critical of right-wing populist conspiracism suggested: "There is a vast gulf between the simplistic yet dangerous rhetoric of elite cabals, Jewish conspiracies and the omnipotence of "international finance" and a thoughtful analysis of the deep divisions and inequities in our society."34 Separating real conspiracies from the exaggerated, non-rational, fictional, lunatic, or deliberately fabricated variety is a problem faced by serious researchers, and journalists. For progressive activists, differentiating between the progressive power structure research and the pseudo-radical allegations of conspiracism is a prerequisite for rebuilding a left analysis of social and political problems. --------------------------------------------------------------- I'm really not going to discuss this any further here. I will create a space for it on the Wiki where others can participate as well. I will put an interesting essay by Chip on the Wiki today. One paragraph from that essay reads as follows: "Progressive conspiracism is an oxymoron. Rejecting the conspiracist analytical model is a vital step in challenging both right-wing populism and fascism. It is important to see anti-elite conspiracism and scapegoating as not merely destructive of a progressive analysis but also as specific techniques used by fascist political movements to provide a radical-sounding left cover for a rightist attack on the status quo. Far from being an aberration or a mere tactical maneuver by rightists, pseudo-radicalism is a distinctive, central feature of fascist and proto-fascist political movements. This is why the early stages of a potentially-fascist movement are often described as seeming to incorporate both leftwing and rightwing ideas." Thanks for your views Paxdora. Hank > > http://davesweb.cnchost.com/nwsltr27.html --- / o o \ ===OO=====OO================================================= http://pnews.org/vortal/ New World disOrder and Myth Busters http://g0lem.net/vortal/ Insane Planet and Wacko World http://g0lem.net/portal/ Bad-Ass Truth and TheGolemsPortal http://pnews.org/portal/ Naked Truth and PNEWS Portal http://g0lem.net/PhpWiki/ (Wiki) http://pnews.org/ (Home) ============================================================= \_/ \_/
