Clearly, having multiple copies of the identical file in different
folders and with different album tags and different track numbers is the
best solution. But the inefficiency of that offends me, for some reason.
(It's not necessarily logical. It's not as though I'm remarkably
efficient in everything else I do.)

Here's a workaround I'm trying:

Put all tracks from a box set in a single folder, using filenames in the
form suggested by w3wilkes: [disc#]-[track#]-title. Edit track number
tags so that they are sequential through the entire set. It helps if
there are gaps in the numbering. For instance, for a four-disc set
containing a total 65 tracks, instead of numbering the tracks 01 through
65, number then 101 through 118 (or whatever the number of tracks on the
first disc), 201 through 221, 301-314, and 401-412. 

Then, edit tags so that every track that was originally released on an
album has ONLY the name of the original album in the album tag. In many
cases, especially with Mosaic sets, the tracks in the box sets are not
in the same order as on the original albums, so it will be necessary to
juggle the track number tags to get them in the right sequence for the
original albums. (That's why it's important to leave gaps in the number
sequence; that will make it much easier to get track numbers in original
album order when the tracks are spread out over multiple discs in the
box set.)

In my limited testing so far, this seems to work. LMS sees the original
albums, and they should be available for Random Albums, which is
important to me. The box set discs will NOT appear as albums in the LMS
database (except for the outtakes and alternates), but that's okay with
me. They aren't albums, in the sense of a programmed listening
experience; they're archival volumes. The box set discs can be accessed
through the Music Folder, though, with the tracks in the order as they
appear in the box set.

This seems to work for me. I'm sure it's not for everybody, but I hope
somebody will find it useful and maybe help refine it.


------------------------------------------------------------------------
RobbH's Profile: http://forums.slimdevices.com/member.php?userid=67008
View this thread: http://forums.slimdevices.com/showthread.php?t=108121

_______________________________________________
ripping mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.slimdevices.com/mailman/listinfo/ripping

Reply via email to