Hi Holger,

Holger Hoffstätte wrote:
Mark,

Mark Brouwer wrote:
Mark Brouwer wrote:

So I think you are right, I will reopen this issue for someone else to
resolve it. Do want to have a go at it Gregg ;-) ?

As nobody volunteered for RIVER-230 I'm removing it from the issues to
solve for AR2. It still would be nice if somebody would tackle this one
given statements as "This is a big pain, especially for new Jini users"
;-P as it would solve 2 problems, getting currently non-committers
involved and solving the pain. I have still plenty of stuff to do for
AR2 so I'm not volunteering here.

I just had a look (not knowing anything about ClassDep until now ;) and commented on the bug. I understand the output problem (reproduced easily) and sanitizing the input seems easy enough too, so if that's all then I can take care of this.

Great, I tried to assign you to this task but apparently I can't select
you as you are not a committer for River, so I'll just make a remark you
are working on it. With regard to your 2 sub-problems as mentioned in
the comment of RIVER-203 I'm not sure whether you are thinking of
changing the behavior of the output of ClassDep as is (when using the
-files option), I don't have a clear view of how people expect it to
behave but it seems that a platform specific output is what you want.

So I would only fix #1, something else you might consider is the path
separator used for the classpath (; versus :) as that one is currently
tied to the OS as well.
--
Mark

Reply via email to