On 3/23/2010 4:51 PM, Dominik Riebeling wrote:
Sure, but giving a subjective reason (like "it's not worth the effort
/ binsize increase / ...) is at least better than having no reason at
all, and the majority of developers agreeing on a subjective reason is
good enough imo. If the NoDo items are discussed on a regular basis
(like the proposed discussion on each years DevCon) such reasons also
have to stand. Which obviously means that if there isn't a majority
for holding up the subjective reason then it's no longer a NoDo item.
I completely agree with Frank here.
Frank didn't say anything about subjective reasons. I'm the one who said
a subjective reason ought to be good enough.
Frank wanted "All NoDo items must have a proper rationale" which sounds
much more significant than just a subjective reason. Maybe I
misunderstood, but I tend to understand a rationale to be something more
significant than "it's not worth the effort"
