Robin Whittle wrote:
Hi Tony and Javier,
Thanks for your replies.
My understanding is that one or more people can write a critique and
post it to the list. Then other people can suggest improvements,
which the original author(s) may or may not incorporate to the
satisfaction of the second person.
Second and subsequent individuals or groups can contribute
alternative critiques by posting them to the list - and Lixia and
Tony will choose one of them.
I think this would be a good approach. In that case, I think that
whenever anyone posts a critique to the list, that it should not be
immediately "incorporated".
- Robin
Hi Robin,
Thank you for your comment. However, in the interests of getting a
draft out for subsequent steps promptly and not leaving all of the
editorial work to a giant unsatisfiable lump at the deadline, we will be
serializing the work. We have no objections to adding updated
critiques, if and when those become available or choosing an alternate
critique if one is presented.
In other words, "incorporated" is not necessarily a final state.
Regards,
Tony
_______________________________________________
rrg mailing list
[email protected]
http://www.irtf.org/mailman/listinfo/rrg
