Researchers, I think we must not attack each other personally. Nor even each other's views. We need to find the best solution each of the design goals.
Here we talk about identity/location split. Robin is against. Most but seem to be for. So with the identity/location split we encounter identifier uniqueness. Whether it has to be global/universal or just local. Some hesitate about this; others, like me, take universal uniqueness for natural. Next question: Uniqueness system is to be hierarchical or flat? Any arguments on flatness side? But there is a ready-made solution. Is it reliable? Are we going any further with this ambiguity? I propose this approach: Let's answer the questions the reverse way. 1. Hierarchical or flat uniqueness system? 2. Global/universal or just local uniqueness? 3. Shall we make identity/location split? Good will Toni _______________________________________________ rrg mailing list [email protected] http://www.irtf.org/mailman/listinfo/rrg
