Good comment.
In general, I don't understand the the problem definition.
If the focus, is backbone scalabillity caused by site-multihooming then
the problem space are very static.
Therefore, an approach with predefined provider adresses space could be
pretty simple.
One may also find a solutions that makes the mapping very simplistic
from an implementation point-of-viow.
-Lasse
________________________________
From: Juan Jose Adan [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Sent: den 11 mars 2008 09:19
To: Geoff Huston
Cc: Lixia Zhang; Lars Westberg; [email protected]
Subject: Re: [RRG] yetAnotherProposal: AS-number forwarding
Hi Geoff,
>Dunno how much all this helps the world other than illustrate
(a) that
>AS-based routing is probably too coarse and you may want a
finer level
>of granularity in terms of division of forwarding elements and
(b) all
>of this is well covered ground.
I think AS-based routing does not necessarily imply that
we have to use just a locator per AS, but the locators'
structure will have to be based on the AS number.
(I will use 2-byte AS numbers to better explain this).
Let's suppose we want to send traffic to a server A having
an IP address within the "identifier prefix" of a stub AS
connected to a transit provider whose ASN=1. Let's also
suppose that we use the "locator prefix" 240.0.1.0/24 to
send tunneled traffic towards AS1 (second and third bytes
are the AS number). It means that the outer IP address
would be 240.0.1.0.
For server B having an IP address in a different "identifier
prefix", AS1 could announce a second "locator prefix", for
example 240.0.1.128/25, so that traffic sent to server B
would be tunneled with the outer IP address 240.0.1.128.
And AS1 would announce these two "locator prefixes", namely
240.0.1.0/24 and 240.0.1.128/25, in different ways to the
rest of the Internet.
And this exercise can be made finer and finer so that an
"identifier prefix" could be assigned a "locator prefix"
such as 240.0.1.77/32.
Therefore AS-based routing can be used with a very fine
level of granularity I think.
Regards,
Juanjo
-----
