Title: Re: chroot() failed, 2: Not owner
You're absolutely right that it was a permissions problem inside of my jail. I modified the script that I created to build my jail (which very much resembles your script, but hey, who doesn't love reinventing the wheel) to use "cp -p" instead of just "cp" when copying files from the root file system to the jail, blew away my jail, and reran the script and now it works without having to suid root on sftp-server or having to make the user the owner of the jail. And, the user only has write access within their home directory in the jail. Yay!
 
Please hang onto that "discounted" consulting rate though. I may need it some day. :-p Seriously, though, thanks for taking the time to respond to my posts- I think it would have taken me much longer to figure things out without your input.
 
Just in case anyone is interested, here's the script that I developed for creating jails on Solaris 8:
 
CHROOTPATH=/export/home/chroot
USER_HOME_DIR=export/home/testrssh
USER_NAME=testrssh
GROUP_NAME=testrssh
SFTP_PATH=/opt/csw/libexec/sftp-server
SCP_PATH=/opt/csw/bin/scp
RSSH_PATH=/opt/csw/bin/rssh
CHROOT_HELPER_PATH=/opt/csw/libexec/rssh_chroot_helper
LDD_PATH=/usr/bin/ldd
KSH_PATH1=/bin/ksh
KSH_PATH2=/usr/bin/ksh
PWD_PATH1=/bin/pwd
PWD_PATH2=/usr/bin/pwd

CopyLibFiles(){
  for aFile in `ldd ${currExecutable} | cut -d' ' -f3`; do
    if [ ! -d ${CHROOTPATH}/`dirname ${aFile}` ]; then
      mkdir -p ${CHROOTPATH}/`dirname ${aFile}`;
    fi
    cp -p ${aFile} ${CHROOTPATH}${aFile}
  done;
}

CopyExecutable(){
  directoryPath=`dirname ${currExecutable}`
  mkdir -p ${CHROOTPATH}${directoryPath}
  cp -p ${currExecutable} ${CHROOTPATH}${directoryPath}
}

# copy sftp-server and library files
# ==================================
currExecutable=${SFTP_PATH}
CopyExecutable
CopyLibFiles
# make sftp-server suid root
# this only needs to be done if
# the user logging in doesn't own ${CHROOTPATH}
# chmod u+s ${CHROOTPATH}/${SFTP_PATH}

# copy scp and library files
# ==========================
currExecutable=${SCP_PATH}
CopyExecutable
CopyLibFiles

# copy rssh and library files
# ===========================
currExecutable=${RSSH_PATH}
CopyExecutable
CopyLibFiles

# copy rssh_chroot_helper and library files
# =========================================
currExecutable=${CHROOT_HELPER_PATH}
CopyExecutable
CopyLibFiles
 
# copy ldd and library files
# ==========================
currExecutable=${LDD_PATH}
CopyExecutable
CopyLibFiles

# copy ksh and library files
# =========================
currExecutable=${KSH_PATH1}
CopyExecutable
CopyLibFiles
currExecutable=${KSH_PATH2}
CopyExecutable
CopyLibFiles
 
# copy pwd and library files
# =========================
currExecutable=${PWD_PATH1}
CopyExecutable
CopyLibFiles
currExecutable=${PWD_PATH2}
CopyExecutable
CopyLibFiles
 

# copy file(s) from /etc
# ====================
mkdir -p ${CHROOTPATH}/etc
cp -p /etc/passwd ${CHROOTPATH}/etc
 
# create home directory in jail
# =============================
mkdir -p ${CHROOTPATH}/${USER_HOME_DIR}
chown ${USER_NAME}:${GROUP_NAME} ${CHROOTPATH}/${USER_HOME_DIR}
echo "Remember to edit /etc/passwd with absolute path to jailed home dir: ${CHROOTPATH}/${USER_HOME_DIR}"
 
# copy ld.so.1
# ============
cp -p /usr/lib/ld.so.1 ${CHROOTPATH}/usr/lib/
 
# create /dev/null in jail
# ========================
mkdir -p ${CHROOTPATH}/dev
cp -p /dev/null ${CHROOTPATH}/dev


From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] on behalf of Derek Martin
Sent: Tue 8/22/2006 2:36 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: chroot() failed, 2: Not owner

On Tue, Aug 22, 2006 at 02:36:00PM -0400, Martin, Russell wrote:
> > The user does not need to own the jail, and they don't need write
> > access to the root of the jail.  The permissions on the jail just need
> > to be sufficient for them to read the directory, i.e. r-x.
>
> Okay. But, I've tested this and retested it and the behavior I've
> described is consistent. If sftp-server (the copy inside the jail)
> is suid root, then sftp works.

Sure, root can do anything...  You are giving your users root
privileges within your jail.  NOT GOOD!

> If sftp-server is not suid root and the user logging in owns the
> jail then things work. I have not found any other combination where
> sftp will work. This is a Solaris 8 box I'm testing on. Any ideas as
> to why things are behaving this way for me?

Well, it seems like it's almost certainly some kind of permissions
problem in your jail.  For starters, with the sftp_server binary not
SUID (and of course the rssh_chroot_helper IS set SUID), does it still
fail with "chroot() failed, 2: Not owner"?

Without seeing your config, passwd file, and having access to the
directory permissions in your tree, I can't really make any guesses.

If you post your config, I can certainly poke at it...  I don't
necessarily need to see your passwd file (which shouldn't have any
passwords in it, of course)... but that would help.  And I'd
definitely need the output of this:

  cd $ROOT_OF_JAIL; find . -type d -maxdepth 1 -exec ls -ld {} \;

My usual consulting fee is $100/hr, but since you packaged rssh for
Solaris, I'll give you the special price of $125/hr.  ;-)

--
Derek D. Martin
http://www.pizzashack.org/
GPG Key ID: 0x81CFE75D

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Using Tomcat but need to do more? Need to support web services, security?
Get stuff done quickly with pre-integrated technology to make your job easier
Download IBM WebSphere Application Server v.1.0.1 based on Apache Geronimo
http://sel.as-us.falkag.net/sel?cmd=lnk&kid=120709&bid=263057&dat=121642
_______________________________________________
rssh-discuss mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/rssh-discuss

Reply via email to