In message <cadndz8-5zpykuu2hzxunjx0weeavmofm_3nclv-tnt7iy-d...@mail.gmail.com> Abdussalam Baryun writes: > Please note that I had difficulty in routing area or MANET WG explaing > my comments and discussing with editors just to understand my point of > views and edit few changes, but failed, it seems that they only follow > ADs, or I just don't know how they think. > > Are editors taking any training? > > AB
It is not clear from your email what draft you are talking about or why this email is on the RTGWG mailing list. I suggest that you try putting your comments in writing in an email and send it to someone to review for clarity before sending to the mailing list. If you are talking about comments at the microphone at a meeting, then perhaps written comments would clear things up. In general written comments on the mailing list are supposed to count for more than verbal comments at the mic at an IETF meeting, though some would argue that is not the case. Authors are obligated to respond to comments about WG drafts, particularly in last call. If the comments were not clear, a response asking for clarification is considered sufficient, awaiting the clarification. Curtis _______________________________________________ rtgwg mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/rtgwg
