http://cic.gov.in/CIC-Orders/WB-06082009-01.pdf
"If the information sought, therefore, would amount to invasion of privacy it could no doubt have been denied. However, the investigation on which information has been sought involved a decidedly public activity. In this case what is sought is only a copy of the disciplinary authority's recommendations to CVC and a copy of CVC's advice meaning that not even proceedings for any offence alleged to have been committed, the disposal of such proceedings or indeed a copy of the original enquiry report has been called for. Clearly this is not a case where disclosure will amount to invasion of privacy. CPIO Shri Arun Nahar, Advisor, CVC will therefore, now provide this information to Shri Naidu within ten working days from the date of receipt of this Decision Notice. This appeal is allowed. There will be no costs"
