ANALYSIS OF the RTI_INDIA POLL OF CIC SATISFACTION NB : The poll closed on 24-Oct-2009 and was open for 72 hours In DESCENDING ORDER of VOTES POLLED BY THE ICs
M L SHARMA = 42 A N TIWARI = 38 P BALASUBRAMANIAM = 35 SATYANAND MISHRA = 34 ANNAPURNA DIXIT = 26 WAJAHAT HABIBULLAH = 8 SHAILESH GANDHI = 6 M M ANSARI = 3 NO. OF MEMBERS VOTING = 24 (APPROX) NOTE: It is significant that not a single member rated IC(M L SHARMA) as BAD, and not a single member has rated IC (M M ANSARI) as GOOD. Sarbajit Roy MODERATOR --- In [email protected], [email protected] wrote: > > > The following rti_india poll is now closed. Here are the > final results: > > > POLL QUESTION: "My satisfaction with the Central Information Commission > graded by my 'inter se' (relative to each other) > satisfaction with its Commissioners (based solely > on the quality of their published decisions which I > have read)is :-" > > INSTRUCTIONS: > 1. Honour system: This poll is only open to group > members who regularly read / analyze CIC decisions. > > 2. Please tick UPTO a maximum of 1 box PER IC. If you > don't follow the IC then don't tick any of their boxes. > > 3. Please be sure to tick the CONTROL BOX (Choice 22). > > 4. To complete this poll properly, you must assume that > there is AT LEAST ONE IC who is "GOOD", and all other > gradings are relative to such "goodness". > > > CHOICES AND RESULTS > - Wajahat Habibullah (GOOD =2 points), 3 votes, 1.47% > - Wajahat Habibullah (AVERAGE =1 points), 2 votes, 0.98% > - Wajahat Habibullah (BAD =0 stars), 18 votes, 8.82% > - A N Tiwari (GOOD =2 points), 17 votes, 8.33% > - A N Tiwari (AVERAGE =1 points), 4 votes, 1.96% > - A N Tiwari (BAD =0 stars), 2 votes, 0.98% > - M M Ansari (GOOD =2 points), 0 votes, 0.00% > - M M Ansari (AVERAGE =1 points), 3 votes, 1.47% > - M M Ansari (BAD =0 stars), 19 votes, 9.31% > - M L Sharma (GOOD =2 points), 19 votes, 9.31% > - M L Sharma (AVERAGE =1 points), 4 votes, 1.96% > - M L Sharma (BAD =0 stars), 0 votes, 0.00% > - Shailesh Gandhi (GOOD =2 points), 2 votes, 0.98% > - Shailesh Gandhi (AVERAGE =1 points), 2 votes, 0.98% > - Shailesh Gandhi (BAD =0 stars), 19 votes, 9.31% > - Annapurna Dixit (GOOD =2 points), 9 votes, 4.41% > - Annapurna Dixit (AVERAGE =1 points), 8 votes, 3.92% > - Annapurna Dixit (BAD =0 stars), 6 votes, 2.94% > - Satyanand Mishra (GOOD =2 points), 9 votes, 4.41% > - Satyanand Mishra (AVERAGE =1 points), 6 votes, 2.94% > - Satyanand Mishra (BAD =0 stars), 8 votes, 3.92% > - Control Question (U MUST TICK THIS BOX), 21 votes, 10.29% > - IC Padma B (Retd.) (GOOD =2 points), 15 votes, 7.35% > - IC Padma B (Retd.) (AVERAGE =1 points), 5 votes, 2.45% > - IC Padma B (Retd.) (BAD =0 stars), 3 votes, 1.47% > > > > For more information about this group, please visit > http://groups.yahoo.com/group/rti_india > > For help with Yahoo! Groups, please visit > http://help.yahoo.com/l/us/yahoo/groups/original/general.html >
