There are two batches of Rock Island cars; ACF in 1970, 62900-999, and P-S in 
1973, 62500-849, many of them probably ended up on CNW and UP.  The ACF ones 
had 4 rows of horizontally narrow waffles, not evenly spread.  DJE


  ----- Original Message ----- 
  From: SMMW 
  To: [email protected] 
  Sent: Friday, October 26, 2012 2:25 PM
  Subject: {S-Scale List} Potential "modern" era kits


    

  I have nothing against producing cars from any era but, historically 
speaking, steam and transition era cars sell MUCH better than modern.  My SR 
waffle box was the only modern car I produced and it barely crossed the 110-kit 
market.  And, before the critics say "it's road-specific", I can assure you 
that with just the addition of 2 waffles per side, you can accurately model all 
of the Family Lines Systems predecessors and CSX.  Without the waffles, you can 
model 2 Southern paint schemes and at least 2 NS schemes.  



  Conversely, the B&O wagontop box, which was also produced in brass, peaked 
near 200.  If modern diesels create a market for modern cars, I'll be there but 
only if the prototype is of interest.



  On a related note, I created a web page of "what if" cars that some folks 
expressed interest in.  NONE of the modern cars (grain hopper, either bulkhead 
flat or the Ugly Duckling box) have come remotely close to the 80-kit minimum 
needed to justify a project.  Some haven't crossed the 30-kit threshold yet!



  Numbers don't lie.  Of the 154 members on my emailing list, only 52 replied 
(a topic in itself!) and the results clearly show that cars built in the 1940s 
and 1950s are of primary interest, so that's where I'll focus (for now).  Like 
I tell some individuals who want their "pet" car to become a reality:  go drum 
up the interest, drawings, photos, etc. and present it to me for consideration.



  Jim King

  President, Smoky Mountain Model Works, Inc.

  Ph. (828) 777-5619

  www.smokymountainmodelworks.com



  Trainmaster, Craggy Mountain Line RR

  www.craggymountainline.com




  

Reply via email to