No End In Sight For Nickel Strength
27/04/2007 By: Greg Peel
2006 saw an interesting development in the global nickel market. As prices
surged to new, previously unthought of highs, a new market developed in "direct
shipping laterite ore" which actually had the effect of reducing the 2006
deficit below that which had been previously anticipated. But even this had
little effect on the price.
Nickel ore is found globally in two major forms sulphide and laterite.
Laterite is exceedingly more abundant at 72% of known resources, yet sulphide
represents 58% of nickel production. This is because nickel laterites suffer
from complex mineralogy, notoriously low grades and very high processing costs.
Laterite mining has a history of longer-than-expected production ramp-ups and
cost overruns. On average, one hundred tonnes of laterite ore needs to be mined
and processed to produce one tonne of nickel.
zMSgetJS('adsize=variable&position=creative2');
on error resume next if (plugin
Advertisement
Because of the high cost of laterite processing, smaller miners have
previously not bothered with this abundant source as the cost exceeded the
potential revenue. But now that the nickel price is in excess of US$23/lb,
laterite ore can be processed commercially. Smaller miners do not have to
invest in expensive processing plants. Instead, they simply ship the ore and
sell it to supply-starved plants that have this capacity already. The high cost
of shipping so much ore still falls short of prices achieved. Thus we now have
a market in "direct shipping" laterite ore. Most of 2006's supply came from the
Philippines and New Caledonia.
Canaccord Adams had previously predicted a global nickel deficit of 50,000t
in 2006, but the end result was 28,000t due to the laterite invasion. If
there's a lot more of this stuff lying around, then one could assume the nickel
price will soon come under threat. Nearly all of the world's major currently
proposed greenfield projects are laterite.
However, Canaccord is not assuming this to be the case. Were the nickel price
to slip below its current levels, laterite mining, due to its high costs, would
be the first to cease. Thus there is still a price support mechanism.
Canaccord estimates global nickel supply reached 1.34mt last year,
representing a 4% increase. Demand reached 1.37mt, for a very strong
consumption growth of 7.4%. And we all know where that came from.
While the Western world increased its nickel consumption by 4.4% in 2006,
which was a stark rebound from the 4.7% fall of 2005, Chinese consumption
increased by a ridiculous 25%, exceeding even the ridiculous figure of 23.5% in
2005. The major driver all round was a 12.4% increase in global stainless
production. Global inventories at the end of 2006 had fallen, on Canaccord's
estimates, to a very low 86,000t, or 3.3 weeks of consumption.
For 2007 Canaccord sees supply growth of 7.2% to 1.44mt, bolstered by direct
shipping laterite ore. Consumption is expected to be 1.45mt, representing
growth of 5.9%. China will contribute 17.4% and the Western world 3.5%. The
deficit will fall to 13,000t, but available nickel inventories will fall to
73,000t or 2.6 weeks of consumption.
As we progress into time, Canaccord still cannot see supply outstripping
demand. 2008 should bring 1.49mt of nickel but consumption will 1.52mt. The
supply figure includes delays to Inco's giant Goro project and BHP Billiton's
(BHP) Ravensthorpe project, still offset by direct shipping laterite ore.
Inventories will fall to 45,000t or 1.5 weeks. This will be considered
critical.
By 2009 several new projects should have started up, but tightness will
remain. Production will reach 1.56mt and consumption 1.59mt. Following the
Beijing Olympics Chinese consumption growth will fall to 9.6%. In theory, at
this point all available nickel inventories will have been consumed. If there
are no stocks available, says Canaccord, then only a high price for nickel can
reduce demand.
Thus the implication is that significantly high nickel prices will be
required through to the end of the decade in order to reduce forecast
consumption levels in line with available inventories.
As far as the supply side is concerned, the biggest barrier is rising costs.
These costs stem from a lack of engineering talent, higher contractor rates,
and higher equipment and material costs. They were always a barrier, but they
are now becoming prohibitive. Estimates suggest the cost of new nickel capacity
has risen to US$18/lb, representing an average project scope of US$1.8bn, and
it can only rise further.
At some point, the cycle will finally cool off, notes Canaccord. Most
resource analysts still assume a long term nickel price of US$5.00-5.50/lb. But
that seems a long way off at present, and many greenfield projects will likely
be delayed until such time as costs become less prohibitive (thus only
extending the delay).
Adding to the likelihood of extended high prices is consolidation in the
market. Four companies Norilsk Nickel, CVRD, Xstrata and BHP Billiton (BHP)
control 48% of the global mined nickel market and 56% of the refined market.
This compares to global aluminium, copper and zinc where the top four producers
only represent 35%, 31% and 23% of their respective markets. (This is explained
to some extent by the fact that global nickel production is about 1.4mt,
compared to 34mt, 17mt and 10mt for the other metals).
Canaccord suggests that this level of control in the nickel market will
ensure a level of "discipline of supply". Usually when metal prices run up
there is a rush to start new projects which ultimately leads to oversupply and
price collapse. There is no advantage in the big four rushing out their new
projects quickly, lest they see the nickel price subside. Already both CVRD and
Xstrata have pushed back start-up dates for major projects.
And the demand side will still be all down to China. In 2000, China's nickel
consumption increased by 50% to hit 65,000t, or 5.8% of global consumption.
Consumption growth has not quite been so staggering since, but in 2006 China
consumed 250,000t of nickel or 18.3% of global consumption. Over 2000-06,
China's stainless steel production has increased from 524,000t to 4.8mt. Unless
it suffers a spectacular economic collapse, China is expected to be consuming
over 400,000t of nickel per annum by 2010.
It is going to take an extremely high nickel price to curtail nickel
consumption, says Canaccord.
In the longer term 2012 and beyond Canaccord still believes the outlook
for nickel remains "extremely encouraging". The current slate of greenfield
developments should be easily absorbed by the market given there appears no end
in sight to China's insatiable appetite. The high cost of ramp-up will also
place a dampener on supply, including from laterite sources. And industry
consolidation will ensure supply cannot get out of hand anyway.
---------------------------------
Ahhh...imagining that irresistible "new car" smell?
Check outnew cars at Yahoo! Autos.