> > You are streching it a bit here. :) "#!" only signals execv() that
> > is shuld use the folowing path to interpret the text-file. And 
> > 'magic numbers' are really not supported by the filesystem itself
> > on UNIX.
> 
> No, not by the filesystem.  And nor should they be.  I thought this was the
> entire point of the conversation.

They should not be - true. :)  

> The operating system recognises several magic numbers as signifying
> executable files.  And yes, "#!"  is a magic number.  On this system
> it is not in /etc/magic but it is built into the file command and the
> same goes for ZMAGIC, NMAGIC and OMAGIC.

Then you also might define the first 512 characters of a text file as a
magic number too. If file(1) does not find any other 'magic number'
it 'guesses' from the first 512 bytes. Try file(1) on a C-program
that contains more than 512 bytes of non C-code. And "#!" doesn't
uniqely distinguish a file - on the other hand a line starting with
"#!" does.

> 
> imc
> 

 -Frode

Reply via email to