Hi *,

I'm attempting to use cascading saned servers, in other words: I'm trying to share a scanner that is reachable from the "saned" system via its network back-end.

Technically, this works. Unfortunately, either saned or the clients are not prepared for this, as the network scanners are not not listed via "xsane" nor "scanimage -L".

The manual pages and network resources I found during my search seem ambiguous: Some people talk about "scanners local to the saned server", while the man page says "[saned] allows remote clients to access image acquisition devices available on the local host", which includes those reachable via network, too.

I've tested with saned from sane-backends-1.0.20-7.6.1 (SLES11SP3) and scanimage from sane-backends-1.0.23-9.2.3.i586 (Opensuse 13.1) and xsane-0.998-19.1.4.i586.

Machines involved:
- client machine (Opensuse 13.1)
- central saned server (SLES11SP3) "sanedserver.company.com"
- remote saned server (i.e. Opensuse 13.1)

When specifying the network scanner via "scanimage -d net:sanedserver.company.com:net:anothersanedserver.company.com:somedriver:somescanner" on the client machine, I can scan successfully, although running "scanimage -L" wouldn't list that device. "xsane" users are left out, as they're presented the same list as the one from "scanimage -L" , thus not seeing the cascaded scanner on the client machine.

Running "scanimage -L" on the central saned server will list the remote scanner.

We're using this design because of hub&spoke configurations, where remote saned servers will only permit the central server in their /etc/saned.conf and all clients connect only to the central saned server.

To be precise, it's the device listing that doesn't seem to work. Probably the central saned server doesn't report network-connected scanners to its clients. Is this "working as designed", or have I hit a bug?

Regards,
Jens



--
sane-devel mailing list: [email protected]
http://lists.alioth.debian.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/sane-devel
Unsubscribe: Send mail with subject "unsubscribe your_password"
            to [email protected]

Reply via email to