ns3 is now optional. Please remove it on DNS Edit page and try changing nameservers with registrar/registry again.
On 09.12.08 13:19, "Edwin B." <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > Hi Alex, > > Well if I don't use NS3 it will include it because it's in the zone > file or something. It then works as a hidden nameserver. > > Regards > > Edwin > > On 9 dec, 10:24, Alex Kovalyov <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: >> Yeah, SIDN are the most clever guys on the CCTLD market. >> >> The interesting thing is: >> Registry said that it does not have the domain and *does not relay*. >> >>> The SOA record of the requested domain was not found, because the >>> addressed server does not have it configured, and does not relay >>> the request either. >> >> This >> tool:http://www.sidn.nl/ace.php/c,728,5886,,,,Nameserver_check.html?domain... >> .net&primary=ns1.scalr.net&primary_ip=67.19.29.18&second1=ns2.scalr.net&seco >> nd1_ip=67.19.90.82&second2=ns3.scalr.net&second2_ip=67.202.32.243&submit=Ver >> zend >> >> Says that ns3 *does relay* and it doesn't like it: >> >> Error: name server at 67.202.32.243 is not authoritative. >> The SOA record for the domain was retrieved from the specified >> server, but that server answered only indirectly: it is not a >> source name server for this domain, but only relaying the query >> to other servers. This address must not appear in the TLD zone file. >> >> ns3 is in fact a caching relay to ns1 and ns2. >> >> Please use ns1 and ns2 only for now. >> We're making so ns3 can be optionally removed from your zone on the Edit DNS >> Zone page, for those captious registries that tend to analyze zone files on >> nameservers. >> >> On 08.12.08 21:35, "Edwin B." <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: >> >> >> >>> Hi there, >> >>> I tried adding an application with a .nl domain. After I created it, I >>> assigned the nameservers to the domain. But the nameserver change is >>> rejected by the SIDN (Dutch domain registry) because of a faulty >>> ns3.scalr.net. I can't leave it out because it will add it in anyway. >> >>> Response from SIDN: >> >>> Errors=4, Warnings=2, Informational=1 >> >>> ** Summary: REJECTED ******.nl. >> >>> Some problems need to get fixed: >>> - In total, 4 configuration errors where found. >> >>> ** Full check report: >> >>> * primary name server "ns1.scalr.net." >> >>> *****.nl. 14400 IN SOA ns1.scalr.net. >>> admin.scalr.net. >>> (2008120802 4H 2H 1D 5M) >>> Warning: TTL of 5M in SOA is quite short; better at least 10M. >>> The shorter the time span in the TTL field of the SOA record, the >>> more often the SOA needs to be checked. >>> RIPE203 advises a TTL of 2D. >> >>> hotnspicy.nl. 14400 IN NS ns3.scalr.net. >>> Warning: hidden name server "ns3.scalr.net." never used for first >>> contact. >>> The zone contains an NS record for a host which is not in the list >>> of >>> specified name servers. Hence, this name server will not be used >>> to >>> initiate contact to the domain. It may be used in sequential >>> lookups, >>> so it may still be useful. >> >>> * secondary name server "ns2.scalr.net." >>> Info: name server looks correctly configured. >> >>> * secondary name server "ns3.scalr.net." [HIDDEN] >>> Error: name server at 67.202.32.243 does not know about domain >>> "*****.nl." >>> The SOA record of the requested domain was not found, because the >>> addressed server does not have it configured, and does not relay >>> the request either. >>> Error: name server "ns1.scalr.net." missing via IP 67.202.32.243 >>> The primary name server listed this name server on its first IP- >>> address. >>> However, this other source does not list that name. >>> Error: name server "ns2.scalr.net." missing via IP 67.202.32.243 >>> The primary name server listed this name server on its first IP- >>> address. >>> However, this other source does not list that name. >>> Error: name server "ns3.scalr.net." missing via IP 67.202.32.243 >>> The primary name server listed this name server on its first IP- >>> address. >>> However, this other source does not list that name. >> >>> ** More information: >>> TE refers to SIDN document "Technische Eisen" (Dutch only) >>> http://www.sidn.nl/doc/te.pdf >>> RFC1035 RFC "Domain Names - Implementation and Specifications" >>> http://rfc.net/rfc1035.html >>> RFC1123 RFC "Requirements for Internet Hosts >>> http://rfc.net/rfc1123.html >>> RFC1912 RFC "Common DNS Operational and Configuration Errors" >>> http://rfc.net/rfc1912.html >>> RFC3330 RFC "Special-Use IPv4 Addresses" >>> http://rfc.net/rfc3330.html >>> RIPE203 "Recommendations for DNS SOA Values" >>> http://www.ripe.net/ripe/docs/ripe-203.html >> >>> ** DNScheck 4.2.4, 2008/12/08 20:29:07 CET+0100 >> >>> I hope you can help me with this.... >> >>> Regards, >> >>> Edwin > > --~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~ You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "scalr-discuss" group. To post to this group, send email to [email protected] To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [EMAIL PROTECTED] For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/scalr-discuss?hl=en -~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
