Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-10-04 Thread Luca Beltrame
In data martedì 4 ottobre 2011 13:36:52, Aaron J. Seigo ha scritto: > we know why we want to move away from the 20 year old implementation of > screen savers, we know how we want to do it ... now let's execute on that > plan, keep communicating to our users and partners about it and be open to FY

Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-10-04 Thread Aaron J. Seigo
On Tuesday, October 4, 2011 13:06:34 Kevin Kofler wrote: > Martin Gräßlin wrote: > > Well if they do I promise to ship an update to kwin to ensure that > > xscreensaver is stacked underneath the desktop shell ;-) > > They'll find a way around that too. "If you make something idiot-proof, > nature b

Re: Re: Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-10-04 Thread Kevin Kofler
Martin Gräßlin wrote: > Well if they do I promise to ship an update to kwin to ensure that > xscreensaver is stacked underneath the desktop shell ;-) They'll find a way around that too. "If you make something idiot-proof, nature builds a better idiot." ;-) (And sorry, I don't remember who origin

Re: Re: Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-10-03 Thread Martin Gräßlin
On Monday 03 October 2011 21:31:19 Kevin Kofler wrote: > Martin Gräßlin wrote: > > What would you say if KDE Plasma would no longer support X Screensavers? > > * I would switch to another DE > > * I would complain > > * I would miss them but could live without them > > * Don't use screensavers, it

Re: Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-10-03 Thread Kevin Kofler
Martin Gräßlin wrote: > What would you say if KDE Plasma would no longer support X Screensavers? > * I would switch to another DE > * I would complain > * I would miss them but could live without them > * Don't use screensavers, it doesn't affect me > * Don't care You forgot option 6: * Come up wi

Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-10-03 Thread Kevin Kofler
Ivan Čukić wrote: >> Probably because the distros are not shipping 4.7 yet. (4.1 to 4.6 >> actually do show desktop icons by default, in a folder view widget which >> is set up by > > No plasma release had the folderview by default. Some of the distros > had (have) the folder view as default conta

Re: Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-10-02 Thread Martin Gräßlin
On Sunday 02 October 2011 14:15:01 Luca Beltrame wrote: > In data domenica 02 ottobre 2011 10:43:43, Ivan Čukić ha scritto: > > > It needs to specify that "no X Screensavers" doesn't mean "no screensavers" > > krop on IRC raised an interesting question: is this "drop of support" related > to just s

Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-10-02 Thread Luca Beltrame
In data domenica 02 ottobre 2011 10:43:43, Ivan Čukić ha scritto: > It needs to specify that "no X Screensavers" doesn't mean "no screensavers" krop on IRC raised an interesting question: is this "drop of support" related to just support, or also library dependencies? This because some stuff such

Re: Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-10-02 Thread Martin Gräßlin
On Sunday 02 October 2011 13:27:13 Luca Beltrame wrote: > In data domenica 02 ottobre 2011 12:19:02, Martin Gräßlin ha scritto: > > > Poll created: http://forum.kde.org/viewtopic.php?ff&t�102 > > I just blogged about this, so the poll gets more exposure. cool thanks - I plan to also blog about it t

Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-10-02 Thread Luca Beltrame
In data domenica 02 ottobre 2011 12:19:02, Martin Gräßlin ha scritto: > Poll created: http://forum.kde.org/viewtopic.php?ff&t—102 I just blogged about this, so the poll gets more exposure. -- Luca Beltrame - KDE Forums team KDE Science supporter GPG key ID: 6E1A4E79 signature.asc Description:

Re: Re: Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-10-02 Thread Martin Gräßlin
On Sunday 02 October 2011 22:07:30 Ben Cooksley wrote: > On Sun, Oct 2, 2011 at 9:31 PM, Martin Gräßlin wrote: > > On Sunday 02 October 2011 09:26:34 Luca Beltrame wrote: > >> In data domenica 02 ottobre 2011 02:47:49, Kevin Kofler ha scritto: > >> > >> > without a custom Plasma init script enabli

Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-10-02 Thread Luca Beltrame
In data domenica 02 ottobre 2011 10:31:32, Martin Gräßlin ha scritto: > would no longer support X Screensavers? * I would switch to another DE Is there a good definition of "X" and "non X" screensavers? This is IMO important to communicate to the userbase as for them they are likely one and the s

Re: Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-10-02 Thread Ben Cooksley
On Sun, Oct 2, 2011 at 9:31 PM, Martin Gräßlin wrote: > On Sunday 02 October 2011 09:26:34 Luca Beltrame wrote: >> In data domenica 02 ottobre 2011 02:47:49, Kevin Kofler ha scritto: >> >> > without a custom Plasma init script enabling the folder view of ~/Desktop >> > one way or the other (either

Re: Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-10-02 Thread Ivan Čukić
> What would you say if KDE Plasma would no longer support X Screensavers? It needs to specify that "no X Screensavers" doesn't mean "no screensavers" -- Cheerio, Ivan -- While you were hanging yourself on someone else's words Dying to believe in what you heard I was staring straight into the

Re: Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-10-02 Thread Martin Gräßlin
On Sunday 02 October 2011 09:26:34 Luca Beltrame wrote: > In data domenica 02 ottobre 2011 02:47:49, Kevin Kofler ha scritto: > > > without a custom Plasma init script enabling the folder view of ~/Desktop > > one way or the other (either as a widget as in 4.6 or in Fedora 16, or the > > KDE-3-sty

Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-10-02 Thread Ivan Čukić
@Martin I say kill X screensaver, and we'll make a few cute QML ones to ship instead. @all For me, it is not only about X-code versus non-X-code. It is also about security of scrsaver's execution. > Probably because the distros are not shipping 4.7 yet. (4.1 to 4.6 actually > do show desktop ic

Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-10-02 Thread Luca Beltrame
In data domenica 02 ottobre 2011 02:47:49, Kevin Kofler ha scritto: > without a custom Plasma init script enabling the folder view of ~/Desktop > one way or the other (either as a widget as in 4.6 or in Fedora 16, or the > KDE-3-style "folder view as desktop" mode), complaints will start popping i

Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-10-02 Thread Martin Gräßlin
- Ursprüngliche Mitteilung - > Aaron J. Seigo wrote: > > unless we give them something better and communicate with > > understanding. > > Users will not accept your "something better" unless their favorite > existing  screensaver runs on it. No amount of communication can change > that.

Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-10-01 Thread Kevin Kofler
Luca Beltrame wrote: > After all, in the KDE Forums we don't see anymore people lamenting the > lack of icons on desktop by default... Probably because the distros are not shipping 4.7 yet. (4.1 to 4.6 actually do show desktop icons by default, in a folder view widget which is set up by default.

Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-10-01 Thread Luca Beltrame
In data sabato 01 ottobre 2011 19:22:21, Kevin Kofler ha scritto: > Users will not accept your "something better" unless their favorite existing > screensaver runs on it. No amount of communication can change that. (And But one can "feel the pulse" of the users. Blogs, and even more so the KDE F

Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-10-01 Thread Kevin Kofler
Aaron J. Seigo wrote: > unless we give them something better and communicate with understanding. Users will not accept your "something better" unless their favorite existing screensaver runs on it. No amount of communication can change that. (And please don't shoot the messenger! I don't even us

Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-10-01 Thread Markus Slopianka
On Samstag 01 Oktober 2011 14:10:39 Marco Martin wrote: > for saving from damage, there is a thing called "power saving" :p Doesn't help the people who want a huge clock as screensaver without damaging their displays. It has to move. A Plasma containment whose widgets can float and bounce from

Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-10-01 Thread Markus Slopianka
On Samstag 01 Oktober 2011 12:36:12 Aaron J. Seigo wrote: > we should also stress that if things like OpenGL screensavers are important > enough to people, that support for "things to draw moving things on screen > when locked" can be created anew. We already have KWin effects – even gimmicky one

Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-10-01 Thread Marco Martin
On Saturday 01 October 2011, Markus Slopianka wrote: > On Samstag 01 Oktober 2011 10:52:04 Marco Martin wrote: > > that's what the support of plamoids on screensaver is for ;) > > I already understood that but as a screensaver (you know: to actually save > screens from damage, incl. LCDs) a few ad

Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-10-01 Thread Markus Slopianka
On Samstag 01 Oktober 2011 10:52:04 Marco Martin wrote: > that's what the support of plamoids on screensaver is for ;) I already understood that but as a screensaver (you know: to actually save screens from damage, incl. LCDs) a few additional features are required. At the very least, plasmoids

Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-10-01 Thread Aaron J. Seigo
On Saturday, October 1, 2011 11:46:43 Martin Gräßlin wrote: > > rather don't do this "if only one user is configured" as > > a) this is rather never the case (does kdm know that "sauerbraten" and > > "mpd" are no regular users? what about "nobody", "fetchmail" yes, kdm does. this is how it kn

Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-10-01 Thread Aaron J. Seigo
On Thursday, September 29, 2011 23:49:50 Kevin Kofler wrote: > Martin Gräßlin wrote: > > * drop screensaver support altogether, probably would create some troubles > > as evil KDE removed screensavers > > * add Plasma widget support to new screen locker implementation but drop > > screensaver suppo

Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-10-01 Thread Martin Gräßlin
- Ursprüngliche Mitteilung - > Am Thu, 29 Sep 2011 22:14:59 +0200 > schrieb Martin Gräßlin : > > > But when compositing is turned off, you currently get the plain old > > implementation including screen savers. And I don't want to change > > that code. > Seconding Marco: "Why?" it's such

Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-10-01 Thread Marco Martin
On Saturday 01 October 2011, Markus Slopianka wrote: > Is anybody aware of empiric studies for what (if at all) people use > screensavers these days? > Personally I'd expect clock, news headlines, and photo slideshows to be the > top answers. QML replacements should be available for the top uses on

Re: Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-09-30 Thread Martin Gräßlin
On Saturday 01 October 2011 04:46:29 Markus Slopianka wrote: > Is anybody aware of empiric studies for what (if at all) people use > screensavers these > days? > Personally I'd expect clock, news headlines, and photo slideshows to be the > top answers. > QML replacements should be available for t

Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-09-30 Thread Markus Slopianka
Is anybody aware of empiric studies for what (if at all) people use screensavers these days? Personally I'd expect clock, news headlines, and photo slideshows to be the top answers. QML replacements should be available for the top uses once the xscreensaver code is dropped. (IMHO at least.) O

Re: Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-09-30 Thread Martin Gräßlin
On Friday 30 September 2011 12:38:34 Aaron J. Seigo wrote: > On Thursday, September 29, 2011 22:14:59 Martin Gräßlin wrote: > > * add Plasma widget support to new screen > > locker implementation but drop screensaver support (same problems as first > > option) > > +1 for this. > > if the lock scree

Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-09-30 Thread Aaron J. Seigo
On Thursday, September 29, 2011 22:14:59 Martin Gräßlin wrote: > * add Plasma widget support to new screen > locker implementation but drop screensaver support (same problems as first > option) +1 for this. if the lock screen is QML, when we get a QML version with OpenGL shaders people can go cra

Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-09-30 Thread Martin Gräßlin
On Fri, 30 Sep 2011 11:27:23 +0200, todd rme wrote: On Fri, Sep 30, 2011 at 11:11 AM, Aaron J. Seigo wrote: On Friday, September 30, 2011 07:48:28 todd rme wrote: What about implementing a screensaver plasma wallpaper backend?  This this would require significant changes to Plasma::Wallpape

Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-09-30 Thread todd rme
On Fri, Sep 30, 2011 at 11:11 AM, Aaron J. Seigo wrote: > On Friday, September 30, 2011 07:48:28 todd rme wrote: >> What about implementing a screensaver plasma wallpaper backend?  This > > this would require significant changes to Plasma::Wallpaper and a lot of > changes to how the painting is ha

Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-09-30 Thread Aaron J. Seigo
On Friday, September 30, 2011 07:48:28 todd rme wrote: > What about implementing a screensaver plasma wallpaper backend? This this would require significant changes to Plasma::Wallpaper and a lot of changes to how the painting is handled there. i don't think this is a realistic option before fr

Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-09-29 Thread Ivan Cukic
> But when compositing is turned off, you currently get the plain old > implementation including screen savers. And I don't want to change that > code. I'm with Marco on this one. I don't think having two totally different code paths and user exp is a good idea. > * drop screensaver support al

Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-09-29 Thread todd rme
On Thu, Sep 29, 2011 at 10:14 PM, Martin Gräßlin wrote: > So there are some solutions: > * drop screensaver support altogether, probably would create some troubles as > evil KDE removed screensavers > * add Plasma widget support to new screen locker implementation but drop > screensaver support

Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-09-29 Thread Kevin Kofler
Martin Gräßlin wrote: > * drop screensaver support altogether, probably would create some troubles > as evil KDE removed screensavers > * add Plasma widget support to new screen locker implementation but drop > screensaver support (same problems as first option) I don't think these are acceptable.

Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-09-29 Thread Thomas Lübking
Am Thu, 29 Sep 2011 22:14:59 +0200 schrieb Martin Gräßlin : > But when compositing is turned off, you currently get the plain old > implementation including screen savers. And I don't want to change > that code. Seconding Marco: "Why?" > So there are some solutions: > * drop screensaver support

Re: ScreenSaver and KDE Plasma 4.8?

2011-09-29 Thread Marco Martin
On Thursday 29 September 2011, Martin Gräßlin wrote: > Hi all, > > the work on the new screen locker implementation is nearly done (I can > unlock again :-) and that brings me to an issue where I wanted to have > more opinions: screensaver. > +1 > > But when compositing is turned off, you curr