OFF: [Assessor] Humiliating Public Reminder to Vote on Proposal 8089
This time, Proposal 8089 has three votes; we need seven, please. Slackers: ATMunn, Aris, Corona, CuddleBeam, D. Margaux, Murphy, omd, P.S.S., Trigon, V.J. Rada, Gaelan, nichdel, o, Ouri, pokes, Quazie, Telnaior and 天火狐. Above reminder, as rule 2168 says, should humiliate. New voting deadline: the second of September, 6:19 AM. -twg
Re: OFF: [Assessor] Humiliating Public Reminder to Vote on Proposal 8089
I vote PRESENT on proposal 8089. On Sun, Aug 26, 2018 at 11:04 AM Timon Walshe-Grey wrote: > This time, Proposal > 8089 has three votes; > we need seven, please. > > Slackers: > ATMunn, Aris, Corona, CuddleBeam, D. Margaux, Murphy, omd, P.S.S., Trigon, > V.J. Rada, Gaelan, nichdel, o, Ouri, pokes, Quazie, Telnaior and 天火狐. > > Above reminder, > as rule 2168 says, > should humiliate. > > New voting deadline: > the second of September, > 6:19 AM. > > -twg >
OFF: [Arbitor] Court Gazette
COURT GAZETTE (Arbitor's weekly report) Disclaimer: Informational only. No actions are contained in this report. Information in this report is not self-ratifying. Open cases (CFJs) - 3645 called by Aris 20 June 2018, assigned to V.J. Rada 26 August 2018: "G. has satisfied eir weekly obligation with regard to the FLR and SLR." 3648 called by G. 24 June 2018, assigned to V.J. Rada 26 August 2018: "The fine levied on Corona for late Herald Tournament Regulations is unforgivable for the purposes of R2559." 3652 called by G. 20 July 2018, assigned to Corona 26 August 2018: "If a person pays the (nonzero) upkeep cost for eir Rank 1 facility and then upgrades it to Rank 2 in the same month, e must pay the full Rank 2 upkeep cost to prevent its end-of-the-month destruction." 3653 called by G. 20 July 2018, assigned to Aris 26 August 2018: "If a facility has an upkeep cost of 0 (i.e. null), the owner must announce an attempt to pay 0 in a month (or otherwise publicly note) the upkeep cost of 0 to prevent its end-of-the-month destruction." (13 August 2018: G. submitted a CFJ, then withdrew it) 3655 called by twg 25 August 2018 (barring G.), assigned to Murphy 26 August 2018: "Aris CAN add Proposal 8077 back to the Proposal Pool by announcement." 3656 called by D. Margaux 25 August 2018 (barring twg), assigned to Murphy 26 August 2018: "D. Margaux currently has in eir possession 5 incense." 3657 called by twg 26 August 2018, assigned to G. 26 August 2018: "This message contains a valid Notice of Honour." Highest numbered case: 3657 Context/arguments/evidence are included at the bottom of this report. Recently-delivered verdicts and implications 3638 called by Cuddle Beam 23 May 2018, judged FALSE by V.J. Rada 31 July 2018, reconsidered and judged TRUE 1 August 2018: "The above is a notice of honor." 3654 called by V.J. Rada 23 July 2018, judged FALSE by Murphy 26 August 2018: "Quorum on the Agoran Decisions on whether or not to adopt Proposals 8066-8076 was 5.0." Day Court Judge Recent -- Corona 3641, 3638, 3645, 3652 [06/17 07/08 07/31 08/26] Murphy 3628, 3633, 3654, 3655, 3656 [03/01 07/08 07/31 08/26 08/26] V.J. Rada 3649, 3643, 3638, 3648, 3645 [07/01 07/22 07/31 08/26 08/26] Weekend Court Judge Recent (generally gets half as many cases) -- ATMunn 3648 [06/24] G. 3657 [08/26] D. Margaux (These are informal designations. Requests to join/leave a given court will be noted. Individual requests to be assigned a specific case will generally be honored, even for non-court judges.) Context/arguments/evidence -- *** 3638 content of "the above": This is a notice of honor -1 Agora +1 Agora *** 3638 caller Cuddle Beam's arguments: - It's not a notice of honor because it causes Agora's Honor to go further away from 0 and only an individual action happens per instant as per CFJ 2086, so the -1 would need to happen first, but since it would make Agora's Honor go further than 0, it doesn't happen. - It's a notice of honor because the notice of honor as a single unit is the action, not the individual movements it's composed of. - It's a notice of honor because the above doesn't matter and the player requirement implicitly only applies when a player is targeted. - It's not a notice of honor because it doesn't "provide a reason for specifying that Player" (and I never can, because Agora isn't a player). And the implicit rule mentioned above doesn't exist. *** 3638 judge V.J. Rada's original arguments: I find CFJ 3638 FALSE. The rules require reasons to be stated for a notice of honour. That clearly means additional text to the score change itself. *** 3638 judge V.J. Rada's reconsidered arguments: Rule 2150 states that "A player CAN publish a Notice of Honour" and then specifies that four conditions must be satisfied for a Notice to be _valid_. Valid can be defined as " legally binding due to having been executed in compliance with the law.". Therefore, the rule contemplates the existence of invalid notices of honour with no legally binding effect and valid ones (this is supported by the fact that the rule attaches consequences only to "a valid Notice of Honour" being "published". The statement of this case is "the above is a notice of honour". "[T]he above" is text purporting to be a Notice of Honour raising and lowering Agora's Karma by 1. Whether that Notice is valid is irrelevant to the statement of this case. The four conditions do not need to be satisfied. It is, valid or invalid, a Notice of Honour. This is in accordance with how we otherwise use English. An invalid license is still a license, an expired passpo
OFF: [ADoP] Metareport
=Metareport= You can find an up-to-date version of this report at http://zenith.homelinux.net/adop/report.php Date of last report: 2018-08-01 Date of this report: 2018-08-26 MISCELLANEOUS INFO Filled offices: 13/14 (92.86%) Total officers: 8 Consolidation[1]: 1.62 Late reports: 5/10 (50.00%) [1] This is the number of filled offices divided by the number of officers. At 1, this means that all offices are filled by different players; if it reached the number of filled offices, that would mean that all offices are filled by one player. OFFICES Office Holder[1] Since Last Election - ADoP Murphy 2018-01-182018-01-18 ArbitorMurphy 2018-01-282018-01-28 Assessor *twg2018-07-192018-02-27 Cartographor Trigon 2018-02-24(never) Distributoromd2018-06-15(never) Herald PSS2018-07-152018-07-15 Prime Minister Aris 2018-07-052018-07-23 Promotor Aris 2016-10-212017-09-21 RefereeVJ Rada2018-07-022018-07-02 Registrar *G. 2018-08-232018-07-15 Rulekeepor*(vacant) 2018-07-01[2] 2018-07-08 SpeakerPSS2018-07-232014-04-21 Tailor*twg2018-08-022018-05-09 Treasuror twg2018-06-242018-06-24 [1] * = Interim office (vacant or holder not elected) [2] Vacant since this date [3] Currently imposed WEEKLY REPORTS Office ReportLast Published Late[1] ADoP Offices 2018-08-01[2] !! ArbitorJudicial matters 2018-08-26 Cartographor Land of Arcadia 2018-07-31 !! Herald Matters of Honour 2018-08-16 Promotor Proposal pool 2018-08-19 RefereeRule violations 2018-07-26 !!! Registrar Players, Fora 2018-08-23 Rulekeepor Short Logical Ruleset 2018-06-12 (vacant) Treasuror Coins, other currencies 2018-08-25 [1] ! = 1 period missed, !! = 2, !!! = 3+ [2] Not including this report MONTHLY REPORTS Office ReportLast Published Late Herald Patent titles 2018-07-15 Registrar Player history2018-08-23 Rulekeepor Full Logical Ruleset 2018-06-06 (vacant) Tailor Ribbons 2018-06-12 ! ELECTIONS Office Initiated Phase Candidates (none in progress) UPCOMING ELECTIONS[1] Office Days Until Last Election Promotor 00 Days 2017-09-21 ADoP 00 Days 2018-01-18 Arbitor00 Days 2018-01-28 Assessor 00 Days 2018-02-27 Tailor 00 Days 2018-05-09 [1] Anyone can start an election (with 2 support and also becoming a candidate) 90 days after the previous one (or if it's interim and no election is ongoing). This section shows the 5 elected offices with the most time passed since the last election. ABBREVIATIONS - ADoP Associate Director of Personnel PSS Publius Scribonius Scholasticus RECENT EVENTS (all times UTC) Sun, Jul 01 2018 (01:43:07) - G. resigned from Registrar Sun, Jul 01 2018 (01:43:07) - G. resigned from Rulekeepor Sun, Jul 01 2018 (19:50:55) - Notary repealed by Proposal 8054 Sun, Jul 01 2018 (19:50:55) - Regkeepor repealed by Proposal 8056 Sun, Jul 01 2018 (21:07:02) - G. published the Herald's weekly report Mon, Jul 02 2018 (04:17:43) - Murphy resolved the Referee election, electing VJ Rada Mon, Jul 02 2018 (05:03:56) - Murphy published the Arbitor's weekly report Mon, Jul 02 2018 (05:05:48) - Murphy published the ADoP's weekly report Mon, Jul 02 2018 (05:09:37) - Murphy initiated an election for Herald Mon, Jul 02 2018 (05:09:37) - Murphy initiated an election fo
OFF: [Referee] Weekly Report
I believe my prior action successfully installed me as interim Referee. If I am already the interim Referee, I hereby submit the below as the Referee's Weekly Report. If I am not already the interim Referee, I hereby deputise for the Referee to submit the below as the Referee's Weekly Report. The Police Blotter (Referee's Weekly Report) Date of last report: 26 Jul 2018 Date of this report: 27 Aug 2018 (all times UTC) BLOT HOLDINGS (asset record - self-ratifying) PersonBlots - Murphy 3 V.J. Rada2 Kenyon 10 Corona 7 Publius 1 ATMunn 1 BLOT HISTORY PersonChange Date Reason -- - --- G. -1 03 Jun 2018 with incense Corona -4 12 Jun 2018 with incense (overpaid) ATMunn +2(f) 13 Jun 2018 Late Tailor Monthly Kenyon +2(f) 13 Jun 2018 Late Rulekeepor Monthly Corona +3(f) 13 Jun 2018 Late Treasuror Weekly Kenyon +4(f) 13 Jun 2018 Late Rulekeepor Weekly Corona -3 13 Jun 2018 with incense ATMunn -2 13 Jun 2018 with incense Trigon -3 18 Jun 2018 with incense Corona +2(S) 20 Jun 2018 Late Herald Tournament V.J. Rada +1(S,D)15 Jul 2018 Late Referee Weekly ATMunn +1(S) 15 Jul 2018 Late CFJ Publius+1(S) 15 Jul 2018 Late CFJ Corona +1(f) 26 Jul 2018 Late Registrar Weekly Corona +1(f) 26 Jul 2018 Late Registrar Weekly V.J. Rada -1 26 Jul 2018 Expunged Murphy -1 31 Jul 2018 Expunged Corona +3(f) 26 Aug 2018 Late action on CoE (f)=forgivable by R2557 (D)=loses next monthly salary for noted office by R2559 (S)=Summary Judgement by R2479
