OFF: [Arbitor] Court Gazette
Arbitor's Weekly Report DEADLINES (details below) --- 3795 Assigned to Gaelan OVERDUE Sat 01 Feb 2020 20:40:47 3804 Assigned to omd OVERDUE Sun 02 Feb 2020 03:07:58 3793 Assigned to Alexis Due Sat 15 Feb 2020 21:20:45 3806 Assigned to Gaelan Due Sun 16 Feb 2020 08:54:29 3807 Assigned to omd Due Sun 16 Feb 2020 08:54:58 3808 Assigned to G. Due Sun 16 Feb 2020 08:55:24 INTERESTED JUDGES AND THEIR MOST RECENT CASE --- 3788 Jason 3803 twg 3793 Alexis 3806 Gaelan 3807 omd 3808 G. Occasional: Aris, Falsifian Penalty box: Murphy, D. Margaux. OPEN CASES --- 3808 Assigned to G. [Due Sun 16 Feb 2020 08:55:24] https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/?3808 Jason has, in the last two weeks, made a single intent to enact multiple Editorial Guidelines and twg is both a Supporter and Objector to it. 3807 Assigned to omd [Due Sun 16 Feb 2020 08:54:58] https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/?3807 Jason awarded emself Indigo Glitter today. 3806 Assigned to Gaelan [Due Sun 16 Feb 2020 08:54:29] https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/?3806 In the attached message, I submitted a public petition to the ADoP, as described by Rule 2143. 3804 Assigned to omd [Due Sun 02 Feb 2020 03:07:58] https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/?3804 Gaelan CAN, by announcement, award emself the patent title of 'The Powerless'. 3795 Assigned to Gaelan [Due Sat 01 Feb 2020 20:40:47] https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/?3795 Falsifian would have won the game in the below message if e had originally specified intent to win by apathy without objection. 3793 Assigned to Alexis [Due Sat 15 Feb 2020 21:20:45] https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/?3793 Rance’s master switch is set to Gaelan. RECENTLY-JUDGED CASES --- 3805 Judged TRUE by Aris [Fri 07 Feb 2020] https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/?3805 G really ought to make sure the string doesn’t adversely affect eir archive. 3803 Judged FALSE by twg [Wed 29 Jan 2020] https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/?3803 If a judgment had ruled that the word 'result' in the phrase 'times the adoption index of the result' in Rule 2496 was properly interpreted as 'proposal', it would be POSSIBLE for a player, having given appropriate notice and received Agoran satisfaction, to clean that rule by replacing that word 'result' with 'decision'. 3802 Judged FALSE by twg [Wed 29 Jan 2020] https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/?3802 If a judgment had ruled that the word 'result' in the phrase 'times the adoption index of the result' in Rule 2496 was properly interpreted as 'proposal', it would be POSSIBLE for a player, having given appropriate notice and received Agoran satisfaction, to clean that rule by replacing that word 'result' with 'proposal'. 3801 Judged FALSE by twg [Wed 29 Jan 2020] https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/?3801 It is POSSIBLE for a player, having given appropriate notice and received Agoran satisfaction, to clean Rule 2496 by replacing the word 'result' in the phrase 'times the adoption index of the result' with at least one of 'decision' or 'proposal'. 3800 Judged FALSE by twg [Wed 29 Jan 2020] https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/?3800 It is POSSIBLE for a player, having given appropriate notice and received Agoran satisfaction, to clean Rule 2496 by replacing the word 'result' in the phrase 'times the adoption index of the result' with either of 'decision' or 'proposal', at eir option. 3799 Judged TRUE by G. [Sun 09 Feb 2020] https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/?3799 If the report referenced by my previous CFJ were to ratify, its 'specified time' for the purposes of Rule 1551 would be 00:00 UTC on 2020-01-20. 3798 Judged TRUE by G. [Sun 09 Feb 2020] https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/?3798 I published a Referee report today. 3797 Judged DISMISS by G. [Sat 08 Feb 2020] https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/?3797 Coming into existence is a regulated action. 3796 Judged FALSE by omd [Fri 31 Jan 2020] https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/?3796 Gaelan has the patent title "The Powerless." 3794 Judged FALSE by Alexis [Sat 25 Jan 2020] https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/?3794 G. earned 12 coins for earning a blue ribbon for CFJ 3792. 3792 Judged FALSE by G. [Tue 14 Jan 2020] https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/?3792 The above-quoted message contained a valid Promotor's weekly report. 3791 Judged TRUE by
OFF: [Arbitor] CFJ 3808 Assigned to G.
The below CFJ is 3808. I assign it to G.
status: https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/#3808
=== CFJ 3808 ===
Jason has, in the last two weeks, made a single intent to enact
multiple Editorial Guidelines and twg is both a Supporter and
Objector to it.
==
Caller:Alexis
Judge: G.
==
History:
Called by Alexis: 07 Feb 2020 04:43:31
Assigned to G.: [now]
==
Caller's Arguments:
As discussed, this is likely a single intent/action rather than
multiple. However, beyond that, by trying to support and/or object to
individual components, has twg thereby supported and objected to it?
Or has this failed and e is neither?
Caller's Evidence:
On 1/27/2020 3:43 PM, Jason Cobb wrote:
> I've finally gotten around to drafting these, so I intend, with Agoran
> consent, to enact the following Editorial Guidelines:
>
> [Informal title: "Capitalization"]
>
> {
>
> Capitalization of terms of art should follow, as closely as possible,
> existing usages of the term. In the event of inconsistent usage, or when
> creating new terms of art, prefer using lowercase letters, except when
> the term of art contains a proper noun.
>
> Example: prefer "blots" to "Blots".
>
> Specifically, all dependent action methods besides "Agoran consent" are
> entirely lowercase.
>
> }
>
>
> [Informal title: "Lists"]
>
> {
>
> There are two types of list numbering: ordered and unordered. Ordered
> lists are marked with a marker that monotonically increases with each
> item. Unordered lists are marked with the same marker for each element.
>
> Example: "*" is the marker in:
>
> * Alice
> * Bob
>
>
> There are two types of list formatting: inline and block. Inline lists
> are contained with in the prose, and are not separated from the
> preceding prose by line breaks. Block lists have newlines before and
> after each element. Inline lists should not exceed more than 2 to 3
> elements; if they do, consider making the list a block list.
>
> Inline ordered lists should have the marker "X)", and block ordered
> lists should have the marker "X.", where X is either the number of the
> list item or a letter. Block unordered lists should have the marker "*".
>
> When there are multiple ordered block lists in a single rule, prefer to
> give each of them a different numbering style. For example, one could
> use "1.", "2.", "3." while another uses "A.", "B.", "C.".
>
> }
>
> [I wanted to put something about how each list item should end, but I'm
> not quite sure how to phrase it, and the current rules diverge a good
> bit on the matter.]
>
>
> [Informal title: "Pronouns"]
>
> {
>
> The singular non-gendered pronoun is "e" in the nominative, and "em" in
> the accusative. Do not use "they" as a singular pronoun. Do not use
> "he/him/his" or "she/her/her" as a singular pronoun when referring to a
> person of unknown gender.
>
> }
>
On Thu, 6 Feb 2020 at 19:26, Timon Walshe-Grey wrote:
>
> Jason wrote:
>> Sorry, do people have other support/objections for these? I would prefer
>> not to just let them die.
>
> I object to the capitalisation one for the same reason as Alexis.
>
> I object to the lists one because the example given is very confusing.
> It's not an inline list because it's separated from the surrounding
> prose, and it's not a block list because the elements aren't separated
> by line breaks. And why are those spacing restrictions needed anyway
> when R2429 lets you, as Rulekeepor, change spacing freely?
>
> I support the pronouns one, although I think it could do with amending
> to specify the other declensions ("eir", "eirs", "emself") too.
>
> -twg
==
OFF: [Arbitor] CFJ 3807 Assigned to omd
The below CFJ is 3807. I assign it to omd. status: https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/#3807 === CFJ 3807 === Jason awarded emself Indigo Glitter today. == Caller:twg Judge: omd == History: Called by twg:30 Jan 2020 01:45:12 Assigned to omd: [now] == Caller's Evidence: Jason wrote: > On 1/28/20 10:26 PM, Jason Cobb via agora-official wrote: > >> // >> ID: 8305 >> Title: Keeping Up With the Times >> Adoption index: 3.0 >> Author: Alexis >> Co-authors: >> >> Amend Rule 1367 (Degrees) by replacing "Bachelor" with "Baccalaureate" and >> by replacing "Master" with "Magisteriate". >> >> Rename every instance of the Patent Titles "Bachelor of Nomic" and "Master >> of Nomic" accordingly. >> // > > I award myself Indigo glitter. Caller's Arguments: In contention is whether "renaming" a patent title means revoking it and awarding a new one; a TRUE verdict would also qualify Murphy and Alexis for Indigo. ==
OFF: [Arbitor] CFJ 3806 Assigned to Gaelan
The below CFJ is 3806. I assign it to Gaelan.
status: https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/#3806
=== CFJ 3806 ===
In the attached message, I submitted a public petition to the
ADoP, as described by Rule 2143.
==
Caller:twg
Judge: Gaelan
==
History:
Called by twg:30 Jan 2020 01:37:47
Assigned to Gaelan: [now]
==
Caller's Evidence:
I wrote:
> Gaelan wrote:
>> NOTARY'S REPORT OF JANUARY 29 2020
>
> Ooh, just occurred to me you don't have a Ministry set! That probably
> wants doing. I reckon Economy probably fits best, since the Ministries
> rule specifically calls out contracts ("private enterprise") as falling
> under Economy.
>
> Only the ADoP can do that though, which might be tricky with Murphy
> absent (hope e's ok). Proposal, or is this not that urgent?
>
> -twg
==
OFF: [ADoP, attn Treasuror] Salaries
Proposal 8295 moved office salary reporting to the ADoP. Wed Jan 29 2020 03:26:29 UTC - initial alleged resolution Sat Feb 1 2020 02:24:44 UTC - CoE accepted, corrected resolution I grant 5 coins to each of these players for publishing these reports, except for: [1] Preceded initial alleged resolution, no grant [2] Preceded corrected resolution, no grant (weekly reports, week starting Jan 27 2020) [1] Tue, Jan 28 2020 (16:00:41) - twg published the Treasuror's weekly report [1] Tue, Jan 28 2020 (16:01:17) - twg published the Referee's weekly report [1] Wed, Jan 29 2020 (00:25:34) - Falsifian published the Registrar's weekly report [2] Thu, Jan 30 2020 (01:17:13) - Gaelan published the Notary's weekly report [2] Fri, Jan 31 2020 (02:29:03) - Aris published the proposal pool Sat, Feb 01 2020 (18:37:34) - Alexis published the Herald's weekly report (weekly reports, week starting Feb 3 2020) Wed, Feb 05 2020 (16:31:30) - twg published the Treasuror's weekly report Wed, Feb 05 2020 (16:31:53) - twg published the Referee's weekly report Thu, Feb 06 2020 (18:18:28) - Falsifian published the Registrar's weekly report Sun, Feb 09 2020 (01:26:05) - Gaelan published the Notary's weekly report Sun, Feb 09 2020 (08:58:03) - G. published the Arbitor's weekly report (monthly reports, Jan 2020) [1] Sat, Jan 11 2020 (17:02:25) - Falsifian published the Registrar's monthly report [1] Tue, Jan 14 2020 (00:59:38) - twg published the Tailor's monthly report [1] Sun, Jan 19 2020 (21:09:44) - G. published the Herald's monthly report (monthly reports, Feb 2020) Sun, Feb 02 2020 (00:46:05) - Falsifian published the Registrar's monthly report Sat, Feb 08 2020 (18:13:20) - Alexis published the Herald's monthly report
OFF: [ADoP] Metareport
=Metareport= You can find an up-to-date version of this report at http://zenith.homelinux.net/adop/report.php Date of last report: 2020-01-05 Date of this report: 2020-02-09 MISCELLANEOUS INFO Filled offices: 14/16 (87.50%) Total officers: 9 Consolidation[1]: 1.56 Late reports: 2/10 (20.00%) [1] This is the number of filled offices divided by the number of officers. At 1, this means that all offices are filled by different players; if it reached the number of filled offices, that would mean that all offices are filled by one player. OFFICES Office Holder[1] Since Last Election *(vacant) 2020-01-29[2] (never) ADoP Murphy 2019-07-022019-07-02 ArbitorG. 2019-06-112019-11-23 Assessor Jason 2019-07-092019-11-11 Comptrollor *(vacant) 2020-01-22[2] 2019-05-19 [3] Distributoromd2018-06-15(never)[3] Herald Alexis 2020-01-242020-01-24 Notary Gaelan 2020-01-292018-03-19 Prime Minister*Alexis 2020-01-252019-11-03 Promotor Aris 2016-10-212017-09-21 Referee *twg2019-09-02(ongoing) Registrar Falsifian 2019-05-04(ongoing) Rulekeepor*Jason 2019-12-062018-11-25 SpeakerFalsifian 2020-02-082019-11-05 [3] Tailor twg2020-01-142020-02-09 Treasuror twg2020-01-232020-01-25 [1] * = Interim office (vacant or holder not elected) [2] Vacant since this date [3] Currently imposed WEEKLY REPORTS Office ReportLast Published Late[1] ADoP Offices 2020-01-05[2] !!! ArbitorJudicial matters 2020-02-09 Herald Matters of Honour 2020-02-01 Notary Contracts 2020-02-09 Promotor Proposal pool 2020-01-31 RefereeRule violations 2020-02-05 Registrar Players, Fora 2020-02-06 Rulekeepor Short Logical Ruleset 2020-01-20 ! Treasuror Coins, other currencies 2020-02-05 [1] ! = 1 period missed, !! = 2, !!! = 3+ [2] Not including this report MONTHLY REPORTS Office ReportLast Published Late Herald Patent titles 2020-02-08 Registrar Player history2020-02-02 Rulekeepor Full Logical Ruleset 2019-12-30 ! Tailor Ribbons 2020-01-14 ELECTIONS Office Initiated Phase Candidates Referee2020-01-14 Post-nominating Alexis, twg Registrar 2020-01-11 Post-nominating Falsifian, Gaelan UPCOMING ELECTIONS[1] Office Days Until Last Election Promotor 00 Days 2017-09-21 Notary 00 Days 2018-03-19 Rulekeepor 00 Days 2018-11-25 ADoP 00 Days 2019-07-02 Prime Minister 00 Days 2019-11-03 [1] Anyone can start an election (with 2 support and also becoming a candidate) 90 days after the previous one (or if it's interim and no election is ongoing). This section shows the 5 elected offices with the most time passed since the last election. INTERESTS - Office Interest ADoP Efficiency ArbitorJustice Assessor Efficiency, Legislation Comptrollor Distributor Herald Participation Notary Economy Prime Minister Justice, Efficiency, Legislation, Participation, Economy Promotor Legislation RefereeJustice Registrar Efficiency Rulekeepor Legislation, Participation Speaker Tailor Participation Treasuror Efficiency, Efficiency ABBREVIATIONS - ADoP
OFF: [Assessor, attn Treasuror] Proposal Rewards
Oh, right, I have to do this now: I award omd (11-0)*1.0 = 11 Coins for the adoption of P 8288. I award G. (11-0)*3.0 = 33 Coins for the adoption of P8290. I award Bernie (8-0)*3.0 = 24 Coins for the adoption of P8291. I award Bernie (6-0)*3.0 = 18 Coins for the adoption of P8292. I award Bernie (8-0)*3.0 = 24 Coins for the adoption of P8295. I award Aris (6-1)*1.0 = 5 Coins for the adoption of P8296. I award Aris (11-0)*2.1 = 23.2 -> 23 Coins for the adoption P8297. I award Aris (9-2)*3 = 21 Coins for the adoption of P8301. I award Aris (8-0)*3 = 24 Coins for the adoption of P8302. I award Aris (4-0)*3 = 12 Coins for the adoption of P8303. I award Bernie (8-1)*2 = 14 Coins for the adoption of P8304. I award Alexis (7-1)*3 = 18 Coins for the adoption of P8305. -- Jason Cobb
OFF: [Promotor] Revised Proposal Pool
Revision: At the time of the last Promotor Report, the proposal pool
actually contained the following proposal.
ID Author(s)AITitle
---
pp1Alexis 2.0 Zombie trade
The full text of the aforementioned proposal is included below.
//
ID: pp1
Title: Zombie trade
Adoption index: 2.0
Author: Alexis
Co-authors:
[This proposal allows zombies to collect the fruits of their zombie
auctions, and to allow players to voluntarily enter servitude. Yes, it does
make buying a zombie a risky business!]
Amend Rule 2483 (Economics) by replacing "Agora, players, and contracts"
with "Agora, players, zombie trusts, and contracts".
Amend Rule 2532 (Zombies) by:
- appending "A player CAN, without 3 objections, flip eir own master switch
to any other player. Other players SHOULD NOT object unless they believe
that the intent is part of an attempt to flood Agora with the undead."
- inserting "- flip eir master switch;" in the list after the first item
- replacing "A zombie's master CAN flip that zombie's master switch to
Agora by announcement." with "A zombie's master CAN flip that zombie's
master switch to Agora or to any player who does not own any zombies by
announcement."; and
- replacing "resale value" with "integrity".
Amend Rule 2574 (Zombie Life Cycle) by:
- replacing the first two paragraphs with: {
Any player CAN, with notice, putrefy player who has not made a public
announcement in the past 60 days. When a player is putrefied:
- if e is not a zombie, eir master switch is flipped to Agora; and then
- eir integrity is set to 2.
Integrity is a secured switch for zombies, tracked by the Registrar, with
possible values of the natural numbers and "well-maintained" (default). If
an integrity switch would be modified in a manner that assumes it is
already a number, such as to increase or decrease it, such a modification
leaves "well-maintained" as-is. Whenever a zombie's master switch is
flipped from Agora to a player other than emself, eir integrity is
decreased by 1. At the end of a zombie auction, every zombie that is an
excess lot in that auction has eir integrity decreased by 1.
};
- inserting "- if a zombie is master to another zombie, flipping the second
zombie's master switch to Agora;" after the second item in the list; and
- replacing "resale value" with "integrity" throughout the rule.
Amend Rule 1885 (Zombie Auctions) by:
- replacing "resale value" with "integrity";
- appending "When the winner of a zombie auction pays Agora to fulfill eir
obligation to satisfy eir bid, the coins so transferred are immediately
transferred into trust for the zombie."
Create a new power-2 Rule entitled "Zombie Trusts":
{
Each zombie has a zombie trust, an entity referred to as the "
Trust". To place assets "in trust" to a zombie is to transfer those assets
to that zombie's trust, and similarly for other similar language.
When an active player becomes a zombie, all of eir coins are transferred
into eir zombie trust unless e flipped eir master switch emself and
specified otherwise in the same message. Whenever a zombie becomes active,
all coins held in trust for em are transferred to em immediately before eir
trust ceases to exist.
}
//
