free-vs-competitive please reply!!

2002-07-27 Thread john hull

Howdy:

Here's my justification for this question:  Milton
Friedman declared on C-span that "The Road to Serfdom"
was the book that inspired him to become a
libertarian.  So please consider the following:

In the Road to Serfdom, Hayek takes great pains to
distinguish between free vs. competitive markets.  The
first are considered to be very contrary to, let's
say, American values, while the latter are considered
to be in line with said values.  

Free markets are bad, according to Hayek, e.g. the
monopolist should be the "economic whipping boy" to
such an extent that any monopolist will welcome
competition rather than continue to be a monopolist
and suffer the regulation/abuse of government.

Additionally, Hayek makes clear extensive oppornuties
for government intervention to ensure a competitive
market rather than a free market.  

Please, please, please!!! Will the advocates of the
"free" market, and those uninterested who have an
opinion, please rectify their conception of the free
market with the competitive market so that it doesn't
offend "The Road To Serfdom."

Begging enlightment,

jsh

__
Do You Yahoo!?
Yahoo! Health - Feel better, live better
http://health.yahoo.com




Re: taxi transitional gains trap

2002-07-27 Thread fabio guillermo rojas


> Alex Tabarrok wrote:
> > . . . In addition, there are serious constitutional
> > issues involved in opening the market to free-entry because this would
> > probably constitute a "taking." . . .

Can somebody tell us exactly what the legal status of the medallions
are? Does the state own them, rent them or is it like a driver's
liscence where the has ultimate authority over them? 

Fabio 





Re: taxi transitional gains trap

2002-07-27 Thread Anton Sherwood

Alex Tabarrok wrote:
> . . . In addition, there are serious constitutional
> issues involved in opening the market to free-entry because this would
> probably constitute a "taking." . . .

How about this?  Every day from now on, the city must auction off one
new taxi medallion, no minimum price.  Does the announcement of such a
plan constitute a taking?

-- 
Anton Sherwood, http://www.ogre.nu/