Re: [arts-dev] freqShift in xaStandard and x2artsStandard

2018-09-18 Thread Patrick Eriksson

Dear Jonas,

Some quick feedback, I am on a conference.

The variables that you can retrieve using ARTS-OEM so far are mainly 
atmospheric quantities. To handle instrument variables I maonly left for 
the future.


A constant frequency switch could be handled by shifting the transitions 
as you tried to do. But frequency shifts are in fact an instrument 
parameter, and moving the transitions will not work for frequency 
stretch. So it seems to be time to implement a general way to handle 
instrument variables. I will discuss with Simon, that is also here at 
the conference.


For the moment I suggest that you do repeated linear inversions. And 
adjusting your instrument frequencies after each linear inversion. This 
should work with your extension of xaStandard. After some iterations 
turn off the frequency switch and make a final inversion.


Kind regards,

Patrick



On 2018-09-17 17:22, Jonas Hagen wrote:

Hello ARTS Developers,

I'm trying to retrieve the Frequnecy Shift along with Wind with the ARTS 
internal retrieval. To my understanding, this should work, but support 
in xaStandard and x2artsStandard WSMs is missing and results in an 
error: "Found a retrieval quantity that is not yet handled by internal 
retrievals: Frequency"


For xaStandard(), the a priori Frequency Shift could easily be set to 
zero after line 793 of m_oem.cc along with baseline and pointing.
For x2artsStandard(), maybe a new WSV would make sense (f_shift) and the 
inversion_iterate_agenda would then call 
abs_linesShiftFrequency(f_shift), similar to the baseline stuff?
I tried to implement it myself but got stuck with jacobian_quantities 
and indices in x2artsStandard().


Best regards,
Jonas Hagen
___
arts_dev.mi mailing list
arts_dev.mi@lists.uni-hamburg.de
https://mailman.rrz.uni-hamburg.de/mailman/listinfo/arts_dev.mi

___
arts_dev.mi mailing list
arts_dev.mi@lists.uni-hamburg.de
https://mailman.rrz.uni-hamburg.de/mailman/listinfo/arts_dev.mi


[arts-dev] freqShift in xaStandard and x2artsStandard

2018-09-17 Thread Jonas Hagen

Hello ARTS Developers,

I'm trying to retrieve the Frequnecy Shift along with Wind with the ARTS 
internal retrieval. To my understanding, this should work, but support 
in xaStandard and x2artsStandard WSMs is missing and results in an 
error: "Found a retrieval quantity that is not yet handled by internal 
retrievals: Frequency"


For xaStandard(), the a priori Frequency Shift could easily be set to 
zero after line 793 of m_oem.cc along with baseline and pointing.
For x2artsStandard(), maybe a new WSV would make sense (f_shift) and the 
inversion_iterate_agenda would then call 
abs_linesShiftFrequency(f_shift), similar to the baseline stuff?
I tried to implement it myself but got stuck with jacobian_quantities 
and indices in x2artsStandard().


Best regards,
Jonas Hagen
___
arts_dev.mi mailing list
arts_dev.mi@lists.uni-hamburg.de
https://mailman.rrz.uni-hamburg.de/mailman/listinfo/arts_dev.mi