Re: Macros: sublists question
Just because a positional sublist parameter works for one (or two) thing doesn't mean you're limited to using only positional sublist parameters. Maybe add a keyword TYPE=EQ, or whatever makes sense? Much more typically, the blinders are on the other side, and people forget that a positional parameter would be much better than a required keyword of FUNCTION=foo|baz sas On Wed, Aug 2, 2023 at 2:55 AM Rene BRANDT < 14a2846c6667-dmarc-requ...@listserv.uga.edu> wrote: > Hi David, > > I don't understand your need of the = sign, and a question comes to me : > why not using a 3rd parameter ? > > René > >
Re: Macros: sublists question
Maybe. Have you tried a solution using AINSERT? Or would that get too messy? -- Shmuel (Seymour J.) Metz http://mason.gmu.edu/~smetz3 From: IBM Mainframe Assembler List [ASSEMBLER-LIST@LISTSERV.UGA.EDU] on behalf of Rene BRANDT [14a2846c6667-dmarc-requ...@listserv.uga.edu] Sent: Wednesday, August 2, 2023 2:54 AM To: ASSEMBLER-LIST@LISTSERV.UGA.EDU Subject: Re: Macros: sublists question Hi David, I don't understand your need of the = sign, and a question comes to me : why not using a 3rd parameter ? René Le mardi 1 août 2023 à 23:12:07 UTC+2, David Eisenberg a écrit : Thank you very much, everyone, for these rapid and helpful replies! I hear you all loud and clear... my concept is apparently wishful thinking. I will put the equals sign inside the parentheses so that the parameter is treated as a sublist. David
Re: Macros: sublists question
Hi David, I don't understand your need of the = sign, and a question comes to me : why not using a 3rd parameter ? René Le mardi 1 août 2023 à 23:12:07 UTC+2, David Eisenberg a écrit : Thank you very much, everyone, for these rapid and helpful replies! I hear you all loud and clear... my concept is apparently wishful thinking. I will put the equals sign inside the parentheses so that the parameter is treated as a sublist. David
Re: Macros: sublists question
Thank you very much, everyone, for these rapid and helpful replies! I hear you all loud and clear... my concept is apparently wishful thinking. I will put the equals sign inside the parentheses so that the parameter is treated as a sublist. David
Re: Macros: sublists question
In my quick playing with it, the assembler treats it as a character string. I tried to do something like what David did. When I parsed a value of =(2021,01,31), the assembler returned the entire character string for the value of (1). I stripped off the leading '=' and tried to pass the remaining value, the '(2021,01,31)' to another macro which attempted to break it down as (1), (2), and (3). (1) was assigned the value of '(2021,01,31)'. The other two were null. In the past, when I have had a list like that and it was converted to a character string, I have had to write a mini-parser to look for the commas and pull out the data I wanted. Not sure if this helps, but it has been my experience. Bill Hitefield Dino-Software Corporation 800.480.DINO www.dino-software.com > -Original Message- > From: IBM Mainframe Assembler List > On Behalf Of Steve Thompson > Sent: Tuesday, August 01, 2023 4:51 PM > To: ASSEMBLER-LIST@LISTSERV.UGA.EDU > Subject: Re: Macros: sublists question > > I haven't been dealing with HLASM for a few years, and I know that the new > kids > wanted certain new features > > But look at this from the Macro Processor's viewpoint: > > AAA m=(1,2,,3),=(a,b,c) > > Which one is a "macro" name (or mnemonic) and then which is a keyword and > which one is positional? > > The second one "=(a,b,c)" is missing the keyword. > > So that statement should be flagged with an error. At least, I would expect > that. > > Steve Thompson > > > > On 8/1/2023 4:39 PM, David Eisenberg wrote: > > I hope someone can help me; I have a macro assembler question. > > > > Suppose I write a macro MYMAC receiving two positional parameters: > > > > MYMAC , > > > > The macro will do some date arithmetic. If I invoke the macro this way: > > > > MYMAC (2023,7,31),(2024,1,15)two dates (year,month,day) > > > > then IIUC, and are both sublists. I therefore have no trouble > coding SETA statements so that I can reference the year, month, and day values > individually. > > > > Now suppose I wish to modify the macro parameter syntax by requiring an > equals sign in front of one of the dates (because I need to handle certain > dates > differently). E.g.: > > > > MYMAC (2023,7,31),(=,2024,1,15) > > > > Again, this is simple: I can check for the equals sign and extract the > > numeric > values from the appropriate positions in each sublist. > > > > However... suppose I want to allow this syntax: > > > > MYMAC (2023,7,31),=(2024,1,15) > > > > in which the equals sign precedes a date, but is *outside* of the > > parentheses. > Now IIUC, is no longer a sublist. This instruction: > > > > SETC ''(2,*) > > > > sets to the string (2024,1,15) which *looks* like a sublist, but of > > course > it’s not. Maybe I'm on the wrong track. Bottom line: in my last example, I > can’t > figure out how to extract the year, month, and day values from so that > I can reference them separately. > > > > I apologize if this is basic stuff... I would really appreciate the help! > > > > Thanks, > > > > David
Re: Macros: sublists question
Hi David, As you stated, the parameter is no longer regarded as a sublist by HLASM. Therefore you'll have to do all the parsing yourself. You'll probably have to rely heavily on INDEX, FIND, and substring notation. Depending on the quality and detail of error messages you might want to produce, that could result in a significant amount of code. From what you wrote it appears you have freedom to choose your own syntax. If that is correct, why not choose something that aligns better with HLASM predefined macro invocation behaviour? Your own suggestion was to use: MYMAC (2023,7,31),(=,2024,1,15) I guess you might also choose to keep sublist positions compatible: MYMAC (2023,7,31),(=2024,1,15) Kind regards, Abe Kornelis === Op 01/08/2023 om 22:39 schreef David Eisenberg: > I hope someone can help me; I have a macro assembler question. > > Suppose I write a macro MYMAC receiving two positional parameters: > > MYMAC , > > The macro will do some date arithmetic. If I invoke the macro this way: > > MYMAC (2023,7,31),(2024,1,15)two dates (year,month,day) > > then IIUC, and are both sublists. I therefore have no trouble > coding SETA statements so that I can reference the year, month, and day > values individually. > > Now suppose I wish to modify the macro parameter syntax by requiring an > equals sign in front of one of the dates (because I need to handle certain > dates differently). E.g.: > > MYMAC (2023,7,31),(=,2024,1,15) > > Again, this is simple: I can check for the equals sign and extract the > numeric values from the appropriate positions in each sublist. > > However... suppose I want to allow this syntax: > > MYMAC (2023,7,31),=(2024,1,15) > > in which the equals sign precedes a date, but is *outside* of the > parentheses. Now IIUC, is no longer a sublist. This instruction: > > SETC ''(2,*) > > sets to the string (2024,1,15) which *looks* like a sublist, but of > course it’s not. Maybe I'm on the wrong track. Bottom line: in my last > example, I can’t figure out how to extract the year, month, and day values > from so that I can reference them separately. > > I apologize if this is basic stuff... I would really appreciate the help! > > Thanks, > > David
Re: Macros: sublists question
I think you are SOL on that last argument format (“=(,mm,dd)”), it just isn’t kosher. Use your second format (“(=,,mm,dd)”) if at all politically feasible. Peter From: IBM Mainframe Assembler List On Behalf Of David Eisenberg Sent: Tuesday, August 1, 2023 4:40 PM To: ASSEMBLER-LIST@LISTSERV.UGA.EDU Subject: Macros: sublists question I hope someone can help me; I have a macro assembler question. Suppose I write a macro MYMAC receiving two positional parameters: MYMAC , The macro will do some date arithmetic. If I invoke the macro this way: MYMAC (2023,7,31),(2024,1,15)two dates (year,month,day) then IIUC, and are both sublists. I therefore have no trouble coding SETA statements so that I can reference the year, month, and day values individually. Now suppose I wish to modify the macro parameter syntax by requiring an equals sign in front of one of the dates (because I need to handle certain dates differently). E.g.: MYMAC (2023,7,31),(=,2024,1,15) Again, this is simple: I can check for the equals sign and extract the numeric values from the appropriate positions in each sublist. However... suppose I want to allow this syntax: MYMAC (2023,7,31),=(2024,1,15) in which the equals sign precedes a date, but is *outside* of the parentheses. Now IIUC, is no longer a sublist. This instruction: SETC ''(2,*) sets to the string (2024,1,15) which *looks* like a sublist, but of course it’s not. Maybe I'm on the wrong track. Bottom line: in my last example, I can’t figure out how to extract the year, month, and day values from so that I can reference them separately. I apologize if this is basic stuff... I would really appreciate the help! Thanks, David -- This message and any attachments are intended only for the use of the addressee and may contain information that is privileged and confidential. If the reader of the message is not the intended recipient or an authorized representative of the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any dissemination of this communication is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately by e-mail and delete the message and any attachments from your system.
Re: Macros: sublists question
I haven't been dealing with HLASM for a few years, and I know that the new kids wanted certain new features But look at this from the Macro Processor's viewpoint: AAA m=(1,2,,3),=(a,b,c) Which one is a "macro" name (or mnemonic) and then which is a keyword and which one is positional? The second one "=(a,b,c)" is missing the keyword. So that statement should be flagged with an error. At least, I would expect that. Steve Thompson On 8/1/2023 4:39 PM, David Eisenberg wrote: I hope someone can help me; I have a macro assembler question. Suppose I write a macro MYMAC receiving two positional parameters: MYMAC , The macro will do some date arithmetic. If I invoke the macro this way: MYMAC (2023,7,31),(2024,1,15)two dates (year,month,day) then IIUC, and are both sublists. I therefore have no trouble coding SETA statements so that I can reference the year, month, and day values individually. Now suppose I wish to modify the macro parameter syntax by requiring an equals sign in front of one of the dates (because I need to handle certain dates differently). E.g.: MYMAC (2023,7,31),(=,2024,1,15) Again, this is simple: I can check for the equals sign and extract the numeric values from the appropriate positions in each sublist. However... suppose I want to allow this syntax: MYMAC (2023,7,31),=(2024,1,15) in which the equals sign precedes a date, but is *outside* of the parentheses. Now IIUC, is no longer a sublist. This instruction: SETC ''(2,*) sets to the string (2024,1,15) which *looks* like a sublist, but of course it’s not. Maybe I'm on the wrong track. Bottom line: in my last example, I can’t figure out how to extract the year, month, and day values from so that I can reference them separately. I apologize if this is basic stuff... I would really appreciate the help! Thanks, David
