Re: [bcop] Community statement
Hi Sander, On 30/05/16 15:48, Sander Steffann wrote: >> Thanks for coordinating this and making this statement at the closing >> plenary session. > > Unfortunately the plenary didn't accept the statement as a community > statement/resolution as-is. The good news is that the reason for that is that > they wanted a stronger statement :) Ruediger Volk was the person stating that > on the microphone during the plenary, and he offered to help improve the > language. I talked to Hans Petter Holen about what to do next, and he > suggested taking this to the ripe-list so we can get consensus there and > still turn this into a community-wide supported statement, which I think is > important. > > I suggest Ruediger and I work on the text and then take it straight to the > ripe-list. Doing word-smithing first in BCOP and then on the ripe-list will > probably double the work, and as the BCOP task force already had consensus on > the old version I'd like to take this directly to the superset :-) > > Do you agree with this plan? I was happy to hear that the plenary supported the idea, but asked for a stronger wording of the statement. The procedure you suggested makes sense to me. Best, - Benno -- Benno J. Overeinder NLnet Labs http://www.nlnetlabs.nl/ signature.asc Description: OpenPGP digital signature
Re: [bcop] Community statement
Hi, > Thanks for coordinating this and making this statement at the closing > plenary session. Unfortunately the plenary didn't accept the statement as a community statement/resolution as-is. The good news is that the reason for that is that they wanted a stronger statement :) Ruediger Volk was the person stating that on the microphone during the plenary, and he offered to help improve the language. I talked to Hans Petter Holen about what to do next, and he suggested taking this to the ripe-list so we can get consensus there and still turn this into a community-wide supported statement, which I think is important. I suggest Ruediger and I work on the text and then take it straight to the ripe-list. Doing word-smithing first in BCOP and then on the ripe-list will probably double the work, and as the BCOP task force already had consensus on the old version I'd like to take this directly to the superset :-) Do you agree with this plan? Cheers, Sander signature.asc Description: Message signed with OpenPGP using GPGMail
Re: [bcop] Community statement
Hi Jan, > Since I can't find Benno *and* there are voices of support *and* this > stuff needs to be presented tomorrow morning I will dare to call a > consensus. > > I think that the text in current form is a good message. Great! In that case I will submit it for the closing plenary right now :) Cheers, Sander signature.asc Description: Message signed with OpenPGP using GPGMail
Re: [bcop] Community statement
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA512 On 26/05/16 17:32, Sander Steffann wrote: > Hi, > >> Yes, it is ok with me. > > Thanks > >> I might suggest adding a sentence: >> >> ... can built their future on. It is not sustainable to build an >> IPv4-only network today. The only way to survive ... >> >> Mainly to introduce the word "sustainable" which is a keyword >> for the audience that I am thinking about. > > It already has the word "sustainable" a bit further down. In order > not to complicate the consensus decision for the chairs I would > prefer not to change the text now. Hey, Since I can't find Benno *and* there are voices of support *and* this stuff needs to be presented tomorrow morning I will dare to call a consensus. I think that the text in current form is a good message. Cheers and thnx, Jan -BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE- iQEcBAEBCgAGBQJXRxfkAAoJEGlfIPo1wzUzVjsH/19ge10HNbVXkZYWWDr3kr3j W58zHOyVa0khc5kv2aMxACHC2J2Q/nES5NoRjQuSiFX0ra5XXMQb/i7kE08kL0m4 +Y0iRZ+UNx6eNo/EXNDFRgpqnvh/pM/VUHnl7wV3dm3iTshJdU5iOlZ3gvT3PSS5 nqysONOw45LMnBHS/dZ6WhUrp2W9hB9LTT/PweJiYs0tmM1mXkCQWS2xyjkZLIAh MTOwGGBwHhqOZwdZdRFAx8VEKl2yhdflSMmxad+WLDdYJeWxKCf2xrmOM31WWK85 /sWda/irLFeroehAhoqmCbyN/vYxMiPp3XuCm/vOX4InttBlscm/2vlPboLKKM8= =AW3e -END PGP SIGNATURE-
