Just a bit of Louisville dance community history on this subject—when my
husband started dancing there in the late 70’s and I came in 1982, the Monday
night dance was a mix of English and contra. The default contradance star grip
was the “wrist lock” not hands across as in English. We called it a basket
handhold or wrist grip. Our influence came from New England because our
friend, Norb Spencer, who started the group along with Marie and Frank
(Cassidy?) and who called much of the time—learned in New England. We then
taught it that way when we moved to Cincinnati and started that group.
Louisville only became a “bastion of hands-across-by-default” sometime in the
late 1990’s or ealy 2000’s during my calling hiatus. When I re-entered the
calling scene 6-7 years ago, I was surprised and bemused upon calling in
Louisville to learn of the high regard held for their ‘traditional’
hands-across star style.
Susan McElroy-Marcus
From: Chet Gray via Callers
Sent: Monday, October 10, 2016 9:44 AM
To: Tim Klein
Cc: callers@lists.sharedweight.net
Subject: Re: [Callers] Wrist-Lock Stars
I tend to consider my home dance, Louisville, KY, and nearby Lexington, as two
of the last bastions of hands-across-by-default. Wrist-grip seems to be the
default (for contra; squares are a different matter) even in relatively nearby
cities: Indianapolis, Bloomington, IN, Nashville, Cincinnati. Not sure about
Berea and Somerset, KY, also nearby.
I'd be hesitant to use weekends, Flurry in particular, as bellwethers of what
is typical in anything but weekends. I'd wager that the vast majority of contra
dancers, even habitual dancers, have never been to a dance weekend, perhaps not
even their "home" weekend. Just as there is a sort of "weekend-style" dance
program, there is a "weekend-style" of dancing that is a pidgin not necessarily
representative of any particular regional style.
On Mon, Oct 10, 2016 at 9:41 AM, Tim Klein via Callers
wrote:
I call for dances in Knoxville, TN and occasionally in the surrounding area
(Jonesboro, Chattanooga). I've been dancing here for 30 years. Kaufman was
correct. I recall hands across stars in Knoxville, Atlanta, Brasstown,
Asheville and points between, but wrist grip stars in Lexington, Louisville and
Nashville. I'm certain about Knoxville, but perhaps others can confirm for the
other cities.
The wrist star has gradually taken over as the default in the area, but a
couple of us old-timers are still holding out. I still teach the hands across
star in the pre-dance lesson because it's quicker, but acknowledge that there
are variations. When I call and dance, I still prompt and encourage the
hands-across grip. We've got to hold onto our traditions and fight the
globalization of contra, right?
Of course, there are situations where one variety works better than another -
to/from a move with an adjacent person (star to alemande, courtesy turn to
star) suggests a wrist star, while moves where the contact is across (star old
neighbors to star with new, ladies start star then gents join in) suggest the
hands across. In those cases, I'll explicitly suggest one version in the walk
through.
Tim Klein
Knoxville, TN
--
From: Dave Casserly via Callers
To: John Sweeney
Cc: "callers@lists.sharedweight.net"
Sent: Monday, October 10, 2016 8:37 AM
Subject: Re: [Callers] Wrist-Lock Stars
Jeff Kaufman wrote a paper on regional variations in contra dance. Here's
what he found for wrist-grip stars (page 31 of the link). Basically, they're
common everywhere in the US except in some parts of the South. This is based
on data from ten or more years ago, so I'm not sure if that's still true. I
would not be surprised if it isn't-- there's enough cross-contamination that
wrist-grips could have taken over even in the South. We do have people from
Georgia and North Carolina on the list; hopefully they'll chime in.
-Dave
Washington, DC
On Mon, Oct 10, 2016 at 4:31 AM, John Sweeney via Callers
wrote:
Hi all,
I have been to contra dances and festivals all over America and
everywhere I have danced everyone automatically uses a wrist-lock star
(unless the caller has specified hands-across because of the subsequent
choreography).
But I am constantly challenged in England by people claiming that
wrist-lock stars are not the standard in America.
When I go to somewhere like The Flurry and see 600 people from all
over the country all doing wrist-locks it seems to me that it must be the
standard way of doing things.
And obviously it has been common in America for a long time; this
video is from 1964 in Northern Vermont and shows