Re: [ceph-users] cephfs filesystem layouts : authentication gotchas ?
Just to get more specific: the reason you can apparently write stuff to a file when you can't write to the pool it's stored in is because the file data is initially stored in cache. The flush out to RADOS, when it happens, will fail. It would definitely be preferable if there was some way to immediately return a permission or IO error in this case, but so far we haven't found one; the relevant interfaces just aren't present and it's unclear how to propagate the data back to users in a way that makes sense even if they were. :/ -Greg On Wed, Mar 4, 2015 at 3:37 AM, SCHAER Frederic frederic.sch...@cea.fr wrote: Hi, Many thanks for the explanations. I haven't used the nodcache option when mounting cephfs, it actually got there by default My mount command is/was : # mount -t ceph 1.2.3.4:6789:/ /mnt -o name=puppet,secretfile=./puppet.secret I don't know what causes this option to be default, maybe it's the kernel module I compiled from git (because there is no kmod-ceph or kmod-rbd in any RHEL-like distributions except RHEV), I'll try to update/check ... Concerning the rados pool ls, indeed : I created empty files in the pool, and they were not showing up probably because they were just empty - but when I create a non empty file, I see things in rados ls... Thanks again Frederic -Message d'origine- De : ceph-users [mailto:ceph-users-boun...@lists.ceph.com] De la part de John Spray Envoyé : mardi 3 mars 2015 17:15 À : ceph-users@lists.ceph.com Objet : Re: [ceph-users] cephfs filesystem layouts : authentication gotchas ? On 03/03/2015 15:21, SCHAER Frederic wrote: By the way : looks like the ceph fs ls command is inconsistent when the cephfs is mounted (I used a locally compiled kmod-ceph rpm): [root@ceph0 ~]# ceph fs ls name: cephfs_puppet, metadata pool: puppet_metadata, data pools: [puppet ] (umount /mnt .) [root@ceph0 ~]# ceph fs ls name: cephfs_puppet, metadata pool: puppet_metadata, data pools: [puppet root ] This is probably #10288, which was fixed in 0.87.1 So, I have this pool named root that I added in the cephfs filesystem. I then edited the filesystem xattrs : [root@ceph0 ~]# getfattr -n ceph.dir.layout /mnt/root getfattr: Removing leading '/' from absolute path names # file: mnt/root ceph.dir.layout=stripe_unit=4194304 stripe_count=1 object_size=4194304 pool=root I'm therefore assuming client.puppet should not be allowed to write or read anything in /mnt/root, which belongs to the root pool. but that is not the case. On another machine where I mounted cephfs using the client.puppet key, I can do this : The mount was done with the client.puppet key, not the admin one that is not deployed on that node : 1.2.3.4:6789:/ on /mnt type ceph (rw,relatime,name=puppet,secret=hidden,nodcache) [root@dev7248 ~]# echo not allowed /mnt/root/secret.notfailed [root@dev7248 ~]# [root@dev7248 ~]# cat /mnt/root/secret.notfailed not allowed This is data you're seeing from the page cache, it hasn't been written to RADOS. You have used the nodcache setting, but that doesn't mean what you think it does (it was about caching dentries, not data). It's actually not even used in recent kernels (http://tracker.ceph.com/issues/11009). You could try the nofsc option, but I don't know exactly how much caching that turns off -- the safer approach here is probably to do your testing using I/Os that have O_DIRECT set. And I can even see the xattrs inherited from the parent dir : [root@dev7248 ~]# getfattr -n ceph.file.layout /mnt/root/secret.notfailed getfattr: Removing leading '/' from absolute path names # file: mnt/root/secret.notfailed ceph.file.layout=stripe_unit=4194304 stripe_count=1 object_size=4194304 pool=root Whereas on the node where I mounted cephfs as ceph admin, I get nothing : [root@ceph0 ~]# cat /mnt/root/secret.notfailed [root@ceph0 ~]# ls -l /mnt/root/secret.notfailed -rw-r--r-- 1 root root 12 Mar 3 15:27 /mnt/root/secret.notfailed After some time, the file also gets empty on the puppet client host : [root@dev7248 ~]# cat /mnt/root/secret.notfailed [root@dev7248 ~]# (but the metadata remained ?) Right -- eventually the cache goes away, and you see the true (empty) state of the file. Also, as an unpriviledged user, I can get ownership of a secret file by changing the extended attribute : [root@dev7248 ~]# setfattr -n ceph.file.layout.pool -v puppet /mnt/root/secret.notfailed [root@dev7248 ~]# getfattr -n ceph.file.layout /mnt/root/secret.notfailed getfattr: Removing leading '/' from absolute path names # file: mnt/root/secret.notfailed ceph.file.layout=stripe_unit=4194304 stripe_count=1 object_size=4194304 pool=puppet Well, you're not really getting ownership of anything here: you're modifying the file's metadata, which you are entitled to do (pool permissions have nothing to do with file metadata). There was a recent bug where a file's pool layout could
Re: [ceph-users] cephfs filesystem layouts : authentication gotchas ?
Hi, Many thanks for the explanations. I haven't used the nodcache option when mounting cephfs, it actually got there by default My mount command is/was : # mount -t ceph 1.2.3.4:6789:/ /mnt -o name=puppet,secretfile=./puppet.secret I don't know what causes this option to be default, maybe it's the kernel module I compiled from git (because there is no kmod-ceph or kmod-rbd in any RHEL-like distributions except RHEV), I'll try to update/check ... Concerning the rados pool ls, indeed : I created empty files in the pool, and they were not showing up probably because they were just empty - but when I create a non empty file, I see things in rados ls... Thanks again Frederic -Message d'origine- De : ceph-users [mailto:ceph-users-boun...@lists.ceph.com] De la part de John Spray Envoyé : mardi 3 mars 2015 17:15 À : ceph-users@lists.ceph.com Objet : Re: [ceph-users] cephfs filesystem layouts : authentication gotchas ? On 03/03/2015 15:21, SCHAER Frederic wrote: By the way : looks like the ceph fs ls command is inconsistent when the cephfs is mounted (I used a locally compiled kmod-ceph rpm): [root@ceph0 ~]# ceph fs ls name: cephfs_puppet, metadata pool: puppet_metadata, data pools: [puppet ] (umount /mnt .) [root@ceph0 ~]# ceph fs ls name: cephfs_puppet, metadata pool: puppet_metadata, data pools: [puppet root ] This is probably #10288, which was fixed in 0.87.1 So, I have this pool named root that I added in the cephfs filesystem. I then edited the filesystem xattrs : [root@ceph0 ~]# getfattr -n ceph.dir.layout /mnt/root getfattr: Removing leading '/' from absolute path names # file: mnt/root ceph.dir.layout=stripe_unit=4194304 stripe_count=1 object_size=4194304 pool=root I'm therefore assuming client.puppet should not be allowed to write or read anything in /mnt/root, which belongs to the root pool. but that is not the case. On another machine where I mounted cephfs using the client.puppet key, I can do this : The mount was done with the client.puppet key, not the admin one that is not deployed on that node : 1.2.3.4:6789:/ on /mnt type ceph (rw,relatime,name=puppet,secret=hidden,nodcache) [root@dev7248 ~]# echo not allowed /mnt/root/secret.notfailed [root@dev7248 ~]# [root@dev7248 ~]# cat /mnt/root/secret.notfailed not allowed This is data you're seeing from the page cache, it hasn't been written to RADOS. You have used the nodcache setting, but that doesn't mean what you think it does (it was about caching dentries, not data). It's actually not even used in recent kernels (http://tracker.ceph.com/issues/11009). You could try the nofsc option, but I don't know exactly how much caching that turns off -- the safer approach here is probably to do your testing using I/Os that have O_DIRECT set. And I can even see the xattrs inherited from the parent dir : [root@dev7248 ~]# getfattr -n ceph.file.layout /mnt/root/secret.notfailed getfattr: Removing leading '/' from absolute path names # file: mnt/root/secret.notfailed ceph.file.layout=stripe_unit=4194304 stripe_count=1 object_size=4194304 pool=root Whereas on the node where I mounted cephfs as ceph admin, I get nothing : [root@ceph0 ~]# cat /mnt/root/secret.notfailed [root@ceph0 ~]# ls -l /mnt/root/secret.notfailed -rw-r--r-- 1 root root 12 Mar 3 15:27 /mnt/root/secret.notfailed After some time, the file also gets empty on the puppet client host : [root@dev7248 ~]# cat /mnt/root/secret.notfailed [root@dev7248 ~]# (but the metadata remained ?) Right -- eventually the cache goes away, and you see the true (empty) state of the file. Also, as an unpriviledged user, I can get ownership of a secret file by changing the extended attribute : [root@dev7248 ~]# setfattr -n ceph.file.layout.pool -v puppet /mnt/root/secret.notfailed [root@dev7248 ~]# getfattr -n ceph.file.layout /mnt/root/secret.notfailed getfattr: Removing leading '/' from absolute path names # file: mnt/root/secret.notfailed ceph.file.layout=stripe_unit=4194304 stripe_count=1 object_size=4194304 pool=puppet Well, you're not really getting ownership of anything here: you're modifying the file's metadata, which you are entitled to do (pool permissions have nothing to do with file metadata). There was a recent bug where a file's pool layout could be changed even if it had data, but that was about safety rather than permissions. Final question for those that read down here : it appears that before creating the cephfs filesystem, I used the puppet pool to store a test rbd instance. And it appears I cannot get the list of cephfs objects in that pool, whereas I can get those that are on the newly created root pool : [root@ceph0 ~]# rados -p puppet ls test.rbd rbd_directory [root@ceph0 ~]# rados -p root ls 10a. 10b. Bug, or feature ? I didn't see anything in your earlier steps that would have led to any objects
[ceph-users] cephfs filesystem layouts : authentication gotchas ?
Hi, I am attempting to test the cephfs filesystem layouts. I created a user with rights to write only in one pool : client.puppet key:zzz caps: [mon] allow r caps: [osd] allow rwx pool=puppet I also created another pool in which I would assume this user is allowed to do nothing after I successfully configure things. By the way : looks like the ceph fs ls command is inconsistent when the cephfs is mounted (I used a locally compiled kmod-ceph rpm): [root@ceph0 ~]# ceph fs ls name: cephfs_puppet, metadata pool: puppet_metadata, data pools: [puppet ] (umount /mnt ...) [root@ceph0 ~]# ceph fs ls name: cephfs_puppet, metadata pool: puppet_metadata, data pools: [puppet root ] So, I have this pool named root that I added in the cephfs filesystem. I then edited the filesystem xattrs : [root@ceph0 ~]# getfattr -n ceph.dir.layout /mnt/root getfattr: Removing leading '/' from absolute path names # file: mnt/root ceph.dir.layout=stripe_unit=4194304 stripe_count=1 object_size=4194304 pool=root I'm therefore assuming client.puppet should not be allowed to write or read anything in /mnt/root, which belongs to the root pool... but that is not the case. On another machine where I mounted cephfs using the client.puppet key, I can do this : The mount was done with the client.puppet key, not the admin one that is not deployed on that node : 1.2.3.4:6789:/ on /mnt type ceph (rw,relatime,name=puppet,secret=hidden,nodcache) [root@dev7248 ~]# echo not allowed /mnt/root/secret.notfailed [root@dev7248 ~]# [root@dev7248 ~]# cat /mnt/root/secret.notfailed not allowed And I can even see the xattrs inherited from the parent dir : [root@dev7248 ~]# getfattr -n ceph.file.layout /mnt/root/secret.notfailed getfattr: Removing leading '/' from absolute path names # file: mnt/root/secret.notfailed ceph.file.layout=stripe_unit=4194304 stripe_count=1 object_size=4194304 pool=root Whereas on the node where I mounted cephfs as ceph admin, I get nothing : [root@ceph0 ~]# cat /mnt/root/secret.notfailed [root@ceph0 ~]# ls -l /mnt/root/secret.notfailed -rw-r--r-- 1 root root 12 Mar 3 15:27 /mnt/root/secret.notfailed After some time, the file also gets empty on the puppet client host : [root@dev7248 ~]# cat /mnt/root/secret.notfailed [root@dev7248 ~]# (but the metadata remained ?) Also, as an unpriviledged user, I can get ownership of a secret file by changing the extended attribute : [root@dev7248 ~]# setfattr -n ceph.file.layout.pool -v puppet /mnt/root/secret.notfailed [root@dev7248 ~]# getfattr -n ceph.file.layout /mnt/root/secret.notfailed getfattr: Removing leading '/' from absolute path names # file: mnt/root/secret.notfailed ceph.file.layout=stripe_unit=4194304 stripe_count=1 object_size=4194304 pool=puppet But fortunately, I haven't succeeded yet (?) in reading that file... My question therefore is : what am I doing wrong ? Final question for those that read down here : it appears that before creating the cephfs filesystem, I used the puppet pool to store a test rbd instance. And it appears I cannot get the list of cephfs objects in that pool, whereas I can get those that are on the newly created root pool : [root@ceph0 ~]# rados -p puppet ls test.rbd rbd_directory [root@ceph0 ~]# rados -p root ls 10a. 10b. Bug, or feature ? Thanks regards P.S : ceph release : [root@dev7248 ~]# rpm -qa '*ceph*' kmod-libceph-3.10.0-0.1.20150130gitee04310.el7.centos.x86_64 libcephfs1-0.87-0.el7.centos.x86_64 ceph-common-0.87-0.el7.centos.x86_64 ceph-0.87-0.el7.centos.x86_64 kmod-ceph-3.10.0-0.1.20150130gitee04310.el7.centos.x86_64 ceph-fuse-0.87.1-0.el7.centos.x86_64 python-ceph-0.87-0.el7.centos.x86_64 ___ ceph-users mailing list ceph-users@lists.ceph.com http://lists.ceph.com/listinfo.cgi/ceph-users-ceph.com
Re: [ceph-users] cephfs filesystem layouts : authentication gotchas ?
On 03/03/2015 15:21, SCHAER Frederic wrote: By the way : looks like the “ceph fs ls” command is inconsistent when the cephfs is mounted (I used a locally compiled kmod-ceph rpm): [root@ceph0 ~]# ceph fs ls name: cephfs_puppet, metadata pool: puppet_metadata, data pools: [puppet ] (umount /mnt …) [root@ceph0 ~]# ceph fs ls name: cephfs_puppet, metadata pool: puppet_metadata, data pools: [puppet root ] This is probably #10288, which was fixed in 0.87.1 So, I have this pool named “root” that I added in the cephfs filesystem. I then edited the filesystem xattrs : [root@ceph0 ~]# getfattr -n ceph.dir.layout /mnt/root getfattr: Removing leading '/' from absolute path names # file: mnt/root ceph.dir.layout=stripe_unit=4194304 stripe_count=1 object_size=4194304 pool=root I’m therefore assuming client.puppet should not be allowed to write or read anything in /mnt/root, which belongs to the “root” pool… but that is not the case. On another machine where I mounted cephfs using the client.puppet key, I can do this : The mount was done with the client.puppet key, not the admin one that is not deployed on that node : 1.2.3.4:6789:/ on /mnt type ceph (rw,relatime,name=puppet,secret=hidden,nodcache) [root@dev7248 ~]# echo not allowed /mnt/root/secret.notfailed [root@dev7248 ~]# [root@dev7248 ~]# cat /mnt/root/secret.notfailed not allowed This is data you're seeing from the page cache, it hasn't been written to RADOS. You have used the nodcache setting, but that doesn't mean what you think it does (it was about caching dentries, not data). It's actually not even used in recent kernels (http://tracker.ceph.com/issues/11009). You could try the nofsc option, but I don't know exactly how much caching that turns off -- the safer approach here is probably to do your testing using I/Os that have O_DIRECT set. And I can even see the xattrs inherited from the parent dir : [root@dev7248 ~]# getfattr -n ceph.file.layout /mnt/root/secret.notfailed getfattr: Removing leading '/' from absolute path names # file: mnt/root/secret.notfailed ceph.file.layout=stripe_unit=4194304 stripe_count=1 object_size=4194304 pool=root Whereas on the node where I mounted cephfs as ceph admin, I get nothing : [root@ceph0 ~]# cat /mnt/root/secret.notfailed [root@ceph0 ~]# ls -l /mnt/root/secret.notfailed -rw-r--r-- 1 root root 12 Mar 3 15:27 /mnt/root/secret.notfailed After some time, the file also gets empty on the “puppet client” host : [root@dev7248 ~]# cat /mnt/root/secret.notfailed [root@dev7248 ~]# (but the metadata remained ?) Right -- eventually the cache goes away, and you see the true (empty) state of the file. Also, as an unpriviledged user, I can get ownership of a “secret” file by changing the extended attribute : [root@dev7248 ~]# setfattr -n ceph.file.layout.pool -v puppet /mnt/root/secret.notfailed [root@dev7248 ~]# getfattr -n ceph.file.layout /mnt/root/secret.notfailed getfattr: Removing leading '/' from absolute path names # file: mnt/root/secret.notfailed ceph.file.layout=stripe_unit=4194304 stripe_count=1 object_size=4194304 pool=puppet Well, you're not really getting ownership of anything here: you're modifying the file's metadata, which you are entitled to do (pool permissions have nothing to do with file metadata). There was a recent bug where a file's pool layout could be changed even if it had data, but that was about safety rather than permissions. Final question for those that read down here : it appears that before creating the cephfs filesystem, I used the “puppet” pool to store a test rbd instance. And it appears I cannot get the list of cephfs objects in that pool, whereas I can get those that are on the newly created “root” pool : [root@ceph0 ~]# rados -p puppet ls test.rbd rbd_directory [root@ceph0 ~]# rados -p root ls 10a. 10b. Bug, or feature ? I didn't see anything in your earlier steps that would have led to any objects in the puppet pool. To get closer to the effect you're looking for, you probably need to combine your pool settings with some permissions on the folders, and do your I/O as a user other than root -- your user-level permissions would protect your metadata, and your pool permissions would protect your data. There are also plans to make finer grained access control for the metadata, but that's not there yet. Cheers, John ___ ceph-users mailing list ceph-users@lists.ceph.com http://lists.ceph.com/listinfo.cgi/ceph-users-ceph.com