date:20220929

This is an automated email from the ASF dual-hosted git repository.

dblevins pushed a commit to branch main
in repository https://gitbox.apache.org/repos/asf/tomee.git


The following commit(s) were added to refs/heads/main by this push:
 new 0b0273009b Philosophy and goals of the itests
0b0273009b is described below

commit 0b0273009b5853fa5aedc52b9604ba853448418a
Author: David Blevins 
AuthorDate: Thu Sep 29 23:07:53 2022 -0500

Philosophy and goals of the itests
---
 itests/README.adoc | 23 +++
 1 file changed, 23 insertions(+)

diff --git a/itests/README.adoc b/itests/README.adoc
new file mode 100644
index 00..e1b658bc88
--- /dev/null
+++ b/itests/README.adoc
@@ -0,0 +1,23 @@
+# iTest
+
+The goal of the itests are to test and use the TomEE binaries exactly how 
users use them; unpack the server, update configurations, deploy an application 
and send it requests.  When tests are done, we're asserting responses, files on 
disk, log output and all expected behavior of the server.
+
+## Why not use Arquillian?
+
+The focus of Arquillian is to create tests for applications that are 
abstracted from the server details.  iTests are the opposite -- we're testing 
the server itself and cannot do that while also abstracting ourselves from the 
server.
+
+It's the job of an iTest to manipulate the server exactly the way users would 
and assert that the user experience is what we want it to be.  Some examples:
+
+- If we tell users, "throw this file in this directory and it should work", 
there is ideally an itest that sets up a server, puts that file in the 
directory and asserts it does in fact work.
+- If we tell a user, "turn on debug logging and you should see these details", 
there is ideally an itest that tries this and asserts the expected debug 
messages do show up.
+- If we tell a user, "set this flag to X and it should enable Y behavior", 
ideally there is an itest that not only tests the behavior when the flag is 
enabled, but tests the behavior when the flag is not enabled and possibly even 
tests the error handling when the flag is set to an invalid value.
+
+We're not testing applications, we're testing the server.  We don't want to be 
abstracted from the server and we don't any magic plumbing like Arquillian's 
adapters, deployment code or local/remote testing code.  Arquillian is an 
awesome hammer, but this problem is not a nail.  It solves a different problem.
+
+## Why no dependencies on internals?
+
+While we do not want to be abstracted from the server, we still want to limit 
ourselves to using the server the way users would use it.  We should not touch 
any internal API that is forbidden or off-limits to users.  iTests should only 
use server features that are supported and considered user-facing.  Should 
users be using the code in openejb-core? No, they should not, so neither should 
itests.  Remember, when you're writing an itest the code inside the server is 
not "our" code -- you n [...]
+
+Not only is this good for ensuring the user experience always works as 
expected, it also means we can theoretically throw alway all the existing TomEE 
code, rewrite it entirely and verify user's applications and configuration 
file's still work.  There are advantages to testing strictly from the user's 
perspective and not digging into guts like unit tests do.  If we wanted to do 
something large and aggressive like cut the size of the server in half, the 
itests should continue to work with [...]
+
+A good itest should work even if the server is entirely rewritten.

Jenkins build is back to stable : TomEE » tomee-8.x-build-full #209

2022-09-29 Thread Apache Jenkins Server

See

Jenkins build is back to stable : TomEE » tomee-8.x-build-full » TomEE :: Server :: Http #209

2022-09-29 Thread Apache Jenkins Server

See

Jenkins build is back to stable : TomEE » tomee-8.x-build-full » TomEE :: Server :: EJBd #209

2022-09-29 Thread Apache Jenkins Server

See

Build failed in Jenkins: TomEE » master-build-full #755

2022-09-29 Thread Apache Jenkins Server

See 


Changes:


--
[...truncated 51.73 MB...]
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
No mail will be sent out, as 'TomEE Â» master-build-full Â» TomEE :: Arquillian 
Adaptors Parent :: Sample :: Moviefun #755' does not have a result yet. Please 
make sure you set a proper result in case of pipeline/build scripts.
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
No mail will be sent out, as 'TomEE Â» master-build-full Â» TomEE :: TCK :: 
MicroProfile Rest Client TCK #755' does not have a result yet. Please make sure 
you set a proper result in case of pipeline/build scripts.
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate jdk_11_latest
ERROR: builds42 is offline; cannot locate maven_3_latest
No mail will be sent out, as 'TomEE Â» master-build-full Â» TomEE :: TCK :: 
MicroProfile Fault Tolerance TCK #755' does not have a result yet. Please make 
sure you set a proper result in case of pip

Jenkins build is still unstable: TomEE » master-build-full » TomEE :: TCK :: MicroProfile JWT TCK #755

2022-09-29 Thread Apache Jenkins Server

See

Jenkins build is still unstable: TomEE » master-build-full » TomEE :: TCK :: Bean Validation TomEE #755

2022-09-29 Thread Apache Jenkins Server

See

Jenkins build is still unstable: TomEE » master-build-full » TomEE :: TCK :: MicroProfile Config TCK #755

2022-09-29 Thread Apache Jenkins Server

See

Jenkins build is still unstable: TomEE » master-build-full » TomEE :: Examples :: MTOM #755

2022-09-29 Thread Apache Jenkins Server

See

Jenkins build is still unstable: TomEE » master-build-full » TomEE :: Examples :: Simple Remote tomcat-users.xml #755

2022-09-29 Thread Apache Jenkins Server

See

Jenkins build is still unstable: TomEE » master-build-full » TomEE :: Examples :: MP REST JWT PRINCIPAL #755

2022-09-29 Thread Apache Jenkins Server

See

Jenkins build is still unstable: TomEE » master-build-full » TomEE :: Server :: EJBd #755

2022-09-29 Thread Apache Jenkins Server

See

Jenkins build is still unstable: TomEE » master-build-full » TomEE :: Web Examples :: EJB WebService with WS-Security #755

2022-09-29 Thread Apache Jenkins Server

See

Jenkins build is still unstable: TomEE » master-build-full » TomEE :: Examples :: MP REST JWT Public Key #755

2022-09-29 Thread Apache Jenkins Server

See

Jenkins build is still unstable: TomEE » master-build-full » TomEE :: Examples :: MP REST JWT JWK #755

2022-09-29 Thread Apache Jenkins Server

See

Build failed in Jenkins: TomEE » master-owasp-check #245

2022-09-29 Thread Apache Jenkins Server

See 


Changes:

[Richard Zowalla] TOMEE-4054 - Snakeyaml 1.33

[Richard Zowalla] Regenerated BOM files after latest dependency updates

[Richard Zowalla] Revert CXF upgrade back to 3.5.0


--
[...truncated 466.54 KB...]
[INFO] TomEE :: BOMs :: TomEE Plus  SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: BOMs :: TomEE MicroProfile API  SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: BOMs :: TomEE WebProfile API .. SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: BOMs :: TomEE Plume API ... SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: BOMs :: TomEE Plus API  SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: iTests :: Server Composer . SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: iTests :: Server Composer . SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: TomEE :: Apache TomEE . SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: iTests :: Server Composer . SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Server :: Daemon .. SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Assembly .. SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Assembly :: Standalone  SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Arquillian Adaptors Parent  SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Arquillian Adaptors Parent :: Common .. SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Arquillian Adaptors Parent :: TomEE Common  SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: iTests :: Failover  SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: iTests :: Legacy Client ... SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: iTests :: Legacy Server ... SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: iTests :: Web . SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: iTests :: JAX-RS .. SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Maven Plugins . SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Maven Plugins :: Util . SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Maven Plugins :: TomEE Maven Plugin ... SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Utils :: LiveReload ... SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Maven Plugins :: TomEE Embedded Maven Plugin SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Maven Plugins :: OpenEJB Embedded Maven Plugin SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Maven Plugins :: TomEE Webapp Archetype ... SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Maven Plugins :: jars.txt Maven Plugin  SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Maven Plugins :: ApplicationComposer Maven Plugin SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Gradle Plugins  SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Gradle Plugins :: TomEE Embedded .. SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Container :: JUnit  SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Container :: JUnit 5 .. SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Container :: JUnit 5 :: Backward Compatibility SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Server :: ActiveMQ  SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Server :: Derby Network Service ... SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Server :: Common CLI .. SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Server :: SSH . SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Server :: BoneCP .. SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Server :: Hessian . SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Assembly :: All In One EJB Lite jar ... SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Utils :: TomEE Webapps-based Deployer EJB . SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: TCK ... SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: TCK :: Common . SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Arquillian Adaptors Parent :: Transaction Provider SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Arquillian Adaptors Parent :: OpenEJB Container SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: TCK :: CDI Embedded ... SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Arquillian Adaptors Parent :: Remote .. SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: TCK :: CDI TomEE .. SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: TCK :: CDI TCK Signature Tests  SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: TCK :: Bean Validation Embedded ... SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: TCK :: Bean Validation TomEE .. SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: TCK :: Bean Validation TCK Signature tests  SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: TCK :: MicroProfile ... SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: TCK :: MicroProfile Config TCK  SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: TCK :: MicroProfile JWT TCK ... SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: TCK :: MicroProfile Health TCK  SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: TCK :: MicroProfile Metrics TCK ... SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: TCK :: MicroProfile Rest Client TCK ... SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Arquillian Adaptors Parent :: ZipLock . SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: TCK :: MicroProfile Open API TCK .. SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: TCK :: MicroProfile Fault Tolerance TCK ... SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Arquillian Adaptors Parent :: Embedded Adaptor SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Arquillian Adaptors Parent :: Webapp Remote SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Arquillian Adaptors Parent :: Tests ... SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Arquillian Adaptors Parent :: Tests :: Web Profile SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Arquillian Adaptors Parent :: Tests :: JAXRS SKIPPED
[INFO] TomEE :: Arquillian Adaptors Parent :: Test