Re: State of FreeCalypso

2015-04-28 Thread Stefan Monnier
>> but still very different from the the goals of Free Software.
> Are they very different?

As long as this FreeCalypso code stays very obscure and marginal, in
practice the difference might not matter that much.
I think what you're saying is that from an Open Source point of view,
his effort is just fine.  But from a Free Software point of view, his
effort is deeply flawed unless/until he/we start lobbying the copyright
holder to Free the original code.


Stefan


___
Openmoko community mailing list
community@lists.openmoko.org
http://lists.openmoko.org/mailman/listinfo/community


Re: State of FreeCalypso

2015-04-28 Thread mail
>FWIW, last I checked, his work does sadly not enjoy any of those
>freedoms.  Yes, you *can* look at the code, change it, and redistribute
>it, but you're not legally allowed to because the source code he has
>is proprietary.
>

le sigh

Imagine you are broke and starving hungry (that's quite easy where I live)

You notice that the local supermarket has forgotten to lock up the trash area, 
where they chuck out perfectly good food coz it's gone past an arbitrary sell 
by date.

You load up a bag with vegetables and you now have some appealing choices:-

1. you can eat the stuff raw or cook it
2. you could add a load of crap to it as in a frozen ready meal or prepare in a 
wholesome recipe
3. you can share a meal with your starving spouse and mewling children
4.  I dunno but I'm sure there is a four and more

So you were slightly naughty and trespassed, you grabbed something that wasn't 
really yours, but it was **going to waste** and **no one really cares**. NOBODY 
loses and a one plus person gets a meal. 


>Much better than running some binary blob you can't even look at, yes,

Yes indeed, very much better

>but still very different from the the goals of Free Software.
>

Are they very different? Well when are these different goals gonna lead 
anywhere in the case of a cell phone? I don't see anything other than 
freecalypso.

--
David Matthews
m...@dmatthews.org

___
Openmoko community mailing list
community@lists.openmoko.org
http://lists.openmoko.org/mailman/listinfo/community