Re: OT:administrivia -- a request to reduce duplicate mails

2007-12-05 Thread Lars Hallberg

Joshua Layne skrev:


'trivial' might be a tad strong here :)  I, for example, have no idea how
to do this with exim4 - I have no doubt it is possible though.  I'll see
what my brain extender (aka google) turns up.


It is trivial for the software... that does not necessarily make it 
trivial to get any given software to do it :-)


/LaH


___
OpenMoko community mailing list
community@lists.openmoko.org
http://lists.openmoko.org/mailman/listinfo/community


Re: OT:administrivia -- a request to reduce duplicate mails

2007-12-05 Thread Joshua Layne


On Wed, 05 Dec 2007 22:57:54 +0100, Lars Hallberg [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
 Joshua Layne skrev:
 Hi all,
 I am subscribed to several of the openmoko lists.  When someone copies
 multiple lists on a message, I get all the copies (usually 3 for some
 reason).  Worse, when anyone replies to the initial mail, they reply all
 and I get another full set of mails.

 I realize that there are valid reasons for crossposting some of the
 content
 (particularly by core devs).  Could I request the following?

 Send one email to each list (instead of copying all lists on a single
 email)
 
 That's a bad idea for two reasons:
 
 1) If the message was appropriate for cross posting, so is the
 discussion. Else we get a fragmented discussion repeating the same
 points in all lists, making thing worse for people reading all lists.
 

ok, I didn't think that all the way through.  I agree.

 2) If it is the same mail it is trivial for mail software to detect
 duplicates and remove them. If its different mail the problem get much
 harder to handle technically.

'trivial' might be a tad strong here :)  I, for example, have no idea how
to do this with exim4 - I have no doubt it is possible though.  I'll see
what my brain extender (aka google) turns up.

The first rebuttal was reason enough - I withdraw the 'rfc'.

thanks for the comments.
Josh


___
OpenMoko community mailing list
community@lists.openmoko.org
http://lists.openmoko.org/mailman/listinfo/community


Re: OT:administrivia -- a request to reduce duplicate mails

2007-12-05 Thread Lars Hallberg

Joshua Layne skrev:

Hi all,
I am subscribed to several of the openmoko lists.  When someone copies
multiple lists on a message, I get all the copies (usually 3 for some
reason).  Worse, when anyone replies to the initial mail, they reply all
and I get another full set of mails.

I realize that there are valid reasons for crossposting some of the content
(particularly by core devs).  Could I request the following?

Send one email to each list (instead of copying all lists on a single
email)


That's a bad idea for two reasons:

1) If the message was appropriate for cross posting, so is the 
discussion. Else we get a fragmented discussion repeating the same 
points in all lists, making thing worse for people reading all lists.


2) If it is the same mail it is trivial for mail software to detect 
duplicates and remove them. If its different mail the problem get much 
harder to handle technically.


/LaH


___
OpenMoko community mailing list
community@lists.openmoko.org
http://lists.openmoko.org/mailman/listinfo/community