I don't know how far anecdotal evidence can resolve this issue but here is
my experience.
I was a verizon DSL subscriber from the beginning in the Washington DC
area. I was paying for 3MB, Verizon stated that they could only give me
1.5MB. and my usual experience ( from the Verizon speed test site was .4 to
.8 MB, I rarely got the 1.5 that I was promised and paying for. After many
conversations with various Verizon Tech Support people, I am highly aware
that that DSL speed is highly dependent on distance from the local central
office. Therefore, other people may have a different average speed from
their DSL
When Verizon informed that they were not likely to get higher speed FIOS to
my area in the next 2 years, I switched to Cox Cable.
Cox promised by 5MB and I now actually get from 7MB to 11MB at all times.
(using the same speed test site.) The speed difference is incredible.
I will add that I found the cost to be slightly less for Cox than Verizon if
you use the bundled service of each
Cox Cable service and system reliability is as good or better.
This report is based on five years of Verizon and four months of Cox Cable.
Maybe after five years of Cox I might have a different opinion.
On 3/15/08, Stephen Brownfield [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
All this cable/DSL talk got me wondering: Is DSL any more secure/safer
than cable or vis-a-versa?
Tom Piwowar wrote:
I never knock the competition. All I can say is that in Verizon
territory, you pay for 3 mbps, you get 3 mbps, or a reasonable
facsimile.
That has been my experience with Verizon DSL.
I'm puzzled why Mike is so anti science. Knowing how something really
works means that you can figure out how it will work, even under
conditions that have not yet been experienced. With Mike's observational
approach the best one can ever say is So far go good. Observation
brought us astrology, science brought us astronomy. Etc., etc.
I agree with Mike that certain companies tend to underperform and that
such compalies should be avoided until there is evidence of improvement.
But that has nothing to do with the choice of DSL vs cable. Such a
company would be a poor performer regardless of the technology they
employed.
*
** List info, subscription management, list rules, archives,
privacy **
** policy, calmness, a member map, and more at http://www.cguys.org/
**
*
*
** List info, subscription management, list rules, archives, privacy **
** policy, calmness, a member map, and more at http://www.cguys.org/ **
*
*
** List info, subscription management, list rules, archives, privacy **
** policy, calmness, a member map, and more at http://www.cguys.org/ **
*