Re: GNU make and VPATH problems

2004-02-12 Thread Jonathan Hudgins
Pete Flugstad peteflugstad at mchsi.com writes:

 
 Greetings,
 
  I just recently started having a problem with GNU make.  I believe
 it's related to VPATH, but I'm not sure.  The weird part is that I think 
 it just recently started happening after I ran the cygwin update (which 
 did not update GNU make).  
 The crypto lib has a lot of files 
 (370+), spread out over probably 30+ sub-dirs.  I setup the directory 
 structure to have a GNUmakefile at the top level, with a src/ directory 
 with all the crypto sources in it and an obj/ directory where I want all 
 the .o's built.  I setup the makefile to use all relative paths using 
 '/' as a seperator.  I setup a VPATH to refer to all the source dirs, 
 again, just simple unix style paths, no spaces, or weird DOS characters. 

I have had a similar problem on my project.  It seems to work on some 
machines at my company and not others.  At this point I think it might have
something to do with which OS (ie XP vs 2k, with it not working on XP).  I
will try running a debug build as well.

I am really curious if this has been logged as a bug against gnu make.

Jonathan


--
Unsubscribe info:  http://cygwin.com/ml/#unsubscribe-simple
Problem reports:   http://cygwin.com/problems.html
Documentation: http://cygwin.com/docs.html
FAQ:   http://cygwin.com/faq/



Re: GNU make and VPATH problems

2004-01-22 Thread Pete Flugstad
Pete Flugstad wrote:
   So, before I start trying to debug GNU make, has anyone seen anything 
like this?  I'll work on recreating the problem with a simplified setup, 
so I can post an example here, but I'm hoping someones seen this before.
Getting no response, I downloaded the GNU make 3.80-1 sources from:

  http://mirrors.kernel.org/sources.redhat.com/cygwin/release/make/

and do a configure/build with -g.   And it works just fine.  No problem 
finding the source files in VPATH.

Just to make sure, I compared my binary /usr/bin/make.exe to the one 
from the .tar.bz2 file downloaded from the above URL, and they were 
identical.

Seems like maybe an GCC optimization bug somewhere, which my debug build 
doesn't trigger?

Pete

--
Unsubscribe info:  http://cygwin.com/ml/#unsubscribe-simple
Problem reports:   http://cygwin.com/problems.html
Documentation: http://cygwin.com/docs.html
FAQ:   http://cygwin.com/faq/


GNU make and VPATH problems

2004-01-21 Thread Pete Flugstad
Greetings,

I just recently started having a problem with GNU make.  I believe
it's related to VPATH, but I'm not sure.  The weird part is that I think 
it just recently started happening after I ran the cygwin update (which 
did not update GNU make).  I checked the mailing list archvies and I 
don't see anything that seems relevant/related.

For various reasons, I have created a GNUmakefile to build the 
OpenSSL crytpo lib using the Tornado (vxWorks) tools (gcc based 
basically) on Windows 2000 SP3.  The crypto lib has a lot of files 
(370+), spread out over probably 30+ sub-dirs.  I setup the directory 
structure to have a GNUmakefile at the top level, with a src/ directory 
with all the crypto sources in it and an obj/ directory where I want all 
the .o's built.  I setup the makefile to use all relative paths using 
'/' as a seperator.  I setup a VPATH to refer to all the source dirs, 
again, just simple unix style paths, no spaces, or weird DOS characters. 
 Here's the VPATH:

VPATH = src:src/asn1:src/bf:src/bio:src/cast:src/comp:src/bn:\
src/conf:src/des:src/dh:src/dsa:src/dso:src/err:\
src/evp:src/hmac:src/lhash:src/md2:src/md4:src/buffer:\
src/md5:src/mdc2:src/objects:src/pem:src/pkcs12:src/pkcs7:\
src/rand:src/rc2:src/rc4:src/ripemd:src/rsa:\
src/sha:src/stack:src/x509:src/x509v3:src/misc
I would normally just use the make that comes with Tornado (ver
3.74), and that generally works just fine, except a couple of the build
steps require some shell scripting that doesn't work with command.com.
So I have been runing GNU make under cygwin for this step, which up 
until a recently has been just fine.

  Now however, after and update to cygwin, when I run cygwin GNU make, 
it acts like it can't seem to find some of the dirs in the VPATH, 
complaining that it has no rule to build the required object files. 
However, it finds .c files in the peer directories just fine.  And 
moving the problem directories around in the VPATH doesn't help either. 
 It's like it thinks that the VPATH directive doesn't apply to those 
directories, or it can't find them.

  The exact same makefile on Linux with GNU make 3.80 works just fine. 
 The same setup with the Tornago GNU make 3.74 works just fine (except 
for the steps that require the shell scripting).

  As a quick example, one of the problem directories is src/bn.  I 
ran GNU make with -dd for a .c file in the src/bss dir (which works 
fine) and for a .c file in a problem dir.  Here's when it's looking for 
the good one:

Considering target file `obj/bss_log.o'.
 File `obj/bss_log.o' does not exist.
 Looking for an implicit rule for `obj/bss_log.o'.
 Trying pattern rule with stem `bss_log'.
 Trying implicit prerequisite `bss_log.c'.
 Found prerequisite `bss_log.c' as VPATH `src/bio/bss_log.c'
 Trying rule prerequisite `algo_defines.h'.
 Found prerequisite `algo_defines.h' as VPATH `src/algo_defines.h'
And here's one where the src/bn directory seems to not be found, even 
though it's in my VPATH:

Considering target file `obj/bn_add.o'.
 File `obj/bn_add.o' does not exist.
 Looking for an implicit rule for `obj/bn_add.o'.
 Trying pattern rule with stem `bn_add'.
 Trying implicit prerequisite `bn_add.c'.
 Trying pattern rule with stem `bn_add'.
 Trying implicit prerequisite `obj/bn_add.c'.
 Trying pattern rule with stem `bn_add'.
  so src/bn and src/bss are both on there (I've tried moving src/bn 
around, it doesn't matter).  The .c files are in those directories, but 
it finds one, but not the other.  The other problem dirs are src/dso, 
src/md5 and src/rc4.  These seem consistent, regardless of where I put 
them in the VPATH.

  I've checked the permissionns on these directories, and they are all 
identical.  I'm actually mounting the whole tree from a Linux box using 
a samba share, and mapping that to a drive letter.  And as I noted 
above, the same GNUmakefile on the Linux system works just fine.  All 
the permissions on the Linux dirs are identical and they all appear 
identical on the Windows box.

  So, before I start trying to debug GNU make, has anyone seen anything 
like this?  I'll work on recreating the problem with a simplified setup, 
so I can post an example here, but I'm hoping someones seen this before.

Thanks,
Pete


--
Unsubscribe info:  http://cygwin.com/ml/#unsubscribe-simple
Problem reports:   http://cygwin.com/problems.html
Documentation: http://cygwin.com/docs.html
FAQ:   http://cygwin.com/faq/