Bug#1029101: Acknowledgement (fontconfig-config: 2.14.1 upload breaks testSimpleText of libreoffice)
Hi, Am 19.01.23 um 12:46 schrieb Andreas Henriksson: I'd like to explicitly ask if you still want me to upload any fontconfig change ASAP or if downgrading severity means you think it can/should wait until after release? worked around it in libreoffice for now, so your decision in the end. As I understand the situation something related to subpixel rendering has changed between 2.13.x and 2.14.1. Debian offers debconf choices "Automatic", "Always" and "Never" for which settings to use in /etc/fonts/conf.d/$SYMLINK which are related to the problem you're reporting. Fedora on the other hand seems to use "always/only on KDE" (with no alternatives) as far as I understand the commit you pointed out. Does that mean we should: - offer an additional alternative /or/ patch "Always"? - make then new/patched alternative the default? - get rid of debconf alternatives and provide one consistent configuration for all users? I'd vote for the latter, the deconf thingy is confusing and leads to problems like this if stuff assumes behaviour Unless we do the last option, wouldn't it mean any (test) failures still happen if the user uses any of the other options? (Which would suggest this is not actually a bug on the fontconfig side to me.) Probably. Maybe just do what upstreams default is? (Whatever that is). Or sync with other distros which so far had no problems (aka the patch I linked), so it's at least consistent between distros. Fedora actually (as one can see in the linked RH bug) did an update to released Fedora versions to add that ... and TTBOMK Abira TAGOH is also fontconfig upstream? In the mail where you tagged this patch you suggested to edit the subpixel config file which makes me think you're using the Always alternative, but as I understand the debconf code Automatic is the (current) default... Can't be. The buildds (and also my buildd chroot) does not get any debconf prompt (noninteractive frontend) so default is what I pasted - without the If you think you have a clear picture of exactly what should happen (on the fontconfig side) then I would very much appreciate if you could either send a salsa MR or just NMU (and I'll make sure to import the NMU-diff into the fontconfig packaging repo). Unfortunately not, I just try to fix the FTBFS ;) Regards, Rene
Bug#1029101: Acknowledgement (fontconfig-config: 2.14.1 upload breaks testSimpleText of libreoffice)
Hello Rene Engelhard, On Tue, Jan 17, 2023 at 07:23:17PM +0100, Rene Engelhard wrote: > severity 1029101 important > retitle 1029101 please Enable RGB stripes layout for sub-pixel rendering on > KDE only > thanks > > [ sorry for "spamming" ] [...] Thanks for taking the time to report and follow up on this! Sorry for the wall of text below. I have to admit I'm having a bit of trouble following everything, possibly because of my lack of knowledge in several areas. I'd like to explicitly ask if you still want me to upload any fontconfig change ASAP or if downgrading severity means you think it can/should wait until after release? As I understand the situation something related to subpixel rendering has changed between 2.13.x and 2.14.1. Debian offers debconf choices "Automatic", "Always" and "Never" for which settings to use in /etc/fonts/conf.d/$SYMLINK which are related to the problem you're reporting. Fedora on the other hand seems to use "always/only on KDE" (with no alternatives) as far as I understand the commit you pointed out. Does that mean we should: - offer an additional alternative /or/ patch "Always"? - make then new/patched alternative the default? - get rid of debconf alternatives and provide one consistent configuration for all users? Unless we do the last option, wouldn't it mean any (test) failures still happen if the user uses any of the other options? (Which would suggest this is not actually a bug on the fontconfig side to me.) In the mail where you tagged this patch you suggested to edit the subpixel config file which makes me think you're using the Always alternative, but as I understand the debconf code Automatic is the (current) default... If you think you have a clear picture of exactly what should happen (on the fontconfig side) then I would very much appreciate if you could either send a salsa MR or just NMU (and I'll make sure to import the NMU-diff into the fontconfig packaging repo). As of right now I'm considering removing the patch tag as the exact change needed here is still unclear to me. (but thanks alot for pin-pointing the problematic area!) Regards, Andreas Henriksson
Bug#1029101: Acknowledgement (fontconfig-config: 2.14.1 upload breaks testSimpleText of libreoffice)
severity 1029101 important retitle 1029101 please Enable RGB stripes layout for sub-pixel rendering on KDE only thanks [ sorry for "spamming" ] Hi, Am 17.01.23 um 19:04 schrieb Rene Engelhard: it still fails. Probably it ignores it since it's already set in /etc and that already matches? OK, got it. I need to "delete" it. mode="delete">rgb Then it passes and it shouldn't break with 2.13 either since deleting somethng non-existing works ;-) Will reassign a clone to libreoffice to fix that test failure. Regards, Rene
Bug#1029101: Acknowledgement (fontconfig-config: 2.14.1 upload breaks testSimpleText of libreoffice)
Hi again, Am 17.01.23 um 18:28 schrieb Rene Engelhard: I tried to adapt the test to expected values but failed. When I adapt some values stuff even further breaks, and at the 50% test I then had no idea what to do.) LO has already a fc_local.conf: ./instdir/share/fonts/truetype/fc_local.conf but when I add the stuff from the patch there rene@frodo:~/Debian/Pakete/LibreOffice/libreoffice/libreoffice-7.4.4.2$ cat ./instdir/share/fonts/truetype/fc_local.conf Symbol OpenSymbol KDE mode="append">rgb it still fails. Probably it ignores it since it's already set in /etc and that already matches? Regards, Rene
Bug#1029101: Acknowledgement (fontconfig-config: 2.14.1 upload breaks testSimpleText of libreoffice)
Hi, addendum: I tried to adapt the test to expected values but failed. When I adapt some values stuff even further breaks, and at the 50% test I then had no idea what to do.) For reference, this is the test: https://cgit.freedesktop.org/libreoffice/core/tree/vcl/qa/cppunit/text.cxx?h=libreoffice-7.4.4.2#n164 ff. Regards, Rene
