Bug#456411: cs89x0 driver in etherboot

2008-03-18 Thread Jan Lübbe
Hello Russ,

Your driver for the cs89x0 network card is used in the etherboot
package. The copyright/license statements are a bit problematic for
Debian as cs89x0.h file states This program is free software; you can
redistribute it and/or modify it under the terms of the GNU General
Public License as published by the Free Software Foundation, version 1.

This license statement is currently also in the Linux kernel source
(which makes it incompatible to the rest of Linux).

This license makes it incompatible with the rest of etherboot which is
GPLv2.

cs89x0.c states: Permission is granted to distribute the enclosed
cs89x0.[ch] driver only in conjunction with the Etherboot package.  The
code is ordinarily distributed under the GPL.

Could you please clarify what you mean by only in conjunction with the
Etherboot package, as this conflicts with the GPL.

Would you be willing to relicense your contributions under the GPLv2
without additional restrictions?

-- 
Jan Lübbe [EMAIL PROTECTED]http://sicherheitsschwankung.de
 gpg-key  1024D/D8480F2E 2002-03-20
 fingerprint  1B25 F91F 9E7B 5D4F 1282  02D6 8A83 8BE4 D848 0F2E




Bug#456411: cs89x0 driver in etherboot

2008-03-18 Thread Russ Nelson
As copyright holder, if I say it doesn't conflict with the GPL, then
it doesn't conflict with the GPL.

However, there's no point in causing people's brains to overheat, so
yes, I grant permission for the code to be relicensed under the
GPLv2.  Please make sure that this change in licensing makes its way
upstream.
-russ

Jan Lübbe writes:
  
  Hello Russ,
  
  Your driver for the cs89x0 network card is used in the etherboot
  package. The copyright/license statements are a bit problematic for
  Debian as cs89x0.h file states This program is free software; you can
  redistribute it and/or modify it under the terms of the GNU General
  Public License as published by the Free Software Foundation, version 1.
  
  This license statement is currently also in the Linux kernel source
  (which makes it incompatible to the rest of Linux).
  
  This license makes it incompatible with the rest of etherboot which is
  GPLv2.
  
  cs89x0.c states: Permission is granted to distribute the enclosed
  cs89x0.[ch] driver only in conjunction with the Etherboot package.  The
  code is ordinarily distributed under the GPL.
  
  Could you please clarify what you mean by only in conjunction with the
  Etherboot package, as this conflicts with the GPL.
  
  Would you be willing to relicense your contributions under the GPLv2
  without additional restrictions?
  
  -- 
  Jan Lübbe [EMAIL PROTECTED]http://sicherheitsschwankung.de
   gpg-key  1024D/D8480F2E 2002-03-20
   fingerprint  1B25 F91F 9E7B 5D4F 1282  02D6 8A83 8BE4 D848 0F2E