Bug#828069: 3 more random crashes

2016-09-13 Thread Carsten Schoenert
On Tue, Sep 13, 2016 at 03:49:15PM +0300, Vassilis Virvilis wrote:
> On 09/13/2016 03:38 PM, Carsten Schoenert wrote:
> > Hello Vassilis,
> > 
> > please append such reports on the bugreport. Offline working people are
> > unable to get such pastes.
> 
> ok attached. I didn't know it is considered bad practice. I saw it somewhere
> and looked cool.

All related information has to be gone into the bug reporting system. As
systems like etherpad oder paste.foo are heavely relaying on a online
service bug reports become useless if parts of the reports are not
reachable. 

> > BTW: You also mixed up a different version than the thread subject is
> > talking about ... it's importend to know which versions report are
> > talking about. The compiler and some flags are different than in
> > unstable.
> > 
> 
> All bug reports are on debian unstable/experimental. There are 3 different
> crashes and it wasn't feeling right to create 3 bug reports (I had already
> created one) when there is this bug report about random crashes. A cursory
> overview on this bug reveals many posted crashdumps. So I thought I could
> add 3 more here. I tried to see if they are the same but that was a lot of
> work actually since I am not familiar with thunderbird codebase.

You need a widther look ;), the original starting report was about issues
in stable-security. You talking about unstable/testing. This are since
the GCC6 switch completely different worlds. So it's mostly impratical
to try to compare booth releases. And we need a lot of time to jump
between different bug report about propably the same issue and
coordinate those with upstream reported bug reports.

We may know a bit more about the codebase of Icedove/Thunderbird, but we
are also fare away from a deep knowledge about to catch the segfaults.

Regards
Carsten



Bug#828069: 3 more random crashes

2016-09-13 Thread Carsten Schoenert
Hello Vassilis,

please append such reports on the bugreport. Offline working people are
unable to get such pastes.

On Tue, Sep 13, 2016 at 02:25:48PM +0300, Vassilis Virvilis wrote:
> 3 more random crashes
> 
> version: icedove-gdb-45.2.0-4_2016-08-31_17:09:38.log
> desc: crash during compact of local folder - not reproducible
> location: nsDisplayList::DeleteAll
> note: This has been reported individually by me as #836319
> backtrace: http://paste.debian.net/820610
> 
> version: icedove-gdb-45.2.0-4+b1_2016-09-06_09:49:49.log
> desc: crash not sure how or when - not reproducible
> location:  ~nsCOMPtr destructor
> backtrace: http://paste.debian.net/820633/
> 
> version: icedove-gdb-45.2.0-4+b1_2016-09-13_10:06:56.log
> desc: crash clicked on unviewed e-mail - not reproducible
> location:   nsPresContext::PropertyTable
> backtrace: http://paste.debian.net/820635/

BTW: You also mixed up a different version than the thread subject is
talking about ... it's importend to know which versions report are
talking about. The compiler and some flags are different than in
unstable.

Regards
Carsten



Bug#828069: 3 more random crashes

2016-09-13 Thread Vassilis Virvilis

3 more random crashes

version: icedove-gdb-45.2.0-4_2016-08-31_17:09:38.log
desc: crash during compact of local folder - not reproducible
location: nsDisplayList::DeleteAll
note: This has been reported individually by me as #836319
backtrace: http://paste.debian.net/820610

version: icedove-gdb-45.2.0-4+b1_2016-09-06_09:49:49.log
desc: crash not sure how or when - not reproducible
location:  ~nsCOMPtr destructor
backtrace: http://paste.debian.net/820633/

version: icedove-gdb-45.2.0-4+b1_2016-09-13_10:06:56.log
desc: crash clicked on unviewed e-mail - not reproducible
location:   nsPresContext::PropertyTable
backtrace: http://paste.debian.net/820635/

   Vassilis Virvilis